Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Turning Chat

Posts

Turning Chat

#1

Turning Chat

Earl Kennedy

>I was in the chat room last nite.We had no topic last nite.We had I think 28 people in at one time.Most people stayed only a short time. I think they left because they were there to learn some thing about turning and there was to much talk that didn't pertaing to turning.I think we shoud have some topic or several topics every chat.Even if they are simple beginner stuff.Some thing is better than nothing.I was not one that left early but wished I had after it was over and never got to much that was interesting.IT IS A WOOD TURNING CHAT ROOM.

Re: Turning Chat

#2

Re: Turning Chat

Tom Libby

>Thank you!!

Re: Turning Chat

#3

Re: Turning Chat

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>There usually is a Topic of the night? I never did see one posted...so I just stayed in the shop and kept turning.

Jen

Re: Turning Chat

#4

Re: Turning Chat

Carole Valentine

>If you have a topic you want to discuss, let Terry know. I am sure he will be happy to schedule it. Last week in the chat room (or was it week before last?) he asked for topics for future chats and got no responses. Personally, I think at least one Wed each month should be open topic. I have learned a lot in those chats as well, even though sometmes we just socialize.

Re: Turning Chat

#5

Re: Turning Chat

Stuart Johnson

>Earl, Tom : I'm sure Terry would like to hear any topic suggestions you might have. Usually if someone asks for a specific topic it will be scheduled.

Personally, I like the sessions with photos like we have had on several topics.

Re: Turning Chat

#6

Re: Turning Chat

Steven

>I sometimes have questions but dont like to ask them if there is a particular topic whch doesnt relate to my question. I will tune in a half hour early to ask them and there are usually several people already in the room. They have always been most helpful. When the chat is like last night I dont mind asking. I find the chat room and this messageboard to be great resources.

Re: Turning Chat

#7

I totally agree with you Earl

TDaniel

>I think we should have a topic every week and we should all stay on topic from 9:30 to 10:30; any other business can be done between 9 and 9:30 or after 10:30. However, I was outvoted on this a while back. Some wanted a topic every other week and some wanted an open night once a month. For some reason, here recently about every topic we pick turns into an argument so I have asked for topic ideas for the past 2 weeks and have had no suggestions. We'll try a critique session next week if everyone wants to. Send your pics to RonS so he can have them on his site as before. Next week we will accept pics of turned items that have no enhancements that are done off lathe or with the lathe turned off. We will feature enhanced turnings a week or 2 later.

Re: Turning Chat

#8

Re: I totally agree with you Earl

Peter Hyde

>"Send your pics to RonS" Could you elaborate? Like where and sizes etc.

Thanks

Peter

Re: Turning Chat

#9

Re: I totally agree with you Earl

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Terry, we're having similar motivational problems on the Tuesday hand tool chat. This week, the topic was "Topics". We got lots of good ideas, which I will reintroduce in the coming weeks. Maybe towards the end of the chat, I'll ask again, for new suggestions or for additional discussion next week on topics that we have not beat to death this week. I hesitate to suggest that other questions should not be brought up. This week, I think some people learned some useful techniques during the impromptu discussion on installing threaded inserts using a brace.

Thanks especially to e, for some great ideas.

Also, to stir up some interest in future chats, you might consider logging the chat, and then extracting the gist of the on-topic discussion, making sure you leave out any and all even remotely personal stuff, and posting it on the Forum. It might give some people the idea that the Chat, and especially a Topic oriented chat, are worth their thought and time.

Remember, you can't please everybody, and if you try too hard to do so, you will displease everybody else. Run it the way you think is best.

Re: Turning Chat

#10

JL

Re: for those of us who are inbetweeners...

JL

>or intermediate turners - how about a discussion on wood properties? Green, air-dried, kiln. Which woods take a crisper line, which are a PITA to turn, which "fuzz" up, etc. Not next week though. Most of my experience is with oak, maple (hard and soft), walnut and some exotics. I want to play around with some different legs, stretchers and stiles that'll give a nice contrast to the seat material (pine or butternut). A wood that won't take a crisp line won't work for baluster turnings. Just a thought. Some of it would be applicable to bowls also.

Re: Turning Chat

#11

Re: Turning Chat

Allen Neighbors

>It has never failed me so far. Everytime I get in the chat room, I learn something. Sometimes more than at other times, but always something.

Allen

Re: Turning Chat

#12

Re: I totally agree with you Earl *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>Check this out Will


Some Past Chats

Re: Turning Chat

#13

Proposal: What do you think?

TDaniel

>OK, let's get back to our roots. WC is here to help new turners learn the basics safely. We can get into intermediate level occasionally. Everyone else, it's time to graduate! If you are advanced then either come on and help us teach the new folks or come on early or late, (before 9:30 or after 10:30), or Friday or Saturday evening for general conversation. Let's keep the Topic Hour what it is supposed to be: a helping hand for the beginners to intermediate level turners. And since we all like to moan and groan about something occasionally how about we use the 5th Wed of each month to bitch about whatever in the turning world bothers us? By limiting the gripe sessions to 4 or 5 a year maybe we can avoid the unfriendly debates that occur occasionally?

Re: Turning Chat

#14

Re: Proposal: What do you think?

Earl Kennedy

>Sounds like a good plan to me.

Re: Turning Chat

#15

Re: Proposal: What do you think?

Carole Valentine

>"WC is here to help new turners learn the basics safely."

Sorry TD, that's an important part, but I think the turning section of WC is far more than that. It's here to help ALL levels of of the craft advance in their skills, ask questions, discuss techniques, finishes, tools, etc. It's also here to allow turners to develop camaraderie with other turners around the world. You want to limit chats to beginner topics, with "occasional" forays to the intermediate level?? What about the other 75% (a conservative rough guess) of the turners who frequent WC who would be categorized in the intermediate to advanced levels? Those people are more than willing to jump in and help a beginner who has questions as evidenced by the posts and the chats, but they should also have the opportunity to advance their skills (including enhancements) through the chat sessions.

Re: Turning Chat

#16

Re: Proposal: What do you think?

Ron in Drums PA

>Sounds like a good idea to me.

How about this

3 Wednesdays are for beginners

4th Wednesday for intermediate

5th Wednesday for advance

9pm-9:30pm for casual conversations

Friday, Saturday or Sunday for casual conversation

But of course a question about turning during casual conversations will always be welcomed.

Now....

How do we choose the topics each week?

Maybe work up a plan for a month at a time?

Re: Turning Chat

#17

Re: Proposal: What do you think?

Stuart Johnson

>This might be a good topic. We can see just where the interest is greatest. I'm a little afraid if we limit it too much the more senior (turning age not years) might fall by the roadside. I think there is a need for non-topic nights to cover general questions. In the past some of these have turned into rather involved discussions. The problem seems to come in to play when the majority of he chat turns into a free for all that has nothing to do with turning. Even non topic nights should be turning related.

An example might be: I'm using the Wolverine jig but my gouge is very pointed. What am I doing wrong and how can I correct it?

This does is a good non topic question but is not appropriate in the middle of critiques.

Another example: "Which team is going win the Stanley Cup?"

This is fine from 9:00 to 9:30 or after 10:30 but never in between.

Non topic night should still be woodturning related from 9:30 - 10:30.

Re: Turning Chat

#18

Sunday is General Woodworking

Carole Valentine

>Fri, Sat and Mon are open. Perhaps one of them should be intermediate/advanced turning. My tennis coach always used to tell me that the best way to improve was to play with people who were better than I was. I think that applies to many skills.

Re: Turning Chat

#19

Re: Proposal: What do you think?

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Maybe I have just missed it or maybe I am obtuse but I have yet to "hear" a cross word during the chats. Now on the forum lately is a different story.

Re: Turning Chat

#20

OK...

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>So the next question is, who is going to decide what topic is good for what level on what day?

Re: Turning Chat

#21

Re: Proposal: What do you think?

Ron in Drums PA

>I never heard a cross word on a chat

Re: Turning Chat

#22

Re: OK..., I wasn't going to say this...

Ron in Drums PA

>How about a committee?

Re: Turning Chat

#23

How about this

Ron in Drums PA

>How about this

1st Wednesdays are for beginners

2nd & 3rd are for beginners to intermediate

4th Wednesday for intermediate to advance

5th Wednesday for advance

Re: Turning Chat

#24

Whatever!

Carole Valentine

>This is ridiculous. I have made my last comment on this "topic". I will leave it to the control freaks.

Re: Turning Chat

#25

Re: How about this

Stuart Johnson

>sorry Ron, that makes it sound like beginners aren't allowed or welcome in higher level chats. I'm all for topics carrying a level in the title:

Beginning Sanding

Intermediate catch repair

Advanced design opportunities after catch 101

but one week labled as being for a specific level and I think we will loose folks.

I really don't like the idea of having one night say Wed. for beginners and another other levels.

A couple weeks ago Terry was begging for topics and didn't have any input at any level. Looking back at some of the topic sessions I think all levels were able to contribute. A broad range of topics will keep up the interest but all sessions must be turning related during topic time.