Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

"Internet Expert"?

Posts

"Internet Expert"?

#1

"Internet Expert"?

Russ Fairfield

>subtitle: The 10 phases of �Expertness� on the Internet.

We have all known them. There is always a danger that anyone can become one of them. Some of them are victims of the �siren call� of the Internet. Some do it on purpose. Others just get sucked in without knowing it is happening.

I have written this description so that we might better recognize them, and more important, that we can recognize these traits in ourselves that we don�t become one of them.

There are only two (2) prerequisites to becoming an �Internet Expert� on the chosen forum -

1. Prior knowledge of the topic is not required. Owning a lathe or having ever turned a piece of wood is not necessary to become an "expert woodturner" on the Internet.

2. Some time at �lurking� is required because this is where the language and definitions of the activity are learned, as are the buzz-words that define the learned.

The 10 Phases of �Expertness�

1. "Discovery". This is where they find somebody who will listen to them. This is the first step past their "lurking" phase. Any messages they post during this phase are repeats of something they have read somewhere else.

2. "Sounding Intelligent - Safe Mode". This is their humble time. They say little things that are reasonable. These are their first original messages. People start to notice them. They post a few photos if they have something that looks good enough that people will notice, and they will use someone else�s photos if they don�t.

3. "Still Sounding Intelligent - Unsafe Mode". They are still on "safe" ground, but they are starting to say things that are only acceptable to the beginners who don't know any better. Those who do know the difference find them full of crap most of the time and are starting to ignore them. They don't know it yet, but the roots for Phase-8 are beginning here.

4. "Full Speed Ahead - Expert on Everything". No explanation needed for this phase. They are the Universal Genius.

5. "Adoration". This the response they get from those who read their messages. They are the smartest person that a lot of the readers have ever known. They are adored by those who don't know any better, and laughed at those who do.

6. "Questioning". Others are starting to question what they say, and call them to task for saying things that are wrong. Things are starting to fall apart, and they often become defensive. They start using typos and brain flatulence as excuses for their errors.

7. "Challenge". This is final phase of "Questioning", and it can cut both ways. Everything they say is challenged by someone, and nobody believes their excuses anymore. They often go into a full defense and counter-challenge. They often resort to personal e-mails. The extreme cases will go so far as making telephone calls and writing threatening letters to those who disagree with them.

8. "Ignore the fool". Everything they say is ignored by all but the new folks to the forum.

9. "Philosophical". Here is where they start writing about things that nobody understands. Since nobody listens to their technical wisdom, they will start lecturing on the philosophical aspect of the subject, things like form, design, and the wood talking to them. They often discuss the meaning of life, and other things that are totally off topic. Somewhere in here is a diatribe on Internet ethics, validity of information, lack of respect, etc., etc.

10. "Exit". They leave in a huff, often with a passionate goodbye message. Sometimes they will repeat this phase several times before their final exit.

Sometimes they will come back with a different name, and start the process all over again.

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#2

Re: "Internet Expert"?

Hooligan

>Gee Russ, bone to bick with someone? Why not just come out and say so?

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#3

Re: "Internet Expert"?

Don in Central Illinis

>C'mon Russ, tell us what you really think. Quit beating around the bush.

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#4

Re: "Internet Expert"?

Dinyar Chavda

>Ouch, Russ, that cut too close to the bone for me! I can see when I have fallen into several of those categories at different times!

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#5

Re: "Internet Expert"?

Jim

>I've avoided even reading many a topic because it had "hot button" written all over it, and I just didn't want to go there. But this one hit my hot button... because....

I'm certain I've fallen into one of these categories at one time or another, and may still fall into one or two of them...Being a newbie to turning, but being the newsletter editor of our club may have contributed to this. But also lurking and posting on many a turning forum may contribute to this as well.

I joined a club a couple of years ago, and almost immediately began writing the newsletter. I do try, however, to only print those things I've heard from experts, or that I've learned myself. That includes reading (books and internet), which is not a totally bad way to learn, despite some folks opinion of it. Dale Nish, Richard Raffan, Keith Rowley and others actually do know what they are talking about. I do try to verify my 'facts'. Although I might not have portrayed everything about someone's demonstration with 100% accuracy, I do strive for it.

So I'm not sure you've intended to include newbies like me who have picked up many a good tip from forums, and then passed them on to others... I don't get angry when someone corrects me though. I don't think I've ever shot off an angry email to another turner, and certainly never gave them a threatening phone call!

Another thing I'm not sure you intend, but I'm wondering about; how many people like myself will read your post, and wonder if it applies to them, and never have the courage to post again? I understand what you're targeting here, and I agree it's a bit disgusting, but I'm not sure of the unintended consequences...

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#6

Re: "Internet Expert"?

Jim

>As an addendum, I'd like to say, that those who most need to hear your message most likely won't see themselves in it, but will continue blithely (or angrily) on and won't change at all, while others may take it a bit personally, and wonder if we have the right to say anything at all.

I'm certain that you didn't intend this, but it could almost be construed to mean newbies should shut up and only post if they actually have 10 years of turning time under their belt.

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#7

Re: "Internet Expert"?

Hooligan

>I rather agree with that viewpoint, Jim. As well, its well thought, and put forward in a manner that is more than acceptable.

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#8

YIKES!

Rick Davenport

>Some of us walk parts of that path then slip back into the lurk mode,

gleaning good info from the site, but keeping out of the way for the most part.

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#9

Re: "Internet Expert"?

Carole Valentine

>Hmmm...think I will head back to lurk mode.

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#10

I am sure...

Bob Fawcett

>I fit into at least some of those, although I tend to think of myself more as a jack-of-all-trades and a master of nothing.

When I first read the topic, I thought of the Internet itself. I might actually qualify as something of an expert there as my real job is network engineer.

Re: "Internet Expert"?

#11

All I have to say is...

keith zimmerman, Normal, IL

>I only know that I don't know much at all. I have found that there is always more to learn about everything.

I will, however, offer an opinion if asked. Of course, we all know about opinions.

keithz