We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I would like to clear up a question that has arisen in a couple of forums about the Oland tool. If you do not care ignore me. I have nothing to sell but I respect a turner who liked to help others. When Knud Oland designed this tool back in the 70's he wanted one that anyone could make in the home shop. He also wanted a cutting tool. Most look at the Oland and think it is a scraper. This may be because it looks like an Ellsworth (a good firend of Knud Oland's) scraper for the inside of hollow forms. There are a couple of short videos here of the tool in action.
http://aroundthewoods.com/oland.shtml#ol1
My apologies for the web page. It was one of my early ones and it needs an extensive rewrite.
>.. that there is a cutting/ scraping difference between the Oland and Ellsworth tools? Knud was my first formal teacher in 1986 and I did a workshop at David Ellsworth's in 1990, so I am well acquainted with and still use their tools. They are very similar in design and use, and are sharpened alike- the only significant difference it in how the 3/16" bits are attached to the tool shafts.
The Oland tool appears to be the same as a so-called "straight" hollowing tool. These are normally considered to be "scrapers". Are they ground differently or is it just that when you use such a tool rubbing the bevel it becomes a cutting tool? It was my understanding that when one uses a scraper on the bevel, they become very catchy. If so, what makes the Oland tool "forgiving"? TIA for your comments.
>Allow me to try an answer if I may--The difference between using the same tool shape as a scraper or a cutting tool as I see it, is simply technique and tool control.
As a cutting tool with the bevel rubbing, you have control of the Oland tool and can manipulate it to keep the tool from catching just as you do with a gouge.
Using that same tool in scraper mode, we intentionally deny ourselves that control so that the cutting edge can be presented at the same position (on center, for example) of the work wherever you may be cutting. Ellsworth's tools are fairly flexible in this regard, but the Jamieson bar and other captured toolrest systems are good examples where this lack of control is built-in.
Thanks for your thoughts. I agree with you. My question is one of degree.
It seems to me that 'some people' (whoever that might be) have said that scrapers are very catchy when used on-bevel. Here, the Oland tool is said to be, in effect, very forgiving. I say you can't have your cake and eat it too. Which is it?
Your answer may be something to the effect that "any tool is catchy if used improperly and any tool is not catchy if used properly". That's obvious too. What I REALLY want to know is where on the scale of 'catchy' is the Oland tool REALLY, for, say, an "advanced novice" turner -- the type of person who still has to be concerned about such things.
>... "catchy" as Ellsworth and other similar tools- they are sharpened and used exactly alike. The main difference is in the offset or angled shaft tools- Oland didn't make an angled shaft tool, which by nature is potentially more "catchy," and that is a reality of physics. I use Knud's 3/4" shaft tool with the angled bit a lot to this day, but it cannot reach into the deeper shoulder areas of hollow vessels with small openings as can the angled shaft tools. And Knud never intended his tools be used as bevel rubbing cutters-the 3/16" cutting bit is just too small for that use.
>Gary, I started turning 30 months ago. I began looking for tools to supplement my Sears set that came with my first lathe. I happened onto Darrell Feltmates pages, and voila! I had found THE PLACE! Until this past May, the only tools I turned bowls, vases, and hollow forms with were my homemade Oland Tools. I have 6 or 8 different modifications of the one shown on Darrell's Site. When I went to the Georgia Symposium people were calling them 'scrapers', and that surprised me. I have a couple that might be called scrapers, but I also have some that are cutters... I think it depends on how you sharpen the end of the cutting tip... (my opinion).
They are way up the scale, in my book, because they are super easy to control, and I rarely get catches with them. When I'm using my bowl gouge, if I have a difficult spot on a piece that I'm working on, I'll grab my Oland tool. It gets me through the difficult spot, and then I go back to my gouge.
>tomorrow, and post them to this thread. However, explaining how I use them is another story. :o) I have a hard time trying to tell my own name sometimes, let alone explaining how I make a cut. :o)
I'll see if I can get a decent shot in my shop, with several of them together. The tool handles are all different, too, but I think I posted a shot of my rolling tool rack here a while back.
>can line these up, as bad as I shake. I'll try to explain a little about how they cut, Left to right: The two on the left are harder than plain HSS, (they were my Dad's) and I use them for cutting turquoise, inside (1st) and outside (2nd) of pieces, while riding the bevel, and creeping up on the stone, trying to hold the cutting tip at about 45 degrees.
The third and sixth are made especially for cutting small coves, very light cuts, holding the tip of the cutting edge at about 45 degrees, and these are the two that I get catches with more than any others, but that's due to my quivering hands.
The fourth one is beveled about an inch along the right edge (left side in pic). I used it to do light (angel hair) finishing cuts, riding the bevel, near the chuck, on the bottom of bowls, and near the top of flared-top vases. (also at about 45 degree angle to the direction of the travel of the wood).
The fifth and the seventh (3/8") I use for roughing or rounding out a piece of stock.
The eighth one is beveled about 3/4 inch along the left edge (facing you). I used it for light (angel hair) finishing cuts on the top shoulders of forms, on the lip of bowls and hollowforms.
The ninth one I use on the inside edge/lip of bowls, forms, vases, etc., and I've also used it for boring holes about a half inch deep in the center of pieces to begin another pass when deepening some forms. (It was handy).
I don't use all of these, all the time, now that I have a bowl gouge (turned for two years without one), but many times I will still grab for one of these if it seems to work better for me. All of them will scrape unless you make them cut, and you can make them cut. These that I use for the "angel hair" cuts are easier for me to use than a bowl gouge, in some cases.
Hope this makes sense to you. Like I said before, sometimes I have a hard time explaining things.
>I've never tried to use a "straight hollowing" tool (which most people use as a scraper) on bevel, but it sounds like it will be "educational". Just for fun, I think I'll try it (very carefully) and see what happens. It never hurts to have a new trick. Thanks for the thoughts and ideas. ...Gary
>Gary and Jamie, watch Darrell's video. It plainly shows using an Oland Tool while riding the bevel. I think it must be a 3/8 or 1/2 inch cutter, and he doesn't even have it slanted to 45 degrees. He's really putting out some shavings with it. :o)
>Sorry to be so long getting back here guys. The day job interferes with this side of life and I spent a lot of time in hospital lately with a dying woman and her family. Great folks. Turning is a grace of God to keep a person centered sometimes. Anyway, the Oland tool. Thanks for posting those videos links Alan. I was not sure if anyone ever watched them :-) Jamie, the big difference between the Ellsworth tools and the Oland tools are the tip configuations. I use both by the way. On the Ellsworth you use a tip grind of about 70* and bring it in as a scraper. On the Oland, you grind it back at 45* and ride the bevel. I use two grinds mostly on the Oland. One is rounded on the end and the other more pointed, sort of like the ground back wings on an Irsih grind bowl gouge. When I started to make and use them, Mrs Oland told me they were to be used on the bevel and cutting. They certainly make the shavings fly.