We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>This question was asked in the British magazine and I was wondering the same thing. One of the major responses they got was perceived value. From my own point of view this is probably one of my major reasons for making the decision to go or not go. I've been to quite a few symposiums over the years and seen a lot of demos so I don't usually go to see a particular demo although that does help make the decision. I usually base my decision on whether or not I think I'll learn enough to justify paying for the event. For my pocket book they aren't cheap and require some commitment on my part to justify the expense. In reality that never works out. By that I mean I could probably buy I can't really say I learned X amount therefore this trip payed for itself. The main reason I think I go is meet other turners. I learn as much from them as I do from the demonstrators and of course it's just nice to see these people. The last time I went to the Southern States Symposium I missed at least 1/3 of the demos because I was out in the vendor area talking to the vendors or other turners.
What are your thoughts. I'll try to compile them and send this info to the editor since he was asking about how we in the US thought of symposiums.
>I attend for several reasons: 1)to see the demos I am interested in; 2) to meet and greet turners either I know and those haven't met yet; 3) to look at the offering of vendors to see what is net, etc.
I prefer the smaller Symposia. That is about the only reason I have not attended the National.
I atttend symposiums for the purpose of learning new techniques and practices. The extra benefit is meeting other turners. Many of which, I get their contact information and ask questions via e-mail.
I have not found much discount in the tool and wood sales.
But, I have benefited mostly from events like the Gathering at Terry Daniel's. I learned more turning practices and met more helpful people than I have in the 3 years of my wood turning hobby.
>When I first started attending symposiums, I felt I had to go to every rotation to get my money's worth. Over the years, it's become a necessity to adopt the John Lucas approach.
The AAW Symposium is so huge that it becomes impossible to see all of the instant gallery, visit the vendor area and attend ALL the rotations. It's been said before and vetoed, but it sure would be nice to have an additional day for instant gallery and vendor visits ONLY (AAW Symposium).
>Meeting and talking with other turners would be my first reason for attending a symposium. Like you, John, my finances must be a consideration so location is an important factor: will it be a 1 or 3 tank-of-gas drive, etc. If there at least 2 demonstrators that I HAVE to see and meet, I'll save to attend that show and skip possibly 2 other shows.
Now that I've attended 3 national shows and a lot of local shows, I enjoy the local a wee bit more because there are just too many people, too much to see and absorb and too long lines at the national. I would come home with the feeling I missed too much, didn't get to talk to people I really wanted to (said "Hi" passing in the crowd) and can't remember 1/2 the turnings I thought I would in the Instant Gallery.
The Instant Gallery would be my second reason for attending. I just love seeing all the wonderful work. The beginner right up to the most professional are of great interest and I learn something from every single piece presented (even if it's "well, I don't want to do that!"). This room is where I learn, converse, relax and meet the most interesting and fun people.
The vendor area comes in 3rd. I love the demos in this area, not only do I get to see products in use but there are a lot of famous turners doing these demos and you can ask questions and see a lot better than in the rotation rooms. Also you don't feel as conspicuous walking away if it's not really of interest or you want to see something else.
The rotation demos would come in last. I do love to watch anyone demonstrate anything pertaining to turning or discussions regarding design (NOT copying or plagiarism). I don't mind watching the tv monitor, I don't mind the crowded rooms, there is a live demonstration and I'll learn something.
My situation is a bit different now that I'm a vendor, I attend to present my products to as many turners as possible. I much prefer being an attendee but I support myself turning and selling turning products.
>In KY, I was quite put off that they kept the Instant Gallery roped off and the vendor area locked while crowds of turners milled in the hallway. Why couldn't both these areas be opened when the people started arriving? If someone's going to steal something at 7 a.m., they will steal it at 9 a.m. just as easy. It gave me a "mistrusted" feeling that I did not like.
Also with having the vendor area and the Instant Gallery the same hours, being a vendor, I did not get to see but 1/3 of the IG in KY and that really upset me.
>As for me, it's a chance to mingle with other people with the same interest....woodturning. In my hometown, I could count the number of people who do woodturning on the fingers of one hand.......and have fingeres left. The number of people who know about woodturning and what it is, is slightly greater.......at least most of my family members and friends know about my hobby.
I have attended several (3) Tennessee Association of Woodturners Symposiums. They were all great. Got to see some great demos. I also attended AAW in Louisville this year, my first national symposium. It was great! No, beyond great......some 2000 woodturners, all under one roof. The gallery.....can you imagine what some of these guys are doing? Far out! The trade show was far beyond my expectations....so much stuff....but, so little money. The demo's were exceptional......although some were full to overflowing. I doubt I venture to the West Coast for the next one, but when there is another national within 500 to 600 miles, look out. I'll be there!
I think the symposiums make me a better turner. Seeing what is being accomplished by other turners sparks my drive to create better turnings and opens my eyes to what is possible... and the possibililties seem endless.
This year at the national I learned to turn a rose, my only attempt was quite ugly. Keith's was the answer. Point is, the demos almost always teach me somethind and I would attend every one if I could. However, there are simply too many. I would go for the extra day just to chat and do the instand gallery.
Are they worth the money--yep if you can drive. Flying to the west coast puts next years AAW out of reach. I have not been to any regional meetings but that may be the answer to the too big event.
Wood turners are simply the best group of folks that I have ever encountered. Getting together with like minds is the main attraction follwed by the demos as a close second.
>I think perceived value is right on. Even the cost of the AAW National is nothing compared to the value. Local (mini symposiums) seem to be the wave of the future with lower cost and lighter attendance. This makes for a more intimate viewing of demos but not near the varity of turners doing demos.I'm partial to the Desert Woodturning Roundup in Arizona each February partly because I helped start it and secondly it has the benefits of a mini symposium. Meeting other turners is a big plus and puts a face with a name you might see on forums.
>John, thanks for posting your question. In Louisville, I had the pleasure (and headache) of coordinating the IG. This was a first time thing for me. One of the things that I quickly learned was that the hours of operation should have been longer. With the scheduling of volunteers, it was impractical to change things, but you can bet that future AAW events will provide more access to the IG. And the hours will not 100% coincide with the trade show, so vendors will have more opportunity.
Regarding, �why to go�, the experience of spending time with so many people with similar interests is just too irresistible.
>I attend the national symposium because it is the BIG show of woodturning. There is nothing else in woodturning that comes close.
The national symposium is bigger than the sum of it's parts. If I put a value on each of the parts the total would be less than how much it all cost me. And yet the value makes the national symposium a bargin for me.
>Why do I attend symposiums? I think it's exciting! The symposium in Louisville was probably the most exciting so far...the atmosphere was electric. So many turners, all in a hurry to be somewhere.
Attending symposiums allows me to visit cities I've never been to. I absolutey loved Louisville, and plan to return. It would be a great place for future symposiums.
I don't attend too many demos...the only real reason I attend is to study the demonstrator's style and presentation. I like to study how the demo flows, and what seems to work , and what does not. For instance, watching someone removing wood for twenty minutes is absolutely boring...things like that should be done in advance.
I usually don't like to attend demos to learn new techniques....simply because I don't want my work to look like anyone elses.
I'm fortunate to demonstrate at symposiums quite a bit. This helps cover the costs of attending the symposiums,allows me to share some of the things I've learned in my 30 year woodworking career, and helps me gain some "name recognition". (I plan on a new thread on this topic) BTW,name recognition and boosting one's ego are NOT the same thing. Want some real excitement? Demo at a National event!
The instant gallery allows anyone to display their work along-side the works of the world's best turners. Anyone. What better opportunity to showcase your work? Your work will be seen by the biggest galleries and collectors in the world..If you are SERIOUS about becoming a professional turner, the symposiums are an absolute MUST. You may be the best turner on the face of the earth, but if nobody sees your work, it won't do you much good.
Maybe, just maybe, your work will be part of the critique. This year, over 2000 pieces were on display in the IG. 30 got selected for the critique.( Not a big deal? Don't tell that to Ed Kelle, whose piece was included in this year's critique.) This is not meant as a gloat or bragging, but almost every "break" I have received in my turning career has been as a result of participating in the AAW symposiums. Contracts with galleries, invitations to exhibitions, magazine articles, colaborative pieces, club demos, or awards can all be traced directly to my participation in AAW sponsored symposiums.
Not least in importance, is the friends I've made through these events. Contrary to some opinions, I find that many of the "big hat" turners are actually real people, just like you and me. I have received a lot of support and gotten good advice from many of them...and established some pretty good friendships. I cannot believe how many people I actually knew in Louisville...amazing! I met many WC friends, I won't name them for fear of leaving someone out!
>I think symposiums are great to a point. I have found that the smaller ones better suit my taste. If the AAW continues to get that many people for theirs I will not probably attend another. If it is close I might go for the IG and trade show but Louisville was just way too crowded. The WOW dinner was great, but having to go and mark a seat or arrive 15 or 20 minutes before a demo did nothing for me. I will be going to Total Turning in Albany and I expect a better experience. I always learn something good or bad.
>John, I don't attend simply because of the expense. I just can't justify the money, even though I know I would learn a lot. The second disappointment in not going, is failure to meet the other turners.
I'll never forget the camaraderie at the Georgia Gathering. :o)
I'd like to offer my own perspective on the instant gallery
I've volunteered as a runner for two instant galleries, my second time was at Louisville. While there is some concern about theft the main reason the gallery is not open to the public while it's being set up is that the crowded room would make the job impossible extremely difficult for the runners and artists. The chance of someones work being bumped into or dropped is just too high.
It was hard enough to get people to leave bags and umbrellas ect. at the entrance once the gallery opened. Imagine the task of carrying a box with delicate turnings thru a crowed room. Also many of the pieces take time and care to setup, this was particularly true with the collaboratives and the wall hangings. It would not be reason able to expect the artists to have to work around the crowd to accomplish this.
I would also recommend volunteering for instant gallery help - it is a great way to spend more time in the gallery, and in particular, if you help with the setup of the instant gallery you get to meet a lot of the turners when they place their items. I had the opportunity to meet quite a few of the demonstrators by helping at the instant gallery.
I believe that the gallery was open during normal symposium hours for the remainder of the time with access restricted only at the beginning. Perhaps the hours could be extended if more people volunteered to help monitor the gallery.
>As a beginner, I have only attended the Gathering in Georgia. This was a great experience. Meeting so many people so willing to share was great. The comraderie was amazing. I will certainly attend future events like this one. I live in Georgia, so this is local for me. The "size" was just right. Large enough to showcase a lot new things, at least for me, but small enough to meet nearly everyone.
I have attended large trade shows for work, and some are so large it is not possible to even see all of the venue (think Georgia World Congress Center), much less all of the vendors and demos. I will go the National at least once someday, probably when it is closer to home.
>I attendended my first national symposium two years ago in Florida. I had a great time even though the total expense of the symposium combined with travel was very high in my estimation. If I remember right, the attendance was around 1,000. I cannot imagine myself going to another one that is larger than this. And, to be honest, I enjoy the smaller SWAT symposium much more due to its size which draws 500-600 turners, costs only $80.00 and is closer to home. I attend a few demos but spend more time visiting with friends, the instant gallery and the vendors. The chance of winning a turning from one of the Lead Demonstrators at the Saturday night banquet is a big draw as is a chance to win the Powermatic 3520B lathe and a bunch of other stuff. This is much more exciting that sitting through a 2-hour auction watching the "rich people" flaunt their bank account.
>When I first started turning, I went to the national symposium and found it worthwhile gaining new skills, and being exposed to new techniques. I am a gadget freak so the vendor area was a favorite haunt. Added to that was connecting with so many people who shared my passion for turning.
That being said, I have found a diminishing return for the money spent. It is an expensive venture to go to a far away place, get a hotel room for three days, pay a substantial registration fee. I am trying to get to the local symposiums in the Southeast and see many of the same "names". It feels a bit more manageable in terms of numbers. And finally, at my experience level, I am finding a day of hands on, a week up at John C. Campbell, or a special trip to a master's studio to be of more value.
>You cannot beat "hands-on". I have attended too many demos and left thinking I knew how to do it and when I got home I found that I did not remember one or two parts or techniques which made it impossible to complete the piece. I'll also spend my money going to informal "Gatherings" and local events or just visiting other turners within driving distance. I welcome any turner who wants to stop by for a visit and I think most other turners do too, so long as they are given advance notice just in case they have something else going at the time and can't break away. When visiting other turners you don't have to put up with inflated egos, politics, and other BS.