Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

AAW

Posts

AAW

#1

AAW

Jim King

>This question is coming from the jungle so excuse it if it doesnt fit reality. It is certainly possible that I am missing something or even more. I have never been to a turning club meeting nor know much about the AAW except they have the show each year.

The question is , why does what should be the father of all woodturning websites seem to have the least activity?

Re: AAW

#2

Re: AAW

albertabob

>I have wondered that myself.

I visited that forum a couple of years back and found the "protocal" quite rigid and the atmosphere very reserved.

It seems a venue for a very select group of people that seem to know each other personally.

I hope someone can shed some positive light on this as it seems a highly over rated destination given the activity.

Maybe the magazine is the primary force and the forum is an after thought?

Bob

Re: AAW

#3

Re: AAW

Sean Troy

>I don't think thats the case at all. I find the fourum for everyones taste from begginer to advanced. It seems just as busy as any other fourm out there. Maybe you should post a message and see the response you get. Hope to see you over there.

Re: AAW

#4

Re: AAW

John Lucas

>It runs in spells and your are right about the fact that it seems like some of us know each other, we've been playing on that site for awhile. I get some pretty good help from there occasionally. It's definitely not like WOW or WC but much better than Woodmagizines site as far as activity.

Re: AAW

#5

Re: AAW

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>I think that the AAW forum is great but could be a lot busier. Members and others just arent using it, I think because of the structure. I dont think that it is dominated by a few friends anymore than any other site. Every site seems to have its regulars who seem to be friends. There are a few that are on every site that I look at and I must say that most are a benifit to the hobby or whatever. They help a lot of turners that need it.

Norm

Re: AAW

#7

Nope, this one  *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>


AAW

Re: AAW

#8

Re: AAW

Gil Jones

>The forum message boards, while not terribly busy, seem friendly and ok to me. I wonder about the gallery; there seem to be painfully few comments on the photo posts for some reason.

Re: AAW

#9

Re: AAW

Devon Palmer

>Heyas all,

I used to visit the AAW forum site regularly, but, started coming here more and more becuase of the informal nature of the exchange and the fact that it was very open and unstructured.

Posting here is very "low risk", with honest and gentle critiques, seems to be much warmer here. I kinda like seeing the occasional "shop-dog" picture, hearing about a fellow turners off topic "win" or "loss", kinda embodies the social nature of turning, and not just the physical act. It binds us together and creates interest in the person doing the turning and their style: not just the turnings themselves. Opinions here seem to be slightly less polarized, becuase its more "people centric" as opposed to "technique/style centric".

That being said, I think the AAW does well by maintaining a "professional" candor to the forums, and Jeff Jilg and Steve Worchester do an INCREDIBLE job of running it. Its very clean, concise, and has a lot of good focused information if you know how to search it. Give's it credibility.

Both sites compliment each other perfectly. Depending on the question, you can select the type of audience that would be best suited to give you an answer.

- Devon

Re: AAW

#10

Re: AAW

bob davis

>sean i agree. i think wc is much more "family" aaw does not have great participation which is a puzzle..people with problems ge great response..the current forum site is fairly new.maybe thats it

Re: AAW

#11

Re: AAW

bob davis

>that is not the aaw site.has nothing to do with yahoo

Re: AAW

#12

Re: AAW

bob davis

>formal?

Re: AAW

#13

Easy Jim

TDaniel

>They only listen to the 5oo or so "elite" artists and ignore the 11,500 turners.

Re: AAW

#14

Perhaps...

TDaniel

>it is because WC makes every effort possible to make all feel equal? We do not let a few who lay their credentials on the line (frequently) to run the place. We are turners. A few are artists. We try to share info to help others to learn. WC is not a place to brag or one up everyone else. We are a group of turners that like each other and love to share info. We aren't afraid to speak our minds about things but we don't intentionally raise feathers either. Sometimes we are taken wrong but we really are here to help. We have some very good turners who volunteer regularly to answer any question you may have. Egos will ruin anyplace, any club, any organization. We try to keep egos from taking over on WC.

TD

Re: AAW

#15

Re: AAW

Phil Joines Krum, Tx.

>As I remember it's only been up for a year or so. I don't go there because it takes too long to load on my verrrry sloooow dial up.

Re: AAW

#16

Re: Perhaps...

albertabob

>I would have to agree with you sir.

There is an uncanny feeling of coldness on that forum.

Can't put my finger on it but it's there for me.

The trail Rangers( moderators) do a fine job of letting you know they are doing a fine job too.

I find this close scrutiny a bit stiffling.

Nobody wants to take time out from their busy day to post something and then have to justify it to a "third party".

That's just too "policeey" for me.

Bob

Re: AAW

#17

Richard Allen

Re: AAW

Richard Allen

>Actualy the AAW used to have a mailing list. They droped that list in favor of the web forum. To keep the mailing list function they "moved" the mailing list to a Yahoo group.

The maintance of the AAW mailing list was to much effort so they gave that maintance headache to yahoo.

It is correct that there has not been any activity on that yahoo/aaw mailing list in a long time.

Re: AAW

#18

Re: AAW -- a different style -- long

Brodie Brickey

>Over the last year or so, they have re-done their site, which is better in the navigation and easier to use. The major mistake they made, IMHO, was moving the turned work out into the galleries.

When I come into a turning site, I'm looking for only a couple things. Advice, the chance to give advice, and the pieces as inspiration. With the gallery outside the main forum, I don't have much comfort in posting my work in the forum (I just ain't that good), and like many turners, I'm looking for new ideas or techniques so I'm spending my time in the forum as opposed to the gallery.

You won't find very much off topic discussions, but you will find information and advice. Jeff and Steve do a great job of keeping things on track and for that I applaud them. But there are those times when you want relax a little more.

I would almost refer to it as the difference between "Wood Magazine" and "Fine Woodworking", both produce great work, some is easier than others, but FWW is a little more critical about quality and fit and finish. That may not be really fair to AAW or to WoodCentral, but WC does give me a more comfortable feel. Some of the pieces y'all show here sure ain't simple!

I'll continue to view both sites and a couple others, but WC may have more traffic in part due to a larger base (ie non-turners). AAW's forum has picked up quite a bit in the last 6 months, it used to be a lot slower.

Also if you do a search on Google with "woodturning" or "wood turning" their site doesn't even come up on the first page. Woodturning Design does, which is a relatively new site, so AAW probably needs to revise their META tags and a couple other items on their site, to ensure higher hits off the search engines.

Brodie

Re: AAW

#19

Re: Easy Jim

john lucas

>Most of the people who visit the AAW website are not elitist. In fact most are relatively unknown turners who like to gather together. If you've visited the site regularly you would see that Jeff and Steve pass on the information to the leaders. In fact our president Angelo is also a frequent visitor and contributor with a great sense of humor. Several other board members also contribute. Judging by what I read in the journal and what I read on the board they are all very interested in the vast majority of turners. They are one of the only organizations actively trying to help turners. They give away scholarships. They use the money from the auction for educational purposes. Our own club and many other clubs I know of have recieved grants to buy lathes and cameras and other things to help thier club. Our little clubs aren't the elite. We are average turners and the AAW is trying to help us, all of us.

I met a turner today who recieved a grant from the AAW to study in japan. He says it was the greatest thing he's ever done. He is now studying at the Craft Center and look forward to working with him. He owes a great deal to the AAW.

They also have spend a great deal of time and money working to get younger kids into turning. This happens to be many of the 500 or so top turners that you seem to dislike. Nick Cook, Betty Scarpino, Bob Rosand, Jack Vessery, Bonnie Klein and many other "big name" turners gave thier time to teach these young people. They also gave away mini lathe with tools to several of the young turners. Does this sound like an elitist group.

sorry to rant but the AAW is trying very hard to help turners and often get a bad rap from turners who don't think they are doing it thier way. We all can't be right, they do the best they can and I think they are doing a darn good job.

Re: AAW

#20

Re: Nope, this one

Jim King

>Ron: That is exactly what I was talking about, no responses. No responses means the Godfather is in trouble and needs help. Looks to me as if everyone would benifit if it had more action.

Jim

Re: AAW

#21

Re: Easy Jim

Jim King

>John: Keep calm, my thoughts are the same as your answers. Who else has a national show, who donates scholarships etc.. I think I am aware of what they do thru the internet as it is the only contact I have with the real world and I would assume it is more or less complete as I dont know anyone who has time to write a newspaper everyday which is esencialy what a good web it is. I guess it is just lack of participation due to competion but I have never seen a good product that could be oversold no matter how many people sold it. It was a well intended question and not ment to upset any one or group.

Re: AAW

#22

AAW -- feedback would be appreciated

Steve Worcester

>I personally would love to see more activity in the AAW forums. Many of us here frequent several forums and I like to think of us all as part of the community and in the computer world what we refer to as "the ecosystem".

I would like to think of the AAW forums as open and unpretentious, but I certainly have an insiders, possibly, myopic viewpoint.

We have had to go to moderating users because of spammers, and that seems to lengthen the "sign-up to posting" time a day of so, but we are trying.

I speak for the three moderators (recently added another) when I say that we would love to hear your feedback.

Steve Worcester

Re: AAW

#23

Thanks Jim

john lucas

>Sorry, didn't mean to ruffle feathers, especially yours, you asked a perfectly logical question and there are some good answers. I just went out to the shop to turn for awhile. I had to be at work at 5:30 am this morning and the long day must have worn on me. Lets get back to turning

Re: AAW

#24

Re: Easy Jim

NELSON

>Count me in now its 501!

Re: AAW

#25

Re: AAW

Peter Hyde

>Well I checked out the actual forum, not the gallery and for instance the first thread was started at 01:41pm today and the most recent post to that thread was at 08:46pm. The thread has a total of 10 posts. That certainly doesn't seem slow to me. Maybe Jim you were only looking at the gallery part?