We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I know all the cliches, "you get what you pay for", "buy cheap, buy twice", buy the best, you'll never be sorry". Well some of us are on fairly slim budgets, so, what is a decent but inexpensive beginning bowl gouge. I have some inexpensive spindle gouges (but they work for pens, weed pots, etc)but am going to try to learn bowl/platter turning. Besides brand/grind, should it be 3/8" or 1/2"?
>When I started I bought several cheap sets from Penn State (http://pennstateind.com/)Actually, they're pretty good tools, especially the Benjamin's Best line.
I knew I would probably grind them up learning how to sharpen and that's what happened. Then I started buying Sorby and Crown. Just got the latest issue of the AAW magazine and noticed that http://hartvilletool.com has 20% of all Crown tools so you may want to take a look there........Ron
>Crown is a good value on sale. I've not used Benjamin's Best, but heard lots of good reports. It may offer more bang for the buck, and you can frequently find them on Ebay too. You'll end up grinding the sides back at least a little bit, so don't worry about grind to start off. As for size, start with 3/8. You'll probably start with smaller bowls which this size will be great for. If you graduate to bigger ones, it'll still be handy for finish cuts.
that tested various brand HSS tools against eachother,,,the outcome was the 'hss is hss is hss" the price difference was attributed to the brand name,factory grind and factory sharpness/finish mostly.. of course some more expensive tools had alot more metal length than these cheap sets below....
i just got the 8pc set from harbor freight adn am happy with it.
the wood case it came in was in 5 pieces when it arrived but the gouges are fine... it looks to be the exact same set PSI sells for $60 only this one cost me $35....someday ill get around to making nice long handles for them...
>I've been buying the Packard brand bowl gouges from Packard woodworks. I also like the Henry Taylor. These are reasonbly priced gouges and work quite fine for me.
>Saying that "HSS is HSS is HSS" is like saying that "A car is a car is a car". Neither is true. They are the same only if they have the same alloys, the same crystalline structure, the same grain size, the same distribution of alloys and carbon throughout the piece, were processed the same, and has been tempered to the same hardness on an Rc scale. Only when all of those things are the same can we say that all steels are the same.
The question should be, do all of these quality and metallurgy differences make any difference in how well the tool cuts wood and for how long? My answer is that the novice can't tell the difference, and should buy the least expensive tool. As we gain experience, and we can tell the difference, we should be buying the better grade of steel. At that point we are getting into the higher priced tools by Sorby, Taylor, Isles, Crown, etc., whose steels and prices are all within a few dollars of each other, and we start buying on the basis of flute shape and handles
Try Landingcrafts as these are the BB longer standard 11" handles with 7" of HSS and better steel than HF tools and do not change color after a month. 30 day money back guarantee if you don't grind more than 1/8" off. Get the 3/8 and 1/2" gouge. I buy all the brand names also but love experimenting with grinds on these and they work fine for less the $20 a pop.
>Excellent overall answer, Russ (as usual). I have been using Benjamin's Best bowl gouges for over a year now and find them to be the biggest bang for the buck out there. I also have Crown, Sorby, Henry Taylor and P&N bowl gouges in M2 steel, plus a bunch of exotics. I sharpen them all at once, then turn until they are all dull. The Benjamin's Best tools stand up just as long as the good M2 steel gouges from England and down under. You also get the same spark when sharpening, which is something of an indicator that it is a similar quality of steel (though this is not a guarantee). But the proof is in the usage -- and the Benjamim's Best bowl gouges are up there in edge holding ability with the best of the M2 tools -- and the price is a LOT less. And I do give my tools a workout. I am using bowl gouges at least 6 hours a day, at least 5 days a week.
I believe Jennifer knows the folks that work there. Great service and great prices... I see they are on vacation right now. They will also beat anyone's price on a one-way. I'm getting hooked on cheap good tools and love playing with grinds instead of using my more pricey stuff.
>I have a 1/4" detail gouge and a 1" scraper by P&N. They come unhandled but the quality for the money is a good value. The attached link is for the 1/2" bowl gouge in the Woodturners Cataloge. P&N tools are available from many suppliers.