Sesame Street - Another long post
Raymond Overman in SC
>Which one of these is not like the other one? Which one of these just doesn't belong?
Internet forums since the days of usenet newsgroups are notorious for giving newcomers a perception of some hidden agenda and behind the scenes goings on. I visit six different turning forums frequently. I live and work around computers so I don't miss many days. Each of the forums has a different feel even though there are many cross-overs like me that jump from one forum to the next.
Personally I think Ellis and WC do an excellent job with this forum and I enjoy the discussions that come out of it. Especially the heated ones that involve the art/craft, natural/embellishment, over the roll/under the roll type arguements. They help me develop my ideas and help me answer the question, "What do you use that for." I like the fact that it regularly sponsors contests (which one day I'll get up the nerve to participate in), has a chat group that meets regularly, has participants willing to organize things like the turning exchange and blank exchange, and will support it's members like Carole's Valentines Day surprise. I would like to see more turning pics posted but this forum doesn't lend itself to picture management as easily as WOW or AAW. That's not a criticism and I know that you can post pictures. It's just a statement of how this site is different.
I also frequent SMC and it seems much more relaxed than other forums and welcomes new turners to post pictures more readily. It's not about the nuances of turning the perfect form there. It's about encouragement and comaraderie and just spending some time on the lathe. There's a lot more "picking" at people on that site than on others and I feel that it's because of a relaxed atmosphere and less push to become the next big thing. There are informal challenges or contests and even the new guys are encouraged, no, almost required to try something above their pay grade. They've even taken up collections and have given three Jet mini-lathes with accesories away in the past year just to get flat workers into turning. There are times when I feel like the site doesn't promote design improvements that are being discussed on other sites due to the informal pats on the back for people just standing in front of a lathe and banging something out. Again, it's not a criticism, just the way it is and I think it has it's place.
I view the pictures on the AAW site. I don't post and I rarely read the main forum there. I can't say why I don't participate over there except the layout just doesn't appeal to me and I think other sites do it better.
I read the Yahoo Penturner's group and the Yahoo Turning and Talking group occasionally. Again, the format makes it difficult so I don't frequent them as often as I used to. Pictures are a pain on the Yahoo forums and following a thread is not very easy either. There are much better alternatives but I do get an occasional bit of information that's useful.
I've just started participating on WOW and a lot of the same discussions that are here are there, as many of you know. Because it's more picture-centric it seems that there are a lot of very talented people who post there. Some are traditionalists and some are avant-garde. Many of them have as strong an opinion about woodturning as they do about the rest of their lives and it reflects in the discussions and work shown. I love this about the site because I think it brings on more emotional thought that can be directed back into my work. I'm too new there to make any criticisms but I can say that I think Herman is doing a good job running a site with a lot of different personalities. If you want an open forum for everyone to discuss whatever they want to unfettered, you can easily develop one with no moderation and watch the people come pouring in. Otherwise, you use someone elses forum and abide by their judgement.
Now, that's the six turning sites. I also read another forum occasionally just to get a feel for the eclectic, eccentric, and just plain wierd thoughts of artists. For those of you who think that the six sites above are disfunctional or clique-ish or have problems, try the Craigslist Art forum for a month. Every time I read a days worth of posts over there I see something I like, something I hate, read something disturbing, read something inspiring, read something I don't understand, and generally get a feeling of sitting in a coffee house with a bunch of tattoo'd and pierced people on one side and suit and ties on the other with biases to match. It's a confusing diatribe of individual personalities and agendas with no real binding agent.
Here and on other woodturning sites, even though there are problems, we all have woodturning as the basis for why we are here. Different skill levels, different approaches, and different ideas can come together to help everyone. There is a place for everyone and friends to be made. My approach is to filter out the things that I don't agree with but not discount them as helpful to someone else. The things I disagree with help solidify my convictions and can help me produce better work.
So, in my opinion, every forum is different, everyone's ideas and posts have merit, (even though some of them are wrong) and I will continue to participate so that I have the right to speak my mind every once in a while. If you try to please everyone, you can't please anyone.