Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

I added a finial... what do you think?

Posts

I added a finial... what do you think?

#1

I added a finial... what do you think?

Blake Washburn

>I decided that I didn't like the plain hole in the middle so I made a finial and threw it on there. What do you think?

Blake Washburn


img

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

#2

Keith Tompkins

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Blake, nice piece. If I could make a suggestion or two, maybe your could integrate the finial into the overall scheme. A concace shape where the finial meets the lid would help accomplish this, I think. A thinner finial stem would help as well. Man, I wish I were at this level when I was your age!

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

#3

JL

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

JL

>Thinner definitely. Some other detail to bring it more in unison with the piece. Your marquetry is a nice touch - perhaps a contrast band on the finial that duplicates the color?

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

#4

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

john lucas

>Me too Keith. At his age I was an idiot. Good job Blake. I agree with Keith. I think finials should rarely be the same thickness. Usually they look better when they taper. I love thin finials. However on box lids you have to be careful because people will break them. I wonder if a short finial would work well. You could start with a gentle sweep and run that into a small form that looks similar to the shapes you have in the marquetry.

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

#5

Hi Blake

Jorge Castaneda

>you are going in the right direction, like the others, I wish I was like you when I was 13.

Have you seen your original post? In there I mentioned Erric, another skilled young turner, same as you, don't miss visiting his site and for sure you will pick ideas and hopefully make a friend...

Keep 'em coming

Jorge

Re: I added a finial... what do you think?

#6

Thanks a lot for the advise!

Blake Washburn

>