Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

New somewhat experimental jar

Posts

New somewhat experimental jar

#1

New somewhat experimental jar

Leppikallio

>More or less experimental box this time. Picture (angle of view) makes that finial look taller than it really is. Finial+lid are 2x height of the box.

Box is again some Australian burl and blackwood. 5" diameter and about 5 1/2" high.

What do you think? The finial is mostly the thing I'm concerned, what do you think? Good, bad or "burn it quickly!"?


img

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#2

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

adrien

>Lovely. Finial is a bit longer than the piece requires, but total effect is great. Very nice piece.

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#3

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

Barry Irby

>Please take my suggestions as just suggestions, I am not an expert on finials and probably could not make one better than yours.

First, is the finial leaning to the left or have I got my head one crooked again?

Second, I think it would look better if the small burl insert in the finial were a replica of the shape of the vessel. The vessel appears to be asymmetrical and the insert appears symmetrical.

Third, I think I would have made the finial slightly more slender by emphasizing the Bells or trumpet shapes slightly more. Less of a straight sided cone and more of a curved flare shape.

The engineer in me (which is the curse of any design sense I might have ever developed) suggests the finial should be shorter. Part of me sees the finial as a handle that you should be able to use to jerk the lid off the box, not as art.

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#4

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

Tom Libby

>JMO, but I like it as is. real pretty.

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#5

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

john lucas

>Very Nice. I'm not usually a fan of big finials but this one seems to work for the shape of the body quite well.

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#6

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

Fred Bearman

>There is just something that strikes me as almost magical or mysterious about this, with that really bold beautiful burl, and that tall finial. I am not a huge finial fan, but there is something about this combination that really catches me, and I like the burl inserts in the finial - I should hope to do so good some day!

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#7

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

Barry Turner

>Beautiful piece! Nice burl. I'm no expert on finials (or much of anything else) but the finial looks to me that it's a bit "heavy". I think it would look better if it were more delicate and slender. Of course, I may have just spent way too much time on Cindy Drozda's website. It's a very nice piece, as is.

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#8

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

Bill Stehman

>Leppikallio,

Lovely turning, beautiful wood and well done.

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#9

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

Leppikallio

>"First, is the finial leaning to the left or have I got my head one crooked again?"

The finial _should not_ lean to left but I don't want to say your head is crooked either...

"Second, I think it would look better if the small burl insert in the finial were a replica of the shape of the vessel. The vessel appears to be asymmetrical and the insert appears symmetrical."

In fact that burl insert is quite close replica of the shape of the vessel. I think that angle of that picture is doing some tricks...

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#10

Thank you very much about your comments!

Leppikallio

>Thank you very much about your comments!

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#11

Little revisited version

Leppikallio

>I just had to chuck that again and modify that lid and finial. This is how it is now. Let's see if I leave that bead/shoulder to the collar, now I think it separates lid from the collar nicely...


img

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#12

Re: Little revisited version

Leslie S

>Wow, I thought the first one was lovely but this one is outstanding (IMHO) Nice job.

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#13

Re: Little revisited version

RevDoug

>Not to be negative, but I liked it much better before the revision.

Turn 'em round,

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#14

Re: Little revisited version

GeeSeaWhy

>I think this is much improved over the original. The finial still seems a bit too tall but it doesn't overpower the box now.

Graeme

Re: New somewhat experimental jar

#15

Re: Little revisited version

Ron McKinley

>Looks much better now that you trimmed down the base of the top part of the finial. That being said, I've never made a finial in my life!.......Ron