Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

Posts

Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#1

Andy DiPietro

Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

Andy DiPietro

>I posted the first HF in the picture on Thursday Night. Since then Dinyar, myself and Russ have been debating via email on which form is our favorite. Russ suggested to open this conversation up to everyone. So please send your comments. The first and second piece were cut from the same log section. Russ please submit your email comments on form.

Thanks


img

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#2

Andy DiPietro

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC2 

Andy DiPietro

>


img

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#3

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

georgetroy

>I like the one in the middle best. Walnut is my favorite wood. Natural edge hollow form is ok and you have done a good job with them. GT

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#4

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC2

Russ Fairfield

>I got into a private conversation with Dinyar and Andy about the piece he posted. The reason for my original comments was because I didn't agree with all iof the nice things thaqt were said about this piece. I agree that it was "nice", but with a little work, it could be "excellent". The following is copy of my e-mail:

Since you asked, and I am awake at 1:30AM with nothing else to do....... here goes.

NOTE:

All that follows is just one guy's opinion that might be somewhat different if I were able to hold this in my hands. Ask somebody else and you will get a different opinion.

This vessel form is one of the most difficult to get right. We can usually get close enough that it is "nice", but rarely "exquisite". If you made 50 of them that were identical, there would be only 1 or 2 that stood out from the crowd. People who are known for these forms have made a lot of mistakes that never got past the shop door, and even then, they don't get it right every time.

These are one of those forms where it is difficult to judge what we have while it is in the horizontal position on the lathe. As a minimum, taking it out of the lathe and sitting it upright on the table where we can look at it for a couple days is good. Taking a photo is even better because we can make a print and manipulate it around a bit or take a marking pen to it.

The original is "nice" but there are a few things I would like to see different. Each of its separate elements are good by themselves, but they don't quite fit together, and there are some conflicting messages.

The basic form is defined by the large global area of white sap wood in that view. The upper body continues that "global" form. Everything else should be in keeping with this same theme. The problem is that it doesn't quite do that. The long tapered lower section to the small foot suggests a taller more delicate form, and that doesn't fit with what is above it. Think of a fat lady with skinny ankles and tiny feet. She looks out of proportion and uncomfortable.

I would shorten the form to continue the "global" line to a more rounded bottom shape. That would cut the darker part of the form to about 2/3 its present height. That small foot could now to tucked under the rounded bottom and it would appear to be floating just above the table, and not sitting on it like it does now.

One of the problems with this form in general is that the foot is plainly visible and anchors it to the table, and that is a difficult one to deal with.

The large natural edge is a separate feature that is well done, but it looks out of place to me because it is in competition with the larger and more voluptious "global" form for my attention. The natural edge would be the dominant feature if the white were not there and the form were a solid brown. One way to remove that competition would be to dye the sapwood.

Natural edges are like finials. They are difficult to work into a design. Personally, I always ask myself the question - "Does it add anything to the form?" That answer can change from day to day.

If I am thinking that there is elegance in simplicity that day, the answer will be "No", and it is gone. In that case the rim would be at the top of the white separation line in Dinyar's rendition.

The answer could be "Yes", and then I would try to work with it. There was a conflict in size between the base and the neck of the original vase, but we removed that by shortening the vase and hiding the foot.

Short or tall is a matter of preference once the conflict with the base has been removed. My only problem with the original is that the shape of the stem under the rim is straight sided on what is otherwise a very curvaceous form. I would prefer a slightly concave curvature, but an ogee might be even better. Either way. I would make the neck smaller, but that might be a skill that Andy hasn't developed yet. Dinyar improved this line when he shortened the neck, but I think the original would look just as good with some curve under the rim.

I hope Andy doesn't mind my playing with his form in the middle of the night. Take it for what it is. The original is a fine piece of woodturning. I wish all of mine would come out that good.

----------------------------------------------------------------------

Written today:

Andy has done several of the things I was refering to in the e-mail with the other two pieces.

The one on the far right has been fattened and more rounded in the lower area. The foot is softer, and I think it looks better that way. There appears to be a foot that might look better if it were removed, and a small radius at the transition into the flat bottom.

The middle one really shows that the natural edge was a distraction on the original piece. This one has an elegance that was missing on the original.

The original (on the far left) looks much different in the side view. I might have had a different opinion of it had I seen this view first. The neck could be smaller, and the underside of the stem could be something other than a straight line, and the bottom could be more rounded; but I really like the "to Hell with design conventions" attitude about it. This one would be my choice of the 3, and I would always display it as shown in this last photo.

Feel free to disagree with everything I said.

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#5

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Andy,

My vote is for #1. The form is really set of by the differernce in color between the sapwood and heartwood. And I love natural edge hollow forms since they are the "best of two worlds" (so to speak).

I also like #2 because of it's simple, yet elegant lines

While it also is a natural edge HF, #3 doesn't do as much for me as the other two. Not sure if it's the size of the top in proportion to the body or what.

Later,

Dominic

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#6

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

Allen Neighbors

>I like the center one best of all three. Classy, beautiful. Second choice is the one on the left, in the second pic.

But then I'm sort of a traditional sort... of sorts... I think. :o)

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#7

JL

Re: Middle

JL

>The natural edge is a distraction on the one on the left. Sort of not in balance. The middle has a simplicity of form and function.

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#8

Middle one is my vote

Jake Niedling

>

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#9

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

Bob Fawcett

>I like the middle one best.

I would also like to thank Andy, Russ, and Dinyar for posting. This really helps a beginner like me to see what the discussion is all about. The pictures add so much.

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#10

The middle...

Blake Washburn

>one is my favorite because it has a nice shape and a great looking finish.

Blake Washburn

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#11

Re: Ditto!

Allen Neighbors

>

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

#12

Re: Walnut HF, Comment on your Favorite form PIC1

Ron in Drums PA

>In order that I like them 2 - 1 - 3