Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

What would you do?

Posts

What would you do?

#1

What would you do?

Carole Valentine

>I am working on a piece of cherry that Barry Irby gave me. It has some nice figure in it. As I got almost two thirds into the hollowing process, I began to uncover these ragged cracks. The only sign of any possible trouble opposite it on the outside was the small knot. Is this thing likely to tear itself (and maybe me) apart as I continue? Do you think an epoxy mixture would work or is it possible that the wood will just rip itself away from the epoxy? What would you do?


img

Re: What would you do?

#2

Re: What would you do?

Gary in Zirconia, NC

>I don't know how thick it is or where you want to stop with thickness, but I'd just keep going until I was within a 16th of final. Then epoxy and make the last cut or two.

Re: What would you do?

#3

Re: What would you do?

Jim

>How big is it?

How wet is it? Is it cured?

If it's cured, I'd be real tempted to fill 'er up with epoxy or CA glue, and cut away, standing to the side, and with face protection on, of course...

Re: What would you do?

#4

Re: What would you do?

Wally Dickerman

>Coffee grounds and med CA. Apply the CA, then just rub the coffee grounds in. A dental tool (ask your dentist for a couple of used ones) helps to poke the grounds in. Whatever you do, don't use wood dust...it just looks like a poorly done patch job. If the wood is dry it probably won't crack any further.

Wally

Re: What would you do?

#5

Never mind

Carole Valentine

>I decided to stop being such a darned chicken, and decided to see if I could just cut on through it. I did.

Jim, it is dry and about 9" in diameter, 3.5" deep.

Wally, you are right about the dental tools. I have some that I use all the time for any number of things. You are also right about "matching" sawdust looking like a bad patch job! I learned that early in my turning career and have the evidence in a box in the attic. :) I am going to experiment with some of the pearlescent pigments mixed with epoxy (on scrap wood of course) and see what they look like.

Re: What would you do?

#6

Re: What would you do?

Russ Fairfield

>It's Cherry. Cracks are as much a part of turning Cherry as the CA and coffee gtrounds to fill them. Do as Wally said. I rub a little charcoal into the coffee grounds or use black and red Sharpie marking pens to give the patches a little color accent.

Re: What would you do?

#7

Re: What would you do?

robo hippy

>I am surprised that some think that saw dust doesn't work well as a filler, as that is all I use. I prefer to take dust from my drum sander (the corrugated tubing will hold a lot of dust) especially if I have been sanding walnut, and using it. If you take dust from turnings that is laying on the floor, you get too coarse of a mixture, and then the patch looks more like partical board. My efforts blend in nicely. The only problem I have is with contamination of flying shavings while turning. This is solved by sifting, or keeping the fill dust covered.

robo hippy

Re: What would you do?

#8

Re: What would you do?

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Just a comment as I see you solved the problem.

I agree don't try to match a fill. Something I do is when I turn any special color of wood, Blood wood for instance, is as follows. I pre clean the ares of all other wood shavings and dust and then turn the new wood. I clean up saveing the shavings and dust and then run them through a coffee grinder, 3 or 4 minutes to make a nice fine color fill.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: What would you do?

#9

Re: Never mind

Wally Dickerman

>If you are going to use colors, get some Glitter at a craft store. Mix in a little to give it some sparkle. I use blue Glitter with turquoise on cracked mesquite. Looks great.

Wally

Re: What would you do?

#10

Re: What would you do?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>It loks like a drying defect from that knot to me. You should be fine.

Re: What would you do?

#11

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: What would you do?

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Carole

Don't be to quick with doing anything, now that you have taken a most of the surrounding wood out, let it settle a bit, it could close up some, but if it still wants to move, it's easier to let it do that now, before you have filled the splits.

As for what to use to fill in, copper powder looks good IMO as does a dark brown to almost black filler, I'm sure you're quite able to find the right color for it.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: What would you do?

#12

Re: What would you do?

albertabob

>Heres' one I did a whle back with epoxy, photocopier toner and a bit of gold paint mixed in.

It's still together now so I am not too worried.

My wood is so bad here the I have had more experience with creative patching than I care to mention.


img

Re: What would you do?

#13

Re: What would you do?

albertabob

>Heres' one I did a while back with epoxy, photocopier toner, and a bit of gold paint mixed in.

It's still together now so I am not too worried.

My wood is so bad here the I have had more experience with creative patching than I care to mention.

bob


img

Re: What would you do?

#14

Re: What would you do?

albertabob

>Heres' one I did a whle back with epoxy, photocopier toner and a bit of gold paint mixed in.

It's still together now so I am not too worried.

My wood is so bad here that I have had more experience with creative patching than I care to mention. (smile)

If you are concerned with separation, run some epoxy in the cracks and let it sit for a week.

I like to "celebrate" the defects rather than try to mask them.

Regards

Bob


img

Re: What would you do?

#15

Designer firewood

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>Carole

Is the only piece of cherry you have? Is there something special about it? I don't mess with cracked pieces. There is always more cherry and the next may have more figure. Its cracked, it will always be cracked and after you "repair" it may crack more.

Terry

Re: What would you do?

#16

Re: Carole, sometimes cracks

Allen Neighbors

>like that are from wind or storm stress while it was still standing.

Glad you went ahead with it. Patching it before final turning like Gary said is my thought too.

In the windy country that I live in, stress cracked wood is a common thing. Nearly all trees in this country have inside cracks. Cherry wood is not common in this country, and if it were mine, I'd do anything to try to save it.

Blessings.

Allen

Re: What would you do?

#17

Re: Carole, sometimes cracks

Jim

>I tried to post this under the Persimmon thread the other day, but my graphic was too large and I ran out of time.

I'll post it here instead, since it applies.

I've found that many times the flaws in the wood add to the character of the piece. If you always use sound wood, you never get to experiment with solutions. I know some turners recommend always using sound stock (Richard Raffan states something to that effect in one of his books). And then other turners say that they want nothing to do with sound stock, they'd rather have a crack or a knot. I think I fall somewhere in the middle as I don't have the money to buy sound stock, and most of the time the stuff I cut either doesn't start off sound, or doesn't stay sound.

I was going to cut this piece up into pen blanks. Fortunately I didn't have any pen turning equipment... And I turned it into a bowl instead.

Notice all the cracks in this spalted Persimmon:


img

Re: What would you do?

#18

Re: Carole, sometimes cracks

Jim

>And then there's the cracks on this side:


img

Re: What would you do?

#19

Re: Carole, sometimes cracks

Jim

>Now does anyone think I shoulda made this into pen blanks instead?

I don't. And I wouldn't take less than $100 for this piece either.