Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Collar issue?

Posts

Collar issue?

#1

Collar issue?

Hooligan

>Not sure that I like the collar on this. I didn't want to go dark with it, though. What I was shooting for, is somewhat an extension of the vessel itself, with a continuation of the curve. I wanted it to land just a bit under the lip of the vessel, though I am unsure of whether that was the right way to go about it.

It's spalted maple, finish is BLO and BriWax.

As well, pardon the photo quality, as that is something which I completely lack, as has been discussed previously.

Re: Collar issue?

#2

Pic would be good.... 

Hooligan

>


img

Re: Collar issue?

#3

Re: Collar issue?

Danny Wells (aka trumpetturner)

>Nice lines Hoo. I think you accomplished your goal. The collar is a nice extension of the lines.

Re: Collar issue?

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Pic would be good....

Keith Tompkins

>Not bad...not bad at all. Very simple, and in keeping with the form. The size of the collar may be a bit overpowering, reducing the dimensions, while keeping the same proportions, should help a bit, IMHO. Added color, even though you are trying to avoid it, will make the piece pop. A nice, reserved, collar, Hooligan.

Re: Collar issue?

#5

Re: Pic would be good....

Allen Neighbors

>Beautiful work! I also think the collar is a little large, but it surely does fit with the curvature. Thanks for posting.

Allen

Re: Collar issue?

#6

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Collar issue?

Leo Van Der Loo

>Pretty nice HF Hooligan, and now just my opinion on the collar OK?. collar is too coarse for the form (like bring the shoulder down some and make the curve going up a compound curve , steepen the last bit), grain difference makes it not look right while keeping the color the same on the collar as on the form, it shows that the collar is separate and accentuating would make it look better, still you did a good job, good finish too.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Collar issue?

#7

Re: Pic would be good....

Hooligan

>Thanks guys. I still have a hard time with collars on forms. Don't know why, but I do. Its something that I only recently started, too, collars. In the past, I haven't done anything, but left the openings, and finished that way, but I've seen sme that really make the form pop, like Keith said. I may pull that one, and stick a piece of bloodwood, or some redheart on it instead.

Thanks for the input.

Re: Collar issue?

#8

Brad Vietje

Re: Collar issue?

Brad Vietje

>I think I agree with Leo... the collar might be just a little too big (though that may be just what you intended), but the dramatic difference in grain & figure would work better if there were a bigger color contrast, too.

When I want the collar to mate or match the vessel, I just leave extra wood around the opening, then finish off the collar detail between centers after all hollowing is completed -- a one piece vessel with a distinct collar. That way the color and figure are a good (in this case, perfect) match. Otherwise, part off a piece of the same wood block, after marking it for orientation, and re-attach it later, as John Jordan does in his Hollow Turning video.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Collar issue?

#9

Re: Collar issue?

Hooligan

>Actually, I like that idea, Brad. Makes a lot of sense.

I was actually going for a "same but different" approach on the collar, as far as grain and orientation, but I didn't want to go dark with it. It appears, though, that it isn't quite different enough to set it off, and its not close enough to be similar. I was lookinng for that happy medium, and I didn't find it.Ah well, that's why they call it trial and error.