Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Doggonit!

Posts

Doggonit!

#1

Doggonit!

Carole Valentine

>This is not the first time I have had this happen and the kicker is it ONLY appears after the first coat of oil is applied. It is nearly impossible to sand out. This piece was finish scraped to the point that it really didn't need sanding at all and then sanded to within an inch of it's life because I wanted it baby-butt smooth inside. No perceptable imperfections even in bright sunlight UNTIL the oil hit it. Then the blasted ring appeared. Tt is always about the diameter of the chuck jaws. It only seems to happen on pieces that are turned fairly thin. It almost looks like a bruising where the tool passed over the jaws. It is not tearout. Can anyone tell me what I am doing wrong and how to avoid this on thin pieces????


img

Re: Doggonit!

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: Doggonit!

Brad Vietje

>Hi Carole,

That stinks ! Its a very pretty piece, and I hope you can find a way to get the ring out -- maybe Woolite ?

I have gotten similar rings when reverse turning between centers to turn the chuck marks away, but in my case, the rings are bruising of the wood fibers where the wooden disk or donut driving the thing compressed the wood fibers inside the bowl.

Does this ring feature match the size of your tenon ? Do you think you could be crushing the fibers a bit by gripping too tightly ? Another question that occurs is if this was turned initially in green wood from a species with tannins that darkened from exposure to the iron content of the jaws ? Is there similar discoloration on the outside ? I'm wondering if some discoloration was down inside the wood, but not visible after the foot was re-shaped, and only shows up when a bowl is thin enough that the inside bottom is within some small "staining radius" of the jaws.

In other words, I really have no clue, but I hope you can find a good answer !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Doggonit!

#3

Re: Doggonit!

Carole Valentine

>Hi Brad,

The wood was turned from dry Pear and there was no evidence on the tenon of reaction. The shape of the rings almost exactly reflect the circumference of the top surface of the jaws. It really looks like a brise but I can't seem to prevent it except by leaving the base of the pieces a little thicker. Now I am wondering if I can use gesso on the interior after that coat of oil has completely cured?

Oh and in case anyone is wondering, the black rim was my first experiment with my little Roburn micro-torch. It sits about 1/32" proud. I like the torch.

Re: Doggonit!

#4

Re: Doggonit!

Bob Fawcett

>I am certainly not one to give advise on this, but that won't stop me. Did you use a vacuum chuck?

Seems I saw another thread with a similar ring the size of the vacuum chuck.

Re: Doggonit!

#5

Re: Doggonit!

Carole Valentine

>Hi Bob,

No vacuum chuck. Just a large padded jam chuck. Didn't even contact the bottom where the ring is.

Re: Doggonit!

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: Doggonit!

Brad Vietje

>Carole -- just an idea...

Maybe your second use of your torch could be to burn a small ring in the bottom of the bowl that would turn the ring into a real bold statement ? Might be really pretty to have a black ring around a gold foil center or something, but that would totally change the look & feel of the piece.

Just a thought ...

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Doggonit!

#7

Re Doggonit

Mike Nelson

>Carole, I have had a ring show up from friction when a padded jam chuck spun against the bowl. Also from vacuum chucking where moisture was pulled through. Nice bowl, I need one of those burning pen kits. sure are expensive though.

Re: Doggonit!

#8

Don Pencil

Re: Doggonit!

Don Pencil

>Is that area of the foot thicker?

The thicker wood will retain a little more water than the thin areas even in some dry wood.

Then the oil shows the moister.

Don

Re: Doggonit!

#9

Re: Doggonit!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Whaa! Carole, I've honestly not experienced this? Of course my stuff is rarely turned thin, thin. It looks like a really lovely bowl. I hope you can get rid of the ring. I'm not sure about using gesso over oil?

Jen

Re: Doggonit!

#10

Re: Doggonit!

Carole Valentine

>Hmmm...it probably corresponded to the outside edge of the tenon before I finished the foot. As you can see, the ring is not perfectly round, which reflects some wood movement between the time I finish turned the inside and the time I finished the foot (which IS perfectly round) Had not thought about moisture. The cool surface of the jaws where they contacted the wood could have prevented that one little strip from losing moisture at the same rate as the rest of the wood. I suppose. If it was a matter of foot thickness, I would think the entire foot area would reflect that, not just a narrow ring. My other thought is maybe I am somehow tightening the jaws too much and on a thin piece they are pulling the wood fibers around the edge of the tenon?

Re: Doggonit!

#11

Richard Allen

Re: Doggonit!

Richard Allen

>Hi Carol

I think you nailed it. I think it's directly related to the sholder of the tennon. I usualy cut the sholder of my tennon with wide parting tool (often times called a beading parting tool). This cutting acts primarly as a scraper and does pull fibers (which might be considered brused). When I know I will be making a thin bottom I will cut the sholder with a couple of gouges, the last cut being with a 1/4" spindle gouge to make the corner at the tennon/sholder sharp.

The whole idea being o make finishing cuts while forming the tennon. Sometimes I will put a coat of shelac on the sholder before mounting in the chuck.

Re: Doggonit!

#12

Re: Doggonit!

georgetroy

>I wonder what a hot damp rag would do to that ring. Pear is splotchy and can show wear areas especially if the moisture content is different. Perhaps wait a few days and you can resand. Who knows? GT

Re: Doggonit!

#13

Re: Doggonit!

Russ Fairfield

>There is not an easy answer because there are several possibilities.

Pear is a wood that bruises easily from turning, sanding, and gripping. In that respect, it is similar to Box Elder. Both can be a problem.

I would suspect 4 things that could have happened. I have encountered all of them. They are all encouraged by a slightly higher moisture content in the bottom area of the wood, or a thin area across the bottom. And, sometimes they reinforce each other.

These things are a reason for using Mineral Spirits or wax to wet the wood after sanding and before finishing. The wetness accents these things so you can see them, and remove them before sealing them into the wood forever with a finish.

My 1st suspicion would be pressure from the jamb-chuck when you turned the bottom.

The 2nd would be compression of the wood from holding it in the cuuck. A longer tenon and less pressure will reduce this. Make the tenon a more pronounced dove-tail shape so it grips on the end of the tenon before the base next to the shoulder. This is a good reason for using the chuck in expansion in a recess. The compression is transferred outward into the larger outer area of the bowl and there is less chance of bruising. It appears that this shape would have allowed that.

My 3rd is that wood was bruised by rubbing the heel of the bevel too long and too hard in one place as you were turning the inside, and never removed all of the bruised wood with sanding. This will happen more easily in a thin piece because there is some flexing of the wood across the tenon area. This one is the most difficult to find because you never see it until the piece is sanded to something greater than 400-grit. Remove the sharp edge at the heel of the bevel with the grinder, and use less inward pressure on the tool as you "glide" the cutting edge across the bottom of the bowl.

My 4th is that the ring is from holding the sandpaper in one place to long while the wood was spinning. This is easy to do if the piece is very thin and there is some flexure across the chucking tenon. The heat from sanding case-hardens the wood in the ring, or it could be a stain from the adhesive from using wet/dry sandpaper. The solution is to run the lathe slower, run the power sander slower, don't let the sandpaper get hot, and sanding at the finer grits with the lathe not spinning the wood.

Which one of these is the cause?? It could be any one of them, or ir could be all of them. Keep spinning wood, and you will figure it out one day.

Re: Doggonit!

#14

Re: Doggonit!

Hooligan

>I've had that too, and I don't know what it is for certain, but more and more, I am led to believe that we bruise the wood just enough for it to be a problem. Its irritating as heck, I know. It obly happens on light woods, for me.

Re: Doggonit!

#15

Re: Doggonit!

John Veerkamp

>I second Russ's observation that pear is very easily bruised. It can be from the sanding or from pressure from your hollowing between the tool on the inside and the chuck on the outside. Very frustrating!! I think the heat building up inside the wood permanently changes the color. I've never had any success in removing the discoloration. Myybe as Brad suggested, time to accentuate the ring with burning.

John

Re: Doggonit!

#16

Re: Doggonit!

Russ Fairfield

>I hope you got the bottom line of my message.

Hold the wood with the chuck jaws expanding in a recess using a light grip just enough to hold it, make light cuts with a sharp tool and no pressure on the wood, and sand slowly to avoid heat. That is the best you can do to avoid the problem.

It happens in some dark woods as well, it is just harder to see. Cherry can be bad, and it shows up as the wood darkens with age.

Re: Doggonit!

#17

Re: Doggonit!

Carole Valentine

>Thank you, Russ, for a most comprehensive response. I think I have narrowed it down to #2. It would not have been the jam chuck because the one I used never touches the bottom of the bowl and I can't believe it is from sanding because my sander is in constant motion, never resting in one area. As for the gouge bevel, I used the Sorby Multi tool for the majority of the hollowing (first the cutter then the teardrop scraper in the final stages) so I don't think that was it. I have never had the problem with a piece on which I used a recess rather than a tenon, so your comment about that gives me much food for thought! I did not use the wax on this piece because I had nothing that I "thought" needed it, but as you said, had I used it, I would have seen the problem before sealing it forever with oil. :( I am sort of glad this happened...it spurred me to finally ask questions and now I know what sort of thing to be careful of to try and prevent it in the future. If I can't cure this piece, it looks like the only option will be to shellac the inside then use gesso. I don't know if gesso would adhere to cured oil, but I have heard that shellac will stick to anything and that anything will stick to shellac!

Re: Doggonit!

#18

Re: Doggonit!

Stephen Mushinski

>Thanks for the question Carole, and the answer Russ! I have seen this on my work a few times and wondered also. Mostly on Cherry. Now I will try some knowledge to avoid it in the future.

Re: Doggonit!

#19

Re: Doggonit!

Allen Neighbors

>Can't say anything to help about the ring. But I sure do like the bowl. Really nice. Like the rim treatment, too.

Allen

Re: Doggonit!

#20

Re: Doggonit!

Duane C.Leach

>Another reason for the ring may be stain from the steel of the chuck. Some wet wood stains easily when it is in contact with the steel cuuck while turning.

Duane

Re: Doggonit!

#21

Thanks everyone!

Carole Valentine

>I think I have learned enough to develop an avoidance strategy. There really is no place like WC! :)

Re: Doggonit!

#22

Re: Thanks everyone!

Scott Hogsten

>Sorry to follow onto the tail end of this but I have one other thought about this. I've seen this effect on thin pieces due to flexing and brusing of the fibers during sanding. Here's what happens you get the piece thin but the piece is still well supported at the tenon. You start sanding/scraping and introduce flex and vibration because of the thiness. However,, because the tenon area is well support the fibers of the wood are flexed and stressed at the tenon resulting in a bruise like effect. So long story short keep pressure light and make sure that you aren't introducing a lot of flex/vibration.

Scott

Re: Doggonit!

#23

Keith Tompkins

Re: Doggonit!

Keith Tompkins

>CArole, a glueblock will solve many problems caused by the chuck...just turn it away when finished. Looks like damage caused by the chuck or torn fibers on the outer surface.