Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

sharpening hollowing scrapers

Posts

sharpening hollowing scrapers

#1

sharpening hollowing scrapers

GaryG in MD

>I have a Scorpion, and I'm wondering about the best way to sharpen the "teardrop" scrapers. Specifically, is it appropriate to sharpen the entire edge on the cutting side, or would it be better to sharpen only a limited section near the area of smallest radius, which I presume to be the primary cutting location? My experience with scrapers in general is that if I make contact with too long a cutting edge I'll get a catch. Not sharpening the edge except near the "point" (plus and minus a quarter inch or so) would seem to be a wise and safe way to go, but I've never seen nor heard this discussed. Comments please. Thanks. Gary

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#2

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

Hooligan

>When you sharpen the teardrop, you put between a ten and 20 degree bevel all the way around, including the flat. If you set the scraper on a flat surface, the teardrop should be swinging to the right and the flat should be swinging in from the left. Keep that as the top, and that is just how you want to sharpen it, because that is going to allow the majority of the radius to be on the left, where the majority of the contact will be made.

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#3

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

Russell L. Babbitt Jr.

>I put my bevel on any side of the teardrop I may find the most useful....I sharpen the entire edge, but like you said I just use a small portion of the cutter at any one time. Cutting with too much of the edge could contact too much surface and cause poblems. On any of my scrapers the angle is not critical. 80 degress (or 20 depending on how you look at the edge)is probably considered "standard".

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#4

Ric Taylor

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

Ric Taylor

>I must be different. When I use my teardrop cutter, most of the time I'm using the edge with the greatest radius, to smooth out previous roughing-out cuts.

Ric

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#5

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

Hooligan

>Nope, you aren't different. At least in that matter. That's hpw I have always been told to do it, as well, how I instruct people to do it. If you read my original post, that is what I intended.

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#6

Brad Vietje

Huh ? I'm not sure I follow that

Brad Vietje

>Hooligan,

I was trying to picture your description of the teardrop orientation, and I'm not so sure I follow. Most teardrop scrapers are mounted with the long point off to the right, which may be what you're describing, or maybe reversing it works better ?

I'm picturing the Stewart system scraper, and now that I think a bit, it isn't actually a teardrop, but more of a French curve with a straight edge, leaving a distinct point. With the Stewart scraper, I sometimes use the nearly straight section (long radius) to smooth interior curves with a shear scrape, but that point can get pretty close to catching... Maybe mounting it (and sharpening it) the other way will work better (?). In the words of one of my least-favorite media personalities, "what say you ?"

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

PS: How'd the exam work out ?

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#7

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

Barry Irby

>I don't have a Scorpion, but I do have a Sorby scraper with a teardrop cutter. To sharpen it, I remove the cutter and press it firmly on a rest on my grinder and pass it across the wheel. I have a rest on my grinder that I leave at the angle. I try to maintain the factory shape, so I sweep the whole edge.

I suppose if I just sharpened the dull spot, I would change the shape, but I don't really know if that matters. I am laboring under the assumption that Sorby know something about what the shape should be. I do pivot the cutter on the handle to take advantage of different parts of the curve and to use whatever part that may still be sharp.

I do see that there would be an advantage to the cutters that have a slot for the screw rather than the hole. You would only have to loosen the screw rather than completely remove it to remove the cutter.

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#8

Re: Huh ? I'm not sure I follow that

Hooligan

>Aced it.

Essentially Brad, we are saying the same thing. The curve is such that it swings away to the right, allowing the greatest portion of the radius to be presented at a dimension that best suits the interior of the vessel. Clear as mud?

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: Huh ? I'm not sure I follow that

Brad Vietje

>Um, well, yeah, that's it: clear as mud. I guess I'm asking if we should try using the blade backwards from the way it's usually supplied by the manufacturer -- that is, upside down.

I may have to try this, but here's my logic: When using the gently curved part with the longest radius, especially on the inside of a bowl or concave object, the tool is much MORE likely to catch on the long point if that point is to the upper right (that is, pointing into the oncomming wood), and less likely to catch if reversed, with the long point to the lower left -- the wood would be passing away from the point.

Are you saying you have tried this and prefer it ? I have a new scraper tip, and could give this a try (and even take a pic, since this is a bit confusing...)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#10

Thanks to everyone for your comments

GaryG in MD

>OK, what I hear you all saying is "sharpen the entire cutting edge". So be it. My fear is that working blind inside a hollow form, I'll get the entire length of the curve matched up with an equivalent curve on the inside of the hollowform wall, and that long line of contact will give too much torque and end up in a catch. (That's why I asked the question in the first place.) Using the small radius side of the teardrop will reduce the probability of that happening, so I think I'll stay away from the large radius side until I get more comfortable with the tool. ...Gary

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#11

Re: Thanks to everyone for your comments

Russ Fairfield

>Why don't you practice using the tool while hollowing an open form. That way you can get comfortable with the feel and sound of the tool while you can see what is happening before you start trying to do it blind.

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#12

Re: Thanks to everyone for your comments

Hooligan

>As Russ said. As well, the smaller scraper is a good tool to learn to "feel" the cut.

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#13

Re: Huh ? I'm not sure I follow that

Hooligan

>Yes, that is just what I am saying. Though, I seem to be scraping pulling forward ony the majority of my hollowing, because its endgrain, most of it.

I think my Sorby teardrops are sharpened the other way, so that the point is towards the back, as it would be for shear scraping bowls. The thing is, I rarely use them.

Re: sharpening hollowing scrapers

#14

yup, definitely doing that -- several times

GaryG in MD

>