Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

Posts

How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#1

How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

Devon Palmer

>Hey All,

I've been playing with the new Minwax water based poly/acrylic, and really like the way it goes on, dries fast, and will go over about anything I've tried so far. I raise the grain a few times w/ alcohol and sand to keep it from raising too much when applying the finish. It has a ammonia smell like latex when drying.

Anyone else have experience with it? How well does it hold up with use? Food? Repair by applying more?

- Devon Palmer,

Columbus, Ohio

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#2

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

Bob Fawcett

>I haven't used it on a turning, but it is very durable. I used it to finish my stairs when I built the house 5 years ago. It is still holding up well to foot traffic.

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#3

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

Russ Fairfield

>It is true that a waterborne polyurethane can be the hardest thing we can put on a peice of wood, but there are large differences in the products.

I have never like the Minwax product because it dries to a bluish cast, doesn't accent wood grain very well, it has a plastic appearance, and it is generally not any harder than a good lacquer or oil finish. It has the advantage that it doesn't add color to the wood, and that is the reason why it doesn't accent the grain.

On the other hand, Enduro, another waterborne polyurethane, is the hardest and most durable finish we can put on a piece of wood by any measure of hardness we want to use. It has solved the blue haze problem, and it accents the grain like an oil finish.

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#4

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I'll echo Russ. Minwax waterbase is formulated for the BORG market and is MOL junk.

There are a number of very good waterborne finishes depending on what you feel like spending. I use Target Coatings products and Fuhr 355 in the $20-30/qt. range. You can go with some serious stuff like a couple of luthiers I know use called KTM-9 which runs $40 for a quart and is replacing lacquers. Bit too pricey for floors though.

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#5

ok, I give up...

GaryG in MD

>BORG=

BMRT Ordinary Rendering GUI

Buell Owner and Repair Group

Bungie.org

Buying Organization

Brandeis Official Readers' Guild

Bored with the Ordinary Reading Group

Business and Organizational Leadership

Badly Organised Roleplaying Games

Brandeis Official Readers Guild

Bill of Review Granted

Big Omaha Rail Group

Brothers Organization

????

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#6

Re: ok, I give up...

Bob Fawcett

>BORG=Big box store like HD or Lowes, comes from Borg on startrek.

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#7

Re: ok, I give up...

GaryG in MD

>Thanks, I'm assimilated.

(Actually, I kind of liked "Badly Organized Role-playing Games.) ;-)

...Gary of Borg

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#8

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

Devon Palmer

>Fantastic,

Thanks for the responses, I'll source some Enduro and play with it. I've noted the blue cast as well, and really didn't care for it.

- Devon

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#9

So, it looks like I may need a spray gun...

Devon Palmer

>Kinda knew this day would come :)

I've been using wipe on finishes, but, am getting enough volume through my shop now that I probably should consider moving to spraying and doing items in batches. How problematic is it to spray items with a fair amount of detail (candlesticks, ornaments, multi-axis)?

HVLP the way to go? Campbell Hausfeld, Turbinare, whats a good name and a good value. Would like to stick close to $500, unless there is a better model that is a coupla hundred more or less. Anyone have one they like/dislike?

- Devo

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#10

Re: So, it looks like I may need a spray gun... *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Most finishes can be had applied to small items like tirnings was lap marks are not an issue but

Why pass up a tool-buying opportunity!

Do you have a compressor? and if so, what size and capacity in storage and CFM?

The turbine outfits are good for waterbornes, not so good for solvent finishes like shellac and lacquer, because they warm the finish somewhat. I had a Fugi 3-stage turbine but sold it because I was using shellac as a barrier coat in flat work and got too much orange peel.

I now run a Walcom FZ SP gun with a 2-qt pressure pot. Puts waterborne down like glass off the gun. That's about a $700 set up but needs a compressor that will supply 5-6 CFM at 50 psi for the HVLP to work as designed.

My suggestion is that you contact Jeff Jewitt either through his site at Homestead Finishing or ask questions through his finishing forum that's part of that site.


Jeff Jewitt - Homestead

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#11

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Russ: Perhaps you can clear something up for me. I've been told that there are two types of water lacquers; water borne, and water based. I've used CrystaLaq which is water borne with success, but it can only be thinned with their thinner and you must use their retarder. Clean-up is water. I'm now trying Resisthane from Highland Woodworking which is a water based product which is thinned and cleaned up with water - no retarders or propriatary thinners. I haven't noticed any difference in end results, but the Resisthane will wipe on much easier than the CrystaLaq which dries too fast.

Your input is appreciated and respected.

Thanks. Ed

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#12

Among the items that were subjected

Don Henthorn

>to water and heat during my moving fiasco was a walnut hollow form with maple, mahogany and walnut neck. The piece had been sprayed with water based poly and had a beautiful finish. When I removed it from its wrappings the whole piece had turned green like a caroded hunk of copper. I think I may be able to remount it on the lathe and restore it.

That really doesn't say much about your question because not many idiots will subject a water based poly finished piece to such conditions. MMMmmmm.

Re: How durable/serviceable is Water Based Poly

#13

Re: Answer to Ed's question

Russ Fairfield

>Ed,

I would use the one that gives you the results you like, and the easier to use. I am not concerned about having to use special thinners because I have been doing that for all of my life with the traditional finishes.

I wasn't impressed with CrystaLac and I haven't used the Resisthane. I have used the ColorTone waterborne lacquer from Stewart MacDonald and it worked well with good burn-in between coats. I thought it looked more like real lacquer than the CrystaLac.

I think Mark Kauder is using a waterborne lacquer, and nobody can argue with his results. I don't remember what he is using, but you can send him an e-mail.