Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

A question of Balance

Posts

A question of Balance

#1

A question of Balance

Steve in NC

>Hey WC friends

I have been on the road for the better part of four months so between being dad and the usual assortment of household chores I have had little time to turn (or post). Today however, a neighbor dropped several fresh cut logs in my driveway. It looks like poplar or holly but it has a very dark (almost purple) pith. I just could not resist.

The most interesting piece is a crotch near the bottom of the trunk where two 8� logs came off. There is a dark area at the center of each trunk about 3� diameter and some nice concentric coloring. It makes me think about turning an end grain double bowl with each of the bowls centered on one of the pith areas.

I cut a 3� thick slab right at the crotch (8" x 16") and sealed it. I am planning to glue a waste block and attach a faceplate to turn each bowl. My question is this. There will be a huge imbalance as I turn each bowl. Is there any way to counterbalance the eccentricity so my lathe does not walk across the room as I try to turn? (Or more simply, am I crazy to even try this.)

Thanks for your comments.

Re: A question of Balance

#2

Re: A question of Balance

Chuck Engstrom

>HI Steve -- I made up a balancer plate once to deal with this sort of thing, see photo. It's just a thin plate of steel with holes around the perimeter for bolts, washers, nuts as needed. In this photo it's held on the spindle with a nut since I was using a spur drive; it could just as well be between the spindle flange and the rear end of a chuck. Others have made similar devices with wood and tire weights, etc.

Find the heavy side of the workpiece. If you can, release the drive belt from your headstock drive and let the piece free-wheel on the bearings alone; the heavy side will of course rotate to the bottom. Add bolts and nuts till the problem diminishes to a tolerable level.

Be careful that whatver you cobble together will stay together during prolonged rotation and not come flying off to cause damage or injury.

Best --

Chuck Engstrom


img

Re: A question of Balance

#3

Re: A question of Balance

TDRice

>Chuck,

I've been turning lots of out of balance pieces and trying to minimize vibration by adjusting speed but mostly just tolerating it. That is a great idea and, like so many great ideas, obvious once someone points it out. I'll be using it and I hope you can feel the blessings being heaped on your head as I do so.

Terence

Re: A question of Balance

#4

another way to do it...

TDaniel

>I use a very heavy faceplate, (think flywheel). Mine is 12" diameter and about 7/8" thick. It really smooths out those out of balance pieces. You could also add some weights to it if needed. With either of these you may be limited to how deep (tall) you can go as the weight at one end does not necessarily balance the other end. Have fun! Trying new things is what makes this hobby interesting.

Re: A question of Balance

#5

Re: A question of Balance

Steve in NC

>Thanks for the ideas. I am going to give this a try and I will post if successful.

Re: A question of Balance

#6

Steve, It Sounds As If You Have Tulip Poplar.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>That purple will turn brown but still look great.

Re: A question of Balance

#7

Re: Steve, It Sounds As If You Have Tulip Poplar.

Steve in NC

>Barbara

Thanks for the info. Is the purple an indication of age or bugs. It is in some logs and not others.

Hopefully I will be able to keep this piece from shaking itself apart.

Steve

Re: A question of Balance

#8

Re: Steve, It Sounds As If You Have Tulip Poplar.

Hooligan

>If its the same, its also known as black poplar, which is a mineral stain. It can be in large sections of a tree, or small areas. It really varies.

Re: A question of Balance

#9

Re: Steve, It Sounds As If You Have Tulip Poplar.

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>I am at work right now; no book to check. Can't say I have ever heard of Black Poplar. Tulip Poplar is also known as Yellow Poplar. The various colors in Tulip Poplar are usually from mineral influence. The heartwood usually has a greenish cast when first cut. Tulip Poplar spalts nicely.

Re: A question of Balance

#10

loggers here call it....

TDaniel

>Black hearted poplar or lightning struck poplar. Many of these black hearted poplars are struck by lightning. My theory is that the black is caused by iron in the soil and usually these trees are near a spring or stream making them a lightning rod. I think the conditions that create the black draws the lightning instead of the lightning causing the black. But what do I know....:)