Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Tonight's Topic

Posts

Tonight's Topic

#1

Tonight's Topic

TDaniel

>Following up on a thread this week......my latest piece of turned art. Please see the pic attached. Note the compressor and the pump were turned. This comprises about 5% of the total piece which is about as much lathe use as some of the other things I have seen posted. So, is this piece a woodturning? Is it wood art? Is it art? Or is it craft? Is it pushing the limits of woodturning....or does it go beyond the limits? What are the limits? Join us at 9pm eastern for some discussion on who sets the limits and how limits are set.

TD


img

Re: Tonight's Topic

#2

Re: Where is the message??

Russ Fairfield

>"Art" has to have a message. If the message isn't obvious, then you will have to write one, preferrably a long one, to explain your intent without offending anyone. Such a piece of "art" must have a long list of contributors, sources, and influences, lest you be accused of "plagiarism".

The only message I get from this is a reminder that I am old enough to remember places like this one, and that I bought a brand new truck that looked just like that one. But, there is a problem with that message. It is not "correct" to remind older people that they are getting older? Have you no sensitivity to our self esteem?? {8>)

Re: Tonight's Topic

#3

Should be interesting *LINK*

Ron in Drums PA

>I bet Garrison Keiller's "A Prairie Home Companion" gave you the inspiration for this!


A Prairie Home Companion

Re: Tonight's Topic

#4

Re: Should be interesting

Cyril Griesbach

>I believe TD's point is...is this turned art even though only about 1% of it involves turning.

Re: Tonight's Topic

#5

Re: Should be interesting

John Lucas

>I don't see that it makes a difference to me unless it's for competition. If a piece is only 1% turned I can still enjoy looking at it and appreciating the techniques. The same is true with the Art vs craft argument. I don't really care as long as I enjoy looking at it.

Now if it's a turning competition then the rules need to spell out how much after turning work can be done and still be called turned work.

I don't know if I'll make the chat tonight I have a lot of shop work to do. If I make good progress early I'll try to be here. If not you guys have a good time.

Re: Tonight's Topic

#6

Steven Antonucci

You mean the truck isn't an eccentric turning?

steve antonucci

>

Re: Tonight's Topic

#7

Re: Where is sensitivity ?

Bill Crommett

>Russ : You are compleely off base when you castigate Terry about lack of sensitivity to the older people. Most of us older people wallow in the pleasure of reaching the ripe age of whatever. It is usually better than the alternative. Now, reminding someone of reaching middle age is a different insult, particularly in this age of youth worship.

Re: Tonight's Topic

#8

Russ- You bought a truck without a hood?

Steve Mushinski

>

Re: Tonight's Topic

#9

it has a hood :)

TDaniel

>

Re: Tonight's Topic

#10

That proves it is art...

Brian Hahn in SW Wisconsin

>...because Art doesn't have to be politically correct and it can have unpleasant messages. QED as they used to say in some class I once took.

Re: Tonight's Topic

#11

See?

TDaniel

>It evokes an emotion therefore it is an art piece! It also makes a statement: The old stuff is still around and still running while much of the new stuff is worn out. Was it turned with the lathe stopped or with the piece spinning? Well, part of it was made with the lathe spinning. So I guess this is a woodturning, right? The whole thing may sound stupid but no more stupid than some other pieces I have seen called "woodturnings". Why do we want to screw up our language so some can claim a new "voice" in the woodturning arena?

Re: Tonight's Topic

#12

Re: See?

John Lucas

>TD What happens if I put it on the lathe but never turn it on, just use it as a convenient holding device. Of course I could turn it on slow speed to dry whatever finish I'm using. :) Then I'd be able to call it a woodturning.

Re: Tonight's Topic

#13

Re: Tonight's Topic

Lan Brady

>If the tractor was a Ford 8N, It would be a picture of my Grand Fathers garage.

I don't care if its art or not, I like it!

Lan

Re: Tonight's Topic

#14

Re: Tonight's Topic

TDaniel

>Lan, I had to replace the truck that came with it with as close as I could get to my 55. As soon as I can find an old red belly tractor I will replace that too. I did not make this old garage; just thought it tied in with the current debate on what is turned art. I bought it at the Whistle Stop in Franklin, NC. The old garage stirs my emotions so I guess it is art? Some turnings involved so I guess that makes it turned art?

Re: Tonight's Topic

#15

TD when did you...

Bob Fawcett

>hang that shell sign over your shop? :-)

Re: Tonight's Topic

#16

Now that was funny!

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>It was there all the time Bob....you don't remember it?

:)

Re: Tonight's Topic

#17

session log?

Leppikallio

>Is there some sort of log of this chat session? It must have been interesting session, unfortunately I was probably still sleeping at that time (9 pm EST).

Re: Tonight's Topic

#18

no, it was not logged this time

TDaniel

>