Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Scorpion question

Posts

Scorpion question

#1

Scorpion question

GaryG in MD

>The washer I got as part of my Scorpion set is much smaller than the "large teardrop" cutter; fine, no problem. On the other hand, it is barely smaller than the "small teardrop". My first reaction was to just not use it. When I looked closer, however, I saw that the cutting tip does stick out a bit, and I wondered if it would act like the shield on some other hollowing tools which adjust the aggressiveness of the tool. Has anybody tried this with the Scorpion? ...Gary

Re: Scorpion question

#2

Re: Scorpion question

Gil Jones

>You are seeing the upper half of the 3/16" square bit holder. The lower half has a square key-way type of cut for the bit, and the upper half is like a washer. It is also used on the large teardrop cutter (but, I think, not the small teardrop cutter).


img

Re: Scorpion question

#3

Re: Scorpion question

GaryG in MD

>Hi Gil,

Since your photo is the exact one in the printed instructions that came with my Scorpion, I'll assume that you are giving me "official" answers.

1) I assume you are telling me NOT to use the washer with the small teardrop scraper -- or, at least, that it was not intended to be so used. I gathered that this would probably be the case, but I'm still interested to know if the washer could be used as a "cut limiter" such as some of the other hollowing tools have to keep them from being too aggressive and catching.

2) Another question: I'm interested in the best placement of the so-called "rotating cutter" (as seen in your photo). In the pic you sent, it is mounted on the 'far' end of the shaft. In this configuration, it does not extend much sideways (in the direction toward the wood) beyond the bulk of the round end of the mounting. I can see this being a problem -- with the mounting hitting the wood. It seems to me that it would make more sense if the cutter bit were mounted (as it easily can be) on the 'near' side of the end of the tool toward the handle. In this way, the round part of the end of the mount does not get in the way of the cutter and will not hit the wood. I don't understand why the 'official' photo shows it on what I would consider to be the wrong end. I would appreciate being enlightened by you, and, of course, by other users.

...Gary

Re: Scorpion question

#4

Re: Scorpion question

Carole Valentine

>Gary, mounting the cutter on the "far" end keeps it more inline with the shaft which reduces torque. You shouldn't have a problem with the holder hitting the wood first. I never have. I suppose the bit could eventually get too short, but I figure I will probably out live the bit! LOL

Re: Scorpion question

#5

Re: Scorpion question

Allen Neighbors

>Gary, I use the 3/16" cutter both ways. Sometimes, when cutting close to the opening under the rim, I mount the cutter, as you say, on the near side, closer to the handle.

At other times, when I am getting deeper into the form, I mount the cutter on the far end, farthest from the handle.

To me, it's usable both ways, and you are right, sometimes the cutter mount gets in the way.

Hope this helps.

Allen

Re: Scorpion question

#6

Re: Scorpion question

Wally Dickerman

>The Scorpion is a copy of the Stewart tool, which I use. The rotating cutter has an advantage over some other tools because the cutter can be rotated so that it's presented to the wood to give the best cutting action, depending on where you're cutting inside the vessel. For this reason, it does a better, easier job, especially up near the rim than many other tools do.

Wally

Re: Scorpion question

#7

Re: Scorpion question

GaryG in MD

>Carole, Thanks for the comment. JSYK, the cutter tip can be put on the center line of the shaft in either configuration (near or far) -- it just sticks out of the holder farther when it's on the far end. I see that Allen uses it on both sides -- you might enjoy experimenting with the 'near' configuration JFF. ...Gary

Re: Scorpion question

#8

Re: Scorpion question

GaryG in MD

>Allen, Thanks for the info. Using it on the "best" side for the task makes a lot of sense. Glad to hear it. ...Gary

Re: Scorpion question

#9

Re: Scorpion question

GaryG in MD

>Wally, I'm pleased to hear that you like this type of tool, and I'm glad to hear that it's very flexible in use. That's what I was hoping for when I bought it. ...Gary