Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

Posts

Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#1

Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

Russ Fairfield

>There are those who think that embellishments AFTER the fact should be separated from "traditional woodturning". But, what about those things done to the wood BEFORE the fact of it being put on a lathe??

There was a time when TD's same argument was leveled against segmented bowls. The first photo of a segmented bowl in the AAW Journal was controversial because most woodturners didn't think that this was "woodturning". I don't remember how many times I heard the comment, "This is nice work, but it isn't woodturning", from folks at club meetings, galleries, and the person doing the critique at an AAW Symposium (Yes, THE Symposium). I heard this same thing said by one of the elders of the AAW as recent as 2-years ago. And, it wasn't that long ago that my segmented entry into an AAW exhibit was rejected because it "doesn't represent any of the new and growing trends in woodturning art".

A major magazine editorial at the time said that "segmented" was something for beginners who didn't have access to real wood, and that they would abandon it as they became more profficient at woodturning and gathering wood.

Fortunately for those who make segmented bowls, times have changed. In spite of those who wanted it otherwise, segmented bowls are now an accepted form of our art; and neither the AAW nor woodturning have suffered. I am sure woodturning and the AAW will survive this new "Age of Enhancement" as well.

Mark mentioned my polychromatic platters. I am still being told that they are not "woodturning" by folks who occupy far higher positions in the woodturning world than I.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#2

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturn

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Russ, You are absolutely right. If it is turned it is wood turning regardless how it is enhansed.

I just refinished a large segment bowl for a friend that was given to her at her wedding in England 50 years ago.

Norm

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#3

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturn

Fred Bearman

>Maybe this "old vs. new" argument is the ultimate answer as to whether what we do is art or not. These kinds of discussions have been going on in the world of art for centuries. Maybe this only means that we have truly arrived .

A number of years ago I was very heavily into photography. I entered a fairly major exhibition, was accepted, and was thrilled to have my work hung. My major disappointment was in not winning Best of Show (or whatever they called it at the time) - that went to a black and white picture of a plate of spaghetti - a very well exposed, very well focused picture, but that was it. That photograph was judged the best and most artistic by the "judges." On the other hand, by the judges that actually count, I sold every photograph that I had in the exhibit as well as ones that I had not entered. The "winner" didn't manage to sell even the one that took best of show. This leads to my three points (which I think have already been made in one way of another):

1. You need to be happy with your work.

2. If you are selling your work, your customers need to be happy with it.

3. Meaningful dialog with others can help us all grow, but flat out negative statements and nitpicking don't benefit anybody.

I don't like everything that I see in the woodturning world, but I don't like everything that I see in other media either. But even those that I don't care for at least give me the occasion to ponder what it is that I don't like, not that that really matters. Whether I like something or not has nothing to do with whether it is valid - it only has to do with my personal taste (which some may question anyway). When looked at honestly, sometimes I think that my dislike is more related to some sort of inner jealousy that I know that I don't have the talent required for a particular embellishment or whatever.

Just my 0.02 from the rapidly cooling locale of Michigan.

Fred Bearman

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#4

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturn

TDaniel

>well said

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#5

Steven Antonucci

You said a mouthful at the end!

steve antonucci

>"I am still being told that they are not "woodturning" by folks who occupy far higher positions in the woodturning world than I."

I didn't realize that we all had positions in the woodturning world?

I've noticed that "segmented" doesn't only apply to bowls in woodturning. Seems turners themselves are "segmented" along many different line (art vs. craft, embellished vs not...)

I see Terry original point, which is very well taken. If something only spent 5 minutes on the lathe and two days to create, is it woodturning? I'd agree with Terry that it's a debatable subject.

It doesn't mean that I dislike something if it isn't 100% turned, it's just that we have a habit in America of abusing our language. I spent 4 years in college getting my degree in Electrical Engineering, and the janitor at my son's school is called a maintenance engineer. Anyone that works with computers is called a network engineer or a systems engineer. Why? Because it pays more.

Maybe woodturning has "made it" as a recognized art form, and because of this, is worth more than "wood art."

Steve

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#6

Well said

John Lucas

>

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#7

Re: Old vs. ..........Caution /Rant ;)

Hooligan

>I agree wholly. When first I started turning, I started on moderate sized blanks, and things in the nature of shallow bowls. They weren't really bowls, so I was told, because they didn't always maintain a curve, some had a straight flare, that sort of thing.

As time went on, and I prgressed, I turned a lot of deeper more ogee style bowls, many semi-enclosed, the sort that take you a lot of time to really decide if you like the form or not, and end up making 15 changes at the lathe.

As I sit now, the number one shape for me, is the shallow, nearly non existent curve. That flare going down to a 4" foot provides a look of elegance, a look that is often unmatched. I've sold bowls up to 10K, and when I started, I was told that they would never sell, that is not what people wanted.

Much of what our art is (though I don't consider myself an artist), is in the mind of the buyer, or end user. I've given up caring what the people with a much more important in the woodturning world than me have to say. I don't mind an honest critique on my piece, but I dislike it when it is to be compared to Raffan, Hosaluk, Osolnik......catch my drift? Its all about what the form is, in and of itself, not about who they think it looks like. I think that they are phenomenal turners, turners who I can only strive to accomplish what they have, yet, I am not them. I am my own, I have my own style, my own technique, and my own preferences.

I think that many, many times, people (within the turning worls) tend to want to look at something, and compare it to something else, rather than look at a piece for its own merits. I have seen people compare work on hollow formes from one person to those of another, and the two shared nothing in common, had no intent to be similar, but the "judge" thought that was what it should have been. I couldn't disagree more. For that matter, there is little that I find irritating as much.

I really wanted to lash a judge recently, accusing someone of trying to "copy" the similarities of another piece, but they were "totally different". If they were really that different, do you think the intent was to be similar in the first place? Or was that some sort of selective perception on HIS part to sate his desire to not really see the piece on its own, for its own merits, and judge it accordingly? All too often we are searching for a point of reference, that isn't there. We tend to look for something that we don't need to be looking for, and we tend to find things that aren't really close to what we should be seeing.

Sorry for the rant, but it is something that often bothers me, and I disagree hearitly.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#8

Re: You said a mouthful at the end!

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Steve,

Well said.

One aside - computer guys/network engineer. I worked 4 years and countless proficiency tests to get my certification as a Master Certified Novell Engineer - one of only 20,000 worldwide. Yet HR departments do not want to call me an engineer because they would need to pay too much. Instead I am a Manager, or a Technician, or a Specialist or a support analyst so they can pay less.

It works both ways.

Mark

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#9

Re: You said a mouthful at the end!

Russ Fairfield

>In many States it is illegal to use the word "Engineer" in the title or desription of anyone who is not a Licensed Professional Engineer in that State. This applies to both individuals and companies. AL, GA, and FL are three of them that I know of.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#10

With respect to the "art" element...

Craig Daymon

>...a good friend of mine is a sculptor, found object sculptures. He creates some wonderful pieces and is extremely knowledgable about art. I've attended several openings with him and when I would blurt out that something was not "art", his comment would be that if the artist calls it "art", it's "art".

All the rest comes down to a matter of opinion. Whether you think it is GOOD art or BAD art and, even if you don't think it is good art, do you like it.

Though, I will say that I thought I heard a VERY BAD argument for certain inclusions into the Woodturning circle at the 2006 symposium. There was a piece that had nothing at all turned on it. The argument was being made that we had to open up to such things if we wanted the AAW to continue to grow. Well, if it's not at least partially turned, it has NOTHING to do with Woodturning, so go start a different group, "Wood Artists" or some such. Don't try and tell me the AAW should support non-turned objects in order to maintain growth.

-Craig

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#11

Brad Vietje

Yet Another Good Discussion

Brad Vietje

>I have been following the Art vs Craft discussions for some time, as well as the sometimes testy exchange a few days ago about the lack of high-quality, finely turned, un-embellished bowls being showcased in the American Woodturner and other journals. I agree with TD in many respects -- a finely crafted, well-designed bowl is a beautiful thing to behold, and nowhere near as easy to pull off as it would appear. It takes a high level of skill and good sense of design to get it just right, while there are hundreds and hundreds of "almost, but not quite" bowls out there (I call 'em "swing -- and a miss !" bowls), and like most people, I've made quite a few, and learned a thing or two in doing so...

What I don't agree with is the perception (may not be TD's opinion, either) that embellished turnings that are sculpted, carved, burned, textured and or painted aren't also part of woodturning, so long as the lathe is the principal woodworling tool. As Terry pointed out earlier, balance is what is needed, since these embellished turnings are not representative of the whole scope of woodturning. If someone submits a beautiful Bob Stocksdale-esque bowl, is that not up there with the finest woodturning has to offer ? I say it is, and I think most would agree.

The issue seems to be who's in the driver's seat, deciding what is worthy of inclusion in the AAW journal and other publications (as well as juried art/craft shows)? If the AAW is US, and the journal is OUR journal (I gotta be gentle here, as my membership has lapsed !), what level of editorial control should WE have in deciding the trends and the focus of the photo spreads ? Maybe none; or perhaps, if we are disgruntled, a letter-writing campaign to the editors would bring some of the balance Terry seeks.

My 3 cents,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#12

Re: Yet Another Good Discussion

John Lucas

>Brad (and others) I suspect what often happens in American Woodturner and the woodturning magazines is the editor can only choose from works (and articles) sent in by the readers. If they only have highly decorated and carved pieces to choose from, that's what will get published. I think we owe it to ourselves to send in photos of "traditional" turnings if there is such a thing, so the editor, and the AAW staff who help, have more to choose from. It's not an easy job being an editor and trying to get quality articles and photos to choose from. The worst problem has been poor quality photos submitted. If the photo is lousy or low resolution it doesn't matter how good the piece is, it won't get published.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#13

Exactly

TDaniel

>Today I drove a couple hundred miles thru several small towns. I saw signs such as "Auto Doctor", "Auto Spa", and such. Do we really take our cars to a doctor? When our cars need a wash job do we really take them to a spa? We are abusing our language. What is wrong with taking our cars to a gargage or a carwash? What is wrong with calling an item turned on a lathe a "turning" and an item carved a "carving"?

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#14

Re: Yet Another Good Discussion

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>Being a relative newbie (2 years) to turning, I have concentrated mostly on the basic bowl - no real embellishments yet. However, my biggest problem with some of the "new" work is that sometimes you can't tell it is wood, or whether it was actually turned at some point in its life. I've seen hollow vessels that were so heavily painted with auto lacquer that they look like plastic instead of wood, and artistic pieces that don't appear to have ever touched a lathe. I really like the sight of a nicely grained piece of wood turned in such a way to enhance the grain and celebrate the beauty of the wood itself. Does that make me too much of a traditionalist for the AAW?

Hope I'm not stepping on too many toes here.

Scott

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#15

Re: Exactly

Russ Fairfield

>Terry, they can charge more for some words than others.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#16

Re: Yet Another Good Discussion

john lucas

>Not at all Scott. I think you will find that every turner regardless of stature loves good wood and likes to see people do wonderful things with it.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#17

Re: Old vs. ..........Caution /Rant ;)

Ruth Niles

>Good post.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#18

Keith Tompkins

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturn

Keith Tompkins

>WHY ARE SO MANY PEOPLE AFRAID OF A LITTLE THREE-LETTER WORD.....ART?

We're told the lathe is a tool that allows the operator to express their creativity.....after all, when was the last time you heard someone refer to table-saw art or drill press art?... Jointer art?

A lathe-turned object makes a wonderful "canvas" for those wishing to express their creativity in wood. THAT is why turning is so popular. WOOD ART has its roots in turning.

I have a fairly extensive library of woodworking books, art books, turning books and magazines, as well as design and architecture books. Yet, after studying them for years, I still cannot find the RULE that says a turned object may not be carved, textured, or whatever, in any way. While looking in vain for the rule, I happened to stumble upon museum-quality furniture pieces with exquisitly turned, carved, and fluted columns, legs, and bases.

Here's my point...carving and turning have complimented each other for centuries. THEREFORE, it would be in keeping with tradition to apply carving to your turnings as well. Those who rail against all of the "artists" who are carving up perfectly good turnings are the ones who are going against tradition, as I see it. The Shakers and the Pennsylvania Dutch (and Germans) have been painting their furniture for centuries as well. So, feel free to paint your turnings...you're in good company. It's the traditional thing to do.

As I have heard time and time again....there is nothing new under the sun. If that's true, then cut, burn, paint, carve, pierce or whatever to your heart's content. It's all been done before. Now, where did I put that hatchet?

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#19

Re: Old vs. ..........Caution /Rant ;)

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Fantastic Post - Well said.

Mark

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#20

Ouch!!

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#21

How did we get to art?

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

Are you implying that, somehow, if the turner "cuts, burns, paints, carves, pierces ", he/she has suddenly started to product art, whereas, if he was "just" turning, it would be a craft? If that was your meaning, I have to disagree with you. All that has been done is to add one craft (i.e., cutting, burning, painting, carving, piercing) to another, and just the fact that he has done so, does not make it art. Actually, I wish it did, because that would make it easy for me to call myself an artist, and, as an added bonus, to really get Grumbine's goat, by calling myself an artiste! Would that it were so easy.

An unrelated observation that I have noticed by looking at the work on WoW is that there is a divergence in the work produced by turners from the US and N. America (I don't know enough about Europe to comment), and that from Australia and New Zealand. In the case of some of the most interesting work coming from the Americas, one often asks the question, "Is this a turning?", or, "What percentage of the work here is turning?" It is very interesting (and, perhaps, inexplicable) that remarkable work from Australia and New Zealand is very clearly turned. Even if it is carved, the customer, even the unsophisticaed one, would immediately recognize it as a turning. While there are obviously exceptions on both sides, in general, it seems to me that the NZ/Aussie turners have made great strides within the confines of turning, whereas we seem to have moved out of its realm. I'm not making a judgement call one way or the other as to which is better, but just something that had caught my eye.

Dinyar

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#22

LOL Mark :)

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio!

>

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#23

Re: From my point of view, here in ...

Jamie Donaldson

>... Kentucky, center of the universe(if you're a horse!)I think some of the most innovative turnings are coming from the Aussie/NZ folks, and the more radical turning as a part(sometimes very small!) of the creative process are the creations of the small cadre of innovative N.Am. artists. I have been disturbed at some few of the juried entries in recent AAW shows that seem to have never visited a lathe, and I believe that the jury process should hold true to the emphasis as turnings. That does not diminish the discussion of whether it is ART, but emphasis is on the visual fact that it is "turner ART!"

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#24

Re: From my point of view, here in ...

Leslie S

>Hi,

Can't we just call carved, pierced, painted, partially turned items, embellished turnings? Just like you call paintings with more than one medium "Mixed Media?" Personally, being newish to the turning world it all interests me. If I didn't see all the things within the turning world I couldn't chose the things that interest me. I'm not copying but being infuluenced. Also, as an Art History major, art vs craft is an ongoing, growing conversation that ruffles feathers whenever the debate begins. I believe that art evokes an emotional response. Negative or positive, if you are involed emotionally you react emotionally. It's all good, I have very much enjoyed the threads about this.

Re: Old vs. New is not a new arguement in woodturning

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: How did we get to art?

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Dinyar, if all those embellished turnings are not art after all, that's even better! Follow the logic: Those who made period pieces were considered CRAFTSMEN. They embellished turnings and flat surfaces with carving, and many applied complex finishes such as gold leaf, faux woodgraining, etc. They dyed and bleached wood, and painted it as well. So: If we want to carve and paint, there is a rich history of this to support the claim that we are craftsmen. Therefore, we are FREE! Free to hack away at our turnings without fear of the dreaded ART label. (I'm being only semi-serious here :)

Hey, I think I just ended the debate of art v craft!