Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Chainsaw quandry

Posts

Chainsaw quandry

#1

Chainsaw quandry

Scott Longberry

>Hi all,

I know that asking for opinions on chainsaw brands is sort of like asking what political party to join, but I'm going to go ahead and ask anyway (about the chainsaw, not the political party! :) ).

I'll start by saying that I have $200 to spend on a chainsaw. I've never owned one before but have recently come into some large pieces of Walnut that will not fit on my bandsaw. So... I'm using it as an excuse to get a chainsaw. I know that there will be many people who will tell me to wait and get a Stihl, but that's really not in my budget at the moment.

A couple of pieces of information that may be pertinent first. I live in Colorado and therefore do not have access to a ton of hardwoods that need to be taken down. This saw will be primarily used to trim down the logs that I do get into manageable sizes. In the past 1.5 years, I've borrowed an electric chainsaw once to cut some blanks, so the saw will not be seeing heavy use.

I've been looking at two saws. The Husqvarna 141 or the Poulan PP4620AVX. The Husqvarna has a 16" bar and a 2.2 HP engine while the Poulan has a 20" bar and a 40cc engine (do't know how that translates to HP). So, the question is, would I be better off with the extra bar length of the Poulan? Or with the Husqvarna simply because of their reputation?

Thanks,

Scott

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#2

Re: Chainsaw quandry

Carole Valentine

>I still say Stihl but....since that's not an option, I personally would go with the Husqvarna. JMHO, mind you...I am no expert by any means! I have just seen too many people here cussing their Poulans lately. You may be able to put an 18" bar on the Husqy, or 16 may be all you need. My Stihl 250 (45.4cc)comes with a 16" bar and I run it with an 18" bar with no problem at all. BTW, I think 2.2 hp would translate to somewhere around 36cc, but that seems to be an inexact science and depends on a lot of factors.

Warning: this advice is worth what you paid for it, but since no one else had replied...

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#3

Re: Chainsaw quandry

LT

>Scott,

I purchased a Husqvarna 350 last year. A little more than your budget, but a great saw/brand that I would highly recommend. Starts when I need it to and cuts great.

Bottom line...you can't go wrong with a Husky or Stihl.

LT

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#4

Steven Antonucci

While hiking in Yosemite this summer...

steve antonucci

>I passed a NPS trail maintenance worker with his Husky... I asked him why, and he said "It's the only damn saw that'll run at this altitude (7500' at the time)" He had a 3' bar on it too.

I love my Stihl, but his comments stuck with me. If you're in Colorado, you're probably at altitude too.

FWIW

Steve

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#5

Re: Chainsaw quandry

Dave Belser

>My personal experience and thoughts (worth what your are paying for them!)

I have a Poulan that I bought years ago when a tree dropped in my backyard and I needed to get rid of it, this was before I was a turnner. I don't know what model it is but it was less than $200 and the borg store.

It has seen a lot of use and abuse over about 6 years, but it still starts easily. I've never adjusted anything on it accept the bar of course.

I just spent $400 on a Stihl 310 and I'm very glad I did. I can now prep a blank from log to lathe in about 10 minutes instead of 30 or more!

Even thought it is tiwce your budget, you might find buying a better saw that you won't outgrow is a better deal. I do believe that the Stihl I just bought will be the last saw I buy for a LONG time AND it would have saved me a lot of time if I had started with it.

- Dave

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#6

Re: Chainsaw quandry

Gerry Meekins

>Scott,

I have never used a Poulan but I�ve owned the Husqvarna 141 with the 16� bar for about 4 years. Walmart has replacement chains for this saw at about $21 bucks for a pair. I have never done anything other than change the plug and chain and clean the air cleaner on this saw. Depending on the size blanks you make this may be all the saw you will ever need. I bought another Husky when I got a bigger lathe and I have no regrets.

Gerry

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#7

Re: Chainsaw quandry

robo hippy

>You might try the local chainsaw shop and see if they have a rebuilt saw for sale, you get more saw for the money.

robo hippy

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#8

Re: Chainsaw quandry

W.C. Turner

>No question the Husky 141 over the Poo-lan. That said, a couple of years ago I got a Husky 350 off the 'net for about $260. Probably a little higher now, but, my point is, search the net. There's some good deals out there, & for a $100, more or less, you'll have more saw.

W.C.

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#9

Yes, a Stihl *IS* in your budget...

Peter Teubel

>I would suggest a Stihl MS170 (about $175). The secret is the very narrow chain and smaller pitch (.043 instead of the standard .050). This narrower kerf translates directly in more power from a given saw. Its their smallest saw, but I find I use it FAR more than my other big saws. Recently, I've been cutting down big pines for milling on my sawmill. I've cut down and bucked 20" diameter trees with that saw. Every one of my friends that have used it loved it and were quite surprised at the power and ease of cutting....and this is with just a 14" bar. Its a super light, extremely dependable saw. I've had POO-lans in the past and (IMO) they live up to their namesake (i.e. POO).

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#10

Re: Chainsaw quandry

Wilford Bickel

>Husky 141 - I have had one for several years now with a 14 inch blade for cleaning up fence rows on the farm. The thing has taken a beating and is still easy cranking and runs great. Good enough I just added a Husky 350 with 18 inch blade during our local dealers store closing sale (bummer!!) to the farm to get ready for when the old Mac 10-10 needs a part that is no longer available. I owned one Poulan made saw and it was the worst chain saw I had ever dealt with in over 30 years of running chain saws.

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#11

Local parts

Phil Joines Krum, Tx.

>Check the availability of parts at local dealers.

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#12

Re: Chainsaw quandry

Hooligan

>I have all three varieties. Husqy, Stihl, and Poooooolan.

All suit me well in their capacites. I'm particularly fond of my Husqy's though.

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#13

Steven Antonucci

Yeah- I use my Stihl O17 all of the time

steve antonucci

>Love it. great "little saw" that I've cut 36" white oak logs with a 14" bar (and finished with wedges and a maul). Easy to control and I carry it with one hand.

1.75HP little dynamo- but follow my comments from the National Park Services guy above who specifically told me they stopped running Stihl's because they didn't work at altitude. I'm at about 500 ft above sea level, and my Stihl is awesome.

not sure what would happend at 8000' though.

Steve

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#14

Re: Yeah- I use my Stihl O17 all of the time

Ed Karch

>Go for the husky.

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#15

Re: Chainsaw quandry

RevDoug

>Buy locally where you can get parts and service. You don't want to have to send your saw off to some service center somewhere in tembucktoo.

Turn 'em round,

Re: Chainsaw quandry

#16

Re: Chainsaw quandry

Merv in BC

>I have a remington electric and a Sthil gas and woud say I use the remington the most as it is convenient and quick the gas I save for adventures in the forest; don't get anything less than a 16in