Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

Posts

question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#1

question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

GaryG in MD

>The small hollowing cutters that CA sells are relieved on the bottom (particularly on the left side looking from the top) so that they have, in effect, a rough second bevel. I'm guessing that this is to stop the missing material from hitting something, but, offhand, I don't understand the reason for this. Since they are used as scrapers (slight down angle), that area shouldn't hit anything anyway. I'm curious to know the reason and would appreciate an explanation. I'm grinding some new cutters for my Scorpion and want to know if I should relieve them in a similar fashion. Thanks. Gary

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#2

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

Rick Allen

>The cutter on the left has no relief. The bottom (non-cutting) edge of the cutter would prevent the top (cutting) edge from engaging the spinning wood. As the form becomes larger and larger the need for relief becomes less and less.

You can tilt the cutter to move the bottom edge out of the way but then the cutter is pushed away by the spinning wood.

Have you thought of contacting CA with this question?


img

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#3

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

Mark Wollschlager

>I think the relief he means is the slight flat spot on the front edge

of the scraper. The graphic hopefully will show the profile.

I checked my CA scrapers and they have the same. None of my others have it. Checking with CA would give and answer.

Mark.


img

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#4

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Rick, Yeah, it's obvious if I think about it. Photo attached here for others to see. These small (3/16") cutters are for things like ornaments with very small diameters. Makes sense.

So now, my question is: do people do this to Scorpion cutters? Tradeoffs? I can see what I gain. Do I lose anything?

[I don't want to bother CA at home -- can you imagine if everyone in CAW started calling him with questions? That's what WC is for. :)] ...Gary


img

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#5

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Mark. See my reply to Rick. ...Gary

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#6

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

Charlie Anderson

>CA prefers emails and is on the computer several times a day.

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#7

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

Wally Dickerman

>Gary, I suggest that you just grind your cutters with about a 20 deg. bevel. No second bevel needed. Grind then well back on the side with a nicely rounded nose. Works for me. You're correct that the cutter and also a rounded scraper should be used tipped down a bit. Cut on, or a little above center...never below.

Wally

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#8

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Wally. Very interesting comment. The Scorpion instructions call for sharpening at a 10-degree angle. Could you tell me the tradeoffs? I certainly respect your advise, but would like to be aware of both sides of the equation. Thanks. Gary

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

#9

Re: question for Rick Allen, Ed Karch, ...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks Charlie; that's very good to know. I'll keep it in mind. ...Gary