Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Posts

Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#1

Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>As most of you know from a previous thread, I bought a Cryosteel bowl gouge at Louisville and received one about month later. For the last several weeks I have been comparing it against a couple of other gouges I have. These are my IMPRESSIONS Your mileage may vary.

I have been turning 3 segmented bowls - all made with Yellowheart, and Bloodwood (Bloodwood has a high silica contant and is vary abrasive). One of the bowls also has some Ebony in it. Each bowl is identical in size and basic shape. Each had a test gouge associated with it 1) Sweezey 1/2", 2) Red Handled (newer flute)

Glaser 1/2", and 3) a Cryo 3/8" with a black coating on it.

Black Coating? When I contacted Cryosteel about the status of my order they were still working on the AAW Anniversary gouges and they asked if I would like to try a 3/8" bowl prototype gouge that was ready. Then when my 1/2" was ready they would send it, and I could send the 3/8" back or buy it, my choice. This gouge has a black coating on it, similar to the gold coating you see on some drill bits. They wanted to know how it held up to sharpening (if the coating is rubbed off and looked ugly, etc, under normal usage). I said sure, why not.

So straight up, the test was not equal, draw what conclusion you want with a 3/8" against 1/2" gouges.

As we used to say in the Army - Bottomline up front: It is my experience/impression that the Cryo's edge lasted about 30% longer than the Glaser, which was about 10-20% better than Sweazey. How did I gauge it? Since I am doing segments, I could count the number of layers I could put on and turn round inside and out, and down to thickness before each gouge "just had to be sharpened". In my cutting I use the tip, the side, shear scrape, ...whatever is needed, but they were all treated the same. All had the same grind. Exact figures - I don't have any - just what I felt.

I had to learn to firmly hand tighten the gouge into the handle, or it could start to rotate - with bad consequences, but a firm hand tightening was all that was needed. The blackcoating is holding up to the sharpening jig, dulled a little but still cool looking. Without being able to test it against another 3/8" regular Cryo, I have no idea how the coating is effecting the longevity of the edge. I love the look of it though. Think of Black Chrome.

How did it feel with the different tool shaft shape - not much difference that I could tell, though I did feel that I was able to hang it a little longer off the rest. It is also marginally deader against the rest.

Feel of the handle - same as the red Glaser, which was new to me as well. Believe it or not, the Glaser/Cryosteel are lighter than my regular bowl gouges w/ Oneway or lead filled Bosch handles, but they are fine, and like others, I do like the fact that they are less likely to roll off the lathe.

A recent conversation (email) w/ the CEO of Cryosteel revealed that they are finishing up the 1000 gouges ordered by the AAW (a thousand of any gouge by anybody, I would think is a pretty big job). He told me that Packard, Highland Hardware, and Cutting Edge will be carrying them. He said that Cutting Edge just got some, though I do not know if those are the new Blue Cryos or Red Glasers. I am no reporter, so I did not confirm with those companies.

Please Folks, I am just telling fellow turners my experience. I have no commercial connection with CET. I paid for every tool I have. I am not commenting on any of their business dealings nor pricing.

Since I do not know the final pricing, I cannot tell you whether the new gouges will be worth the price. I like mine, but is certainly will not the only gouge in my arsenal. I love playing with different tools.

Mark

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#2

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Allen Neighbors

>Mark, thanks for reporting on the new gouges. I appreciate your taking the time.

Allen

PS: I'm still thinking about a Sweazey!

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#3

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

George Van

>Thank you Mark for the evaluation. It is always nice to be kept up to date on the new items available from a woodturners view rather than the manufacturer.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#4

Mark, could you

Terry Quiram, Roanoke Illinois

>bring the gouge to Ray's in Oct? Would it be possible to test drive it?

Terry

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#5

Mark ?

Bob Fawcett

>One of the gouges in your comments is a red handle Glaser with new flute. What is the difference between the new flute and the previous?

I have a red handle Glaser, that I think was made by Jerry. Mine has the lead shot sealed into the handle with what looks like an automotive freeze plug. This is just a metal cap with no provision to remove it. You would have to pierce the plug and pull it out with a screw. Hope this description is understandable. I understand that the ones Cryo makes have a screw in cap, but I have never seen one.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#6

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

justwannaturn

>I'm curious why 30% is worth twice the cost of a gouge?? 1/3 doesn't equal x2. Not worth it. I'm not getting into a cost issue but a steel. If this is a necessity, people need to learn to sharpen better and more efficiently. In my opinion I don't know if the tools as a whole, Kryo/2030/2060, are going the right direction. Unless you're Mahoney or a full time production woodturner I don't think its valid. When I say production, I mean PRODUCTION. Again, I'm not talking about cost or CET costs etc. It's outrageous, none of us will say nice price. But more of a steel topic?? M2 has made turning what it is today. Is it the best?

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#7

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>I have 15 or so different pieces I use for this type of remount. Even thjough I never use a glue block the method is the same.

My fixtures are made of scrap wood with a tennon on one end. Each time I use them I re true if required. Insert the fixture through the hole and against the bottom of the hollow form. For larger forms I use a a kitchen hot pad inside and on small like yours I use nothing. Slide it in, lightly bring up the tail stock and do a slight back and forth rotation to center the fixture inside and tighten up lightly. If the bowl does not have a flat inside bottom try to match the fixture shape. Rember to maintain most of the pressure inside on the center and not the walls of the form. The walls only maintain the straight line of the form to the lathe headstock. Lightly turn away the glue block and sand off the center tip that is left.

Good turning and be safe.

Bill in Casa Grande, AZ.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#8

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Sorry

This got on the wrong Post.

It belongs on Reverse Mount

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#9

Re: Mark, could you

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Sure, I don't know why not.

Mark

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#10

Re: Mark ?

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>As you said, the newer CET made red handled Glaser line has a screw in plug on the bottom, and the lead shot is in a removable plastic tube.

Flute - look at a Sorby, and you will see the same flute. I heard Stuart Batty say a couple of years ago that he would like to change the V shaped flute to a more of a U. I guess that is one of the changes made while he was still consulting for them.

Mark

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#11

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Paulo Marin

>I think it is important for me to set the record straight in relationship to the price CryOSteel gouges will command. The answer is WE DO NOT KNOW YET. To assume that 30% is not worth the cost is not the right thing to do, especially when you should look at the entire package. The gouge is modular, the steel is better, it definitely has better wear resistance, it looks great, it does not corrode, its design is unique and it carries a lot of Jerry's visions and implementations throughout the years. Besides, it is 100% made in America. As for Kryo tools from Henry Taylor, I feel honored that a company that is 178 years old chose a name that coincides with mine about the same time I was releasing our tool line. It seems that they liked the buzz we created here in America. I chose the name CryoSteel because it sounded great, but the CryoSteel tool line is a lot more than cryogenic treatment of regular tools in wooden handles.

Keep in mind that there is a tremendous difference between M2, M4 10V and Cryo's steel. I appreciate Mr. Kauder's report on performance. It is also important to note that he has bought these tools and it is NOT affiliated with CET in any form.

It means a lot to us to get the view directly from the woodturner. We have several other people doing the same right now as well as some professional turners and we are thrilled with the results.

Thank you all for the opportunity to place this comment!

Paulo Marin, ceo

CryoSteel Engineering & Technology

Glaser Hitec

CycleStart Engineering


img

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#12

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>I understand your point, though we do not know the final pricing for the Cryosteel gouges, the price will be more than the red handled Glasers. But to carry you point, why is a Glaser worth nearly twice what a Sweazey? It is my understanding that Jerry Glaser had not raised his price to the consumer or the retailer for over 10 years. He was making the money he wanted, even though the cost of materials went up. That was a personal decision he made. What you are willing to pay for a gouge is also a personal decision.

I have wondered the same issues on numerous thing in manufacturing. I recently bought a new Rikon 14" Deluxe Bandsaw (Deluxe means it has a built in light, fence, mitre gauge, 1.5hp motor and 13" resaw capacity). I bought it for $650 new. Now compare the work involved with making that BS (motor & all the entails, metal stamping, metal casting, machining, etc)to a 3M resporator that I priced at $950 (some hose, lexan face shield, a small motor, some filters, rubber, etc). Or the Apollo HPLV spray gun I bought (not a turbine, just the cup and gun for $400 (compared to a Home Depot at $60) or another manufacturers gun at $600. ??? Just depends on what you perceive as the value to you.

When I started turning, I had some carbon steel tools. I was having a blast. Then I bought an M2 Gouge, and enjoyed turning more, and sharpening less, and so it goes on up the scale. They say that in most things, whether water purity, air quality, or manufacturing that it is cheap to get 80-90% of the way there, but the price goes up exponentially for every percent above that. That is why you can pay $350 for a 14" BS from Harbor Freight, twice that for the Rikon, or 4-5 times the HF price for one from Laguna. They both cut, what are you willing to pay? You can do it all for a couple bucks if you do it by hand.

According to Crucible Specialty Metals. here are the comparitive wear resistance properties of the metals we use to turn with:

M2: 110% M4: 160% M42: 130% 10V: 530% 15V: 890%

Most Glasers were/are made with V10. The Black Handles were made with V15. V15 is good, but does not raise a good burr, so in some feel it does not cut as well, though it lasts for a very long time - but not twice V10. It is also somewhat more brittle.

Wear resistance in the lab does not equate to our perceived working time at the lathe, most of the time. Most will agree that a Glaser V10 does not last 5 times longer than an M2.

Cost of materials is usually a relatively small portion of the final cost of the product. Labor is a much higher percentage of the final cost - thus why many manufacturers are moving to Mexico, India and China. Even with the increased shipping costs they can offer a lower cost product, or keep the cost the same longer, or (Yes) increase their profits.

I know for me, though I am a hobby turner, when I am in "the zone" working on a shape or whatever, the less that I have to sharpen, the more I like it. Some people like the whole shop experience, so they are just as happy sharpening as turning.

I did not mean for this to be long, it is not meant to be disrespectful to your very, very valid questions and it is certainly not pointed at your our just your questions "justwannturn". I am afraid I got into lecture mode (for which I am not sure I am qualified) and my fingers and mind just ranaway with it.

You just want to turn - what are you doing at the keyboard? (smile - joke) I say have fun. Good turning.

Mark

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#13

Richard Allen

Re: Mark ?

Richard Allen

>Her is a picture of the "New" style Glaser tool and the "old" style Glaser tool (both are 5/8" bowl gouges).

Note that the handle for the "New" style is longer it is also slightly large around. I think they only have one handle now for all of their Glaser tool. So a 3/8" bowl gouge will have the same handle as the 3/4" bowl gouge. I ask and was told that V15 Glaser tools would be part of the line but that the handle would be the same red handle.

The Flute shape on the new gouge is on the left. You will notice that there is a little more of a "U" shape to the flute.

The "bolt" on the end is made of aluminum.


img

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#14

test drive?

john lucas

>I think we all need a test drive. I'll do the off road testing. That's where my skills are. You could send it around to each of us. :)

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#15

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

john lucas

>Mark I think you covered it very well. I go through the same question and answer thing everytime I buy something. Every once in a while I treat myself to something really nice and it's always been worth it from the standpoint of just holding the tool and feeling the quality. It sort of gives you a mental attitude toward improvement whether the tool actually helps or not.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#16

Re: Mark ?

Bob Fawcett

>Thanks for the picture Richard. I definitely have an old style one.

I bought mine at woodworkers supply. They still have a few. They are new, but the old style, so Jerry made them.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#17

Glaser Hitec line Handle Sizes

Paulo Marin

>Mr. Allen,

The handles will be available in the following sizes:

10" - 12" - 14" - 18" - 20" - 25" - 30" - 36" and 42".

The 15V tools will be available in a black handle, just like Jerry did in the past. The difference is as you noted: Slightly larger handle (diameter), threaded back to accomodate the lead, a hex aluminum button and the engraving.

Thanks

Paulo Marin

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#18

New CET Glaser 5/8"

Barry Turner

>I bought one of the new 5/8" Glaser's by CET at AAW. I lost the end plug. I think it got swept up and thrown out with the shavings. I emailed CET to order a new one. I quickly got an email from the CEO (Paulo) with a promise to mail me a new one.....no charge. Haven't got it yet, but that's a prompt response. I love the gouge.....can't compare it with the original Glaser because I have never used one. It has a nice feel though and the edge seems to hold up a bit better than my Crown PM.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#19

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Barry Turner

>I am not a professional turner. I do consider myself a serious hobby turner, though. I try to buy tools that are as good as I can afford. Cheap tools just never work well for me. A Glaser gouge may cost 5 times what another similar tool may cost, even though the edge may not last anywhere near 5 times as long. That's not the reason (edge durability) that I buy tools. The deciding factor for me is whether or not a tool has obvious quality and whether or not the tool "feels good" in my hand. I bought a CET/Glaser bowl gouge at AAW. I'm not going to be an unhappy camper if the edge doesn't last at least twice as long as the edge on my Crown PM. I think both are quality tools and the choice of which to buy is largely a personal one.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#20

CET/Glaser Handle Plug, Caution...........

Barry Turner

>Be sure that handle plug is tight. I lost mine and I think it got thrown out with the shavings. Finger tight isn't good enough. Use a wrench.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#21

Re: CET/Glaser Handle Plug, Caution...........

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Just the other day, I took the plug out of the end of my 1/2" Hi-Tec Glaser to look in there - I just had not before then. But today I noticed that it had vibrated nearly out. When you say use a wrench, I think I would say use a wrench, but you don't really have to crank down on it.

I don't really think that this is design defect, but I think what I will do, is just put a tiny, tiny bit of silicon sealant on the threads to keep it from vibrating out, but still easy enough to remove it necessary.

Mark

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#22

Re: CET/Glaser Handle Plug, Caution...........

Barry Turner

>Oh, I didn't mean to imply it was a design problem. I bought mine off the CET display at AAW in Louisville. The tools were mounted with bolts screwed into the handles. They took mine off the display and screwed the plug in finger-tight.

When I got home, I went to the shop and tried it out, never thinking to snug up the plug with a wrench. Well, it vibrated loose........ fell to the floor and I assume it got swept up and thrown out with the shavings of the day........can't believe I was so dumb! CET is sending me a replacement......no charge. Silicone sealant or Locktite is probably a good idea, but maybe not even necessary.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#23

Maybe we need a new cateory..

Bob Fawcett

>Some of us buy cars that are far more expensive than others. Both a Toyota and a Mercedes offer the basic things needed to make a good automobile. We could argue for days about the merits of one vs the other, similar to bowl gouges.

Maybe we should just call some of these tools "luxury" gouges.

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#24

Re: Maybe we need a new cateory..

Allen Neighbors

>I agree, Bob. If I bought one of them, it would surely be a luxury!

:o)

Allen

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

#25

Re: Preliminary Comments on Cryosteel Gouge - Long

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

>Mark, Thank you for taking the time to test all three tools. The results seem fair comparing the different tool steels. Good Job!

Richard, the side by side photo is nice to see, Glaser made the best tools but the old flute was slightly tight. Could you try both tools side by side and tell us what you think?

To be honest, this saga is getting old...

Thanks again Mark for your time and effort.