WC's full of surprises!Waaay OT and much too long!
Dinyar Chavda
>My suggestion is that you print this out, go to bed, and read this just before you go to sleep. It should help put you to sleep for several nights. I'm serious!
I should've edited it down, but was too lazy to do so--hey, you get bored with it, you can just skip the rest of it.
I would never have believed that WC would be having a discussion that revolved around the following topics:
- Disintermediation, also called cutting out the middleman, but saying "disintermediation" allowed one to charge more for one's consulting services! :-) Actually, this is much older than the Internet, which has only facilitated and accelerated it. Any intermediary that does not provide value is cut out of the supply chain. Remember what it was like booking a ticket on an airplane? Remember the number of carbon-copied pages in a ticket? (I'm "carbon"-dating myself!) Travel agents that merely acted as intermediaries are out of business.
- Reengineering business processes, which, in this case, translates into making the customer do the work. Staying with the airline example, while previously you called a travel agent or an airline, who was the only one with all the information, which they could choose to share with you or not (remind you of oldtime car dealers, anyone?), now you can log onto Expedia or Sidestep or any of the other sites, and do it all yourself, including payment, reserving a seat, and printing your boarding pass. In fact, when it comes to airlines, if I did have to deal with a human, it meant that I had problems, e.g., a flight cancelled after I got to the airport. Today, I would try to get on a wifi with my laptop and see if I could avoid standing in lines in front of a harried human. (Speaking of lines, I remember all the wonderful books that I read standing in line at a bank to get to my money. The only time I now go to a bank is to get quarters---even a loan is done over the internet) For this ability to make the customer do the work, companies are willing to provide information to ease the process, as it is a heckuvalot cheaper than hiring a human (including humans from the country where I was born). Far from discouraging this, companies are providing as much information as they can to their customers or potential customers, as they have found it to be more efficient. It's not just companies and consumers. Want to sell products to WalMart--better get ready to hook into their systems, and let them hook into yours, as one way that they control costs is by controlling inventory, and that means that their machines talk to yours, place orders, and tell you when and where to deliver, and that is right down to the loading dock at a specifictime! Same thing with GE--in fact, that is how GE has:
- created Relationships rather than Transactions with their customers, by knowing their business inside out and partnering with them on designing GE products for their use, and following them through installation and periodic use. That's what Allen and Russ are referring to---transactions, where the only thing that matters is price for a certain quality, and ease of transaction---also why most of us are disgruntled when we have to provide information for a $5 torch (as an aside, isn't that a wonderful word: "disgruntled". I am reminded of that quote, "I wouldn't say he was disgruntled, but I wouldn't say he was exactly gruntled either!"---love that language). But I digress. We're willing to provide information for a relationship, but not for a transaction. And if we are going to have a relationship with someone, then, as Leo implies, that person better be a whole lot more knowledgeable than what I can pick up from the Internet, because I will have that information with me. It was amazing to me how many marketing VPs just couldn't grasp that they were in a transaction business, and couldn't understand why the customer was not loyal to them, but went wherever they got the best deal. Some companies have wised up to this by the simple expedient of asking the customer. Hotels used to provide all kinds of service at check-in and check-out, with friendly conversation, enquiries about how your day had gone, and, heaven help you if you admitted that this was the first time you stayed with that unit---then you were subjected to a long list of the amenitites provided by the hotel.
As a business traveller for more years than I wish to recall, I did not want to have a relationship with the clerk. My "favorite" was in Lousiville, where I always found myself checking into the hotel at around midnight or later, and the very courteous clerk would ask me questions like "And how has your day been so far?"......
"It's past midnight.......I'm checking into a hotel in a strange city........Alone!!!!! How do you think my day has been?!!!!!"
Finally, someone realized that when a business traveller checks in and out, he/she does not wat a relationship with the clerk, in fact, he/she would prefer to not even have a transaction. So, as a frequent customer, when I checked into some hotels, I walked up to a desk, showed ID, was handed a set of keys and paperwork, asked if I had any questions, and I went to the elevator. However, the hotel knew that I liked to have lots and lots of ketchup with my burger and fries, and I wanted my burger done medum well, and I liked mayo in addition to the mustard on my burger. This was information I was willing to provide to them, because it was in my interest to do so, as this was a relationship I wanted with them. It is the same thing on the Internet.
I use the Internet heavily for purchases, and, in fact have found several sites that are excellent in comparing various merchants that offer the same item at different prices. They also provide reviews of the product, including expert reviews and customer reviews, and ratings of the merchants. I will pay more for a reputable merchant, but I want value for my money.
However, we are currently redoing our bathroom, and my wife has been working with a bricks-and-mortar distributor, and the salesman has worked hard on providing options and suggesting ideas. We know that we can get the fixtures, the vanity, the showers, etc., slightly cheaper on the Internet, but, because the guy is giving us most of the discount that he would otherwise give the plumber, we are willing to pay the premium just because of the value he has delivered. But, we were aware of the discount that he provides to plumbers when they buy from him, and if he hadn't offered us something close to that percentage, we would have had a conversation!
The internet is not to blame for providing information and making some salesmen a commodity. Information was always available, it's just that it took effort. If you wanted to research cars, you had to go to the library, or subscribe to Consumer Reports or some such periodical. It took a lot more work than sitting at a computer typing away. But, if you worked at it, it was there.
Salesmen who have been hurt have primarily been the ones who were just out to sell you something, without trying to solve the problem or need that you have. Try going into a Best Buy and getting information on cameras---good luck--I tried recently! If a salesman were capable of giving me information beyond what I picked up from dpreview.com, I'd be willing to pay the extra cost, but, if they can't do that, then they are definitely not going to get my business, and I have no compunctions about holding similar cameras (they never have the ones that I am interested in) and seeing what they feel like in my hands. The same thing happened in 1981, when we were shopping for a VCR---they were expensive then, around $800, and the VCR-Betamax war was in full swing! I went to several stores in LA to compare various units, and in each store, the salesman would say, "This is a great unit." "How is it better than this other unit (one he did not carry)" "Oh, that's a piece of junk!" "Why?" "Oh, that's a piece of junk". Same story in every store, about whatever unit they carried versus those they did not carry---not one substantive bit of information! I ended up looking up one of the photography magazines, and buying from a NY store, based on price. Today, I'd do it online, and not even bother to go to the store.
Good salesmen can provide you with something above and beyond what you can get from the Internet or other sources. And in some business, you need them, but their function has changed. Car salesmen who are successful have realized that their role has completely changed over the past 20 years or so to one of being a demonstration center, a delivery site, and a service center.
Things change (also the title of an old movie with Don Ameche). You either change with them (just look at the various business models that Amazon.com has gone through), or you get run over.