We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I'm proud to be a founding member of AAW since it was formed. I have most all the issues of the AAW American Woodturner including the first. I have enjoyed the articles about woodturning as well as the projects. Some of them are more contempary than I what I would do, who knows? The insurance is great as I do demonstrate. I think all of those who calls themselves woodturners should belong. It seems to me it is the magazine has been the glue that has helped the organization grow. I have read about many of the people on this discussion group over the years. I have supported AAW by also forming 4 interest groups on the web, one of those long before this one existed. I do many aspects of woodturner and have no voice. So hang in there turner the best is yet to come. GT
>Yes and not just because it's a requirement of our chapter because I was a member even before the requirement. I think the magazine is wonderul but the support that turners can get through the chapter program is where I think the biggest benefit is. Belonging to an AAW chapter and the support those chapters give to the turner is the is the real glue that has united turners in recent years.
>I joined the local club in order to gain exposure to and education about woodturning.
1) The local club requires AAW membership.
2) I enjoy the magazine - though still personally working on "fair curves," I like to see what others are doing, consider what I have yet to learn, and imagine "how'd they do that."
3) As club treasurer, I appreciate the liability insurance.
And about that flimsy membership card - 'round here Woodcraft and Rockler offer a small discount when it is presented.
>I support the organization because it helps support woodturning. Woodturning has changed my life and I want to pass it on. I look at the money for membership as helping someone else so the magazine is free in my way of looking.
>I'm somewhat in disagreement with the direction the AAW has taken, and don't feel like it offers much to me personally. But membership is required for inclusion in the local club, and I would be sorry to loose that opportunity to share and exchange with that local bunch of great people so I continue to re-inlist.
>Yes I am a member and enjoy both the local and national organization. This flies in the face of my personal motto: "I would never belong to any club that would have me as a member."
>...and let's not forget the wonderful grants that are awarded every year! I was the lucky recipient of one a few years ago and that has made my membership dues well worth the price of admission.
>Lawyers, doctors and people of the cloth are a terrible group ...until you need one.
I belong to AAW, enjoy the magazine, website and symposia. I remember the isolation and fractured sharing before AAW drew us together, but I have long since lost interest in 'going up thru the chairs'. I appreciate those who do the work knowing that I couldn't do as well. It seems to me that most of the published articles are written by turners not by Pulitzer Prize winners. If anyone deplores a wrong direction taken or a failure to include a perceived important point they should submit a corrective article and not complain til it's rejected without explanation.
I do note (without an opinion) a trend common to most growing professional and/or technical organizations: ie. they become more like publishing houses and purveyors of memorabilia than was their original intent.
Best regards to both sides of this discussion, Arch
>Yes I am a member. I am also a member of two local chapters, one in which I helped to create. I have also been the recipient of an educational grant to help in purchasing equipment for teaching woodturning through the Artisans Center of Virginia. One of my younger students (16) just received a grant to pay for a week of tutoring from Fred Williamson, a wonderful teacher.
I ran for the AAW Board last year and probably will again in the future. I truly believe that the AAW will continue to grow and it's leadership will be able to satisfy the majority of it's member's needs.
>Was a member for 3 years, then went through a tough year nursing my dad, another AAW member, who was dying of cancer, and another getting my finances back in order. Now I have no excuse, and need to re-join -- for all the right reasons. It's a great organization, chock full of the nicest people one could hope to meet, and an organization worthy of our (my) support.
Actually, our chapter requires it for demonstrators but I also look forward to the Journal. I first joined in '88, if memory serves me right but some years I didn't renew when money was very tight.
>My attitude about membership is the same as voting. If we are a member, we have the right to complain, contribute, vote, and run for office. If we aren't a member, we have nothing to complain about. It's that simple.
The AAW and I started seriously turning wood at about the same time. In the beginning, our interests were the same. Bowls were a new adventure for me and there were a lot of bowls in the magazine. It isn't the AAW's fault that they have moved on to other things while I am still trying to make the perfect bowl. Some would say I am a slow learner, but I like to think of it as being my choice; and I can't blame the AAW for that.
It is a matter of perspective whether there are enough "beginner" articles in the AAW Journal. From mine, there are too many. It is also a matter of perspective whether there are sufficient bowls represented in the Journal. From mine, there are enough bowls, and more would be too many.
Bowls are everywhere. If I want to see more bowls, there is an abundance of information in other publications and on the Internet. If I want to talk about bowls, there are other woodturners everywhere who are making them and willing to share their tyechniques. If I want to touch bowls, they are as close as any gallery or the local club meeting.
>I am a member at present but like Terry have some issues with AAW that really have me debating my renewal.
Things I like:
My fellow members. AAW trying to get tool names consistent (even if I did not receive a reply from Alan Lacer when I emailed him offering to help as requested in Journal) AAW helping with insurance. The tips section with John Lucas and the quick responses from John when I submitted ideas!
Things I have problems with:
AAW refusing to define Woodturning and allowing pieces that have more work done off the lathe than on it be declared a woodturning. AAW allowing access to Journal, Forums, etc to non members at members expense. Journal not really covering what interest me and yes I offered idea for an artice (see next paragraph).
Lack of responses from AAW staff and directors - I emailed editor twice with an idea for an article (per web instructions) and NEVER got a response (would Terry have gotten one?). I received an almost immediate response from Joe Hermann with Woodturning Design so they got the article submission. See note above about tool name issue response. I also emailed all directors and officers last year with concerns on the Woodturning definition - I had ONE Director take the time to respond and got a "canned" answer from the President. I understand volunteering to be a Director/officer and time issues, but does it really take a lot of time to acknowledge receipt of an email and note you will take it into consideration???
Will I renew:
Probably by the end of the year but I am really having to ask myself if it is worth it considering my work schedule will not allow attending the symposium.
>I am a member of the AAW. I joined right after buying my first lathe. I found my local chapter through the AAW. Even though membership in the national organization is required in my chapter, I was already a national member before joining the local chapter. I enjoy the magazine, I read all the articles, like looking at all the work, the traditional and the non-traditional, even if I don't like it. I attended my first symposium this year and loved every second of it. It will be a highlight in my year from now on. What an amazing learning experience.
I am glad I joined, will continue to be a member, and will encourage others to join.
>You and TD share the same problem. You have a difference of opinion with the Directors of the AAW and a complaint about it's personnel. As a member, you can vote them out of office; or you can run for office. As a non-member, all you can do is complain and throw rocks, and nobody will listen.
As a member, you are helping to pay for all of those good things that the AAW brings to woodturning. As a non-member, you are getting a free ride.
>I like Barb's suggestion that it is better to improve an organization from the inside rather from outside. I have even been contemplating joining the Democratic party.
>Allen You need to move Man. Just kidding. Start your own group. We did that in cookeville and Crossville, Tn because it was 96 miles to one club and 98 in the other direction to the other. We started the Crossville club which was 37 miles away and then 3 years ago started the Cookeville club in my backyard. So now I have 2 groups of turners close buy and even though i've been turning for 20 years I learn something almost every club meeting. cool people,turners.