Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

Posts

Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#1

Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

Craig Daymon

>I'm getting tired of my 6" high speed grinding wheel for sharpening my turning tools. I have Leonard Lee's DVD on sharpening and he sharpens using his 1" belt Sander/Grinder (Lee Valley part# 68Z75.01). It looks like it is very easy to sharpen with this system (remembering I still have the 6" grinder for serious reshaping) and able to get a very good edge. The price of his system is less than an 8" grinder would likely cost me, especially a slow speed grinder. Yes, I have the Wolverine and the Vari-Grind.

Anyone using or have used this system? Pros/cons? Any special tricks when it comes to using it for turning tools? Are there certain tools that you would use the grinder instead of the belt system?

Thanks in advance,

Craig


Lee Valley Tools - Sander/Grinder Part #68Z75.01

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#2

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

Leppikallio

>That should be almost as good as it can get (just note that you need to buy motor separately). Also grinding jig would require some rethinking because belt runs vertically... Herman de Vries has some information on his web page and I guess he will tell you more if you e-mail to him.

I use cheap belt grinder for all sharpening but that grinder is different beast with some serious drawbacks... But it works well anyway.


Herman de Vries, belt grinder sharpening

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#3

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Bob Ballard

>I have one with a leather belt,charged with buffing compound,my wife uses as a power strop for her carving tools.I have a set of the Sorby micro tools,I occasionally use and I polish the gouge and skew before using.I haven't tried it on normal size tools nor have I used the sanding belt.

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#4

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Craig Daymon

>Thanks, I didn't realize it didn't come with a motor. There is really no excuse for it not coming with one at that price. I can buy a 1" sander with a sanding disk and motor for about that price or only slightly more from Grizzly. I guess I could still use the same sharpening techniques. Easy belt changing might be a minor issue.

-Craig

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#5

Andy DiPietro

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Andy DiPietro

>Harbor Freight has the same maybe identical 1" sander on store sale for $29.99 part # 2485. The web price is $39.99. The 1" x 30" belts are $1.99 for a pack of 5. I am going to pick one up this weekend at the Franklin Mills store. I will use it to sharpen my 3/16" square hollowing cutters. Check out their chain saw sharpener too part # 93213. It is cheaply made but it gets the job done for only $29.99. See you at the next Bucks club meeting.

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#6

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

albertabob

>It's not the same thing. I have both. If you were closer I would deliver the one you think is equivalent for free.

Sometimes you have to ask the right questions.

bob

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#7

Andy DiPietro

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Andy DiPietro

>I was not very clear. I was trying to compare the Harbor Freight 1" sander on store sale for $29.99 part # 2485 to the Grizzly H3140 for $47.50. They look the same. Do you own either of the two models? Are either of them worth buying?

Thanks

Andy D.

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#8

Brad Vietje

CCW is Important -- Belt must go UP

Brad Vietje

>I have used a larger system (3" belt) that is similar in many respects, though it also comes with a narrow buffing wheel to de-burr freshly-sharpened edges.

It is important that the belt travel UP, away from the work surface, and not the more "normal" down. There are a few reasons for this, but the most important is that the sanding belt "floats" on a thin cushion of air as it travels past the platen, and when you push your bevel up against this to sharpen, the belt is deflected, and makes a slight curve to go between the bevel and the platen. If the belt is running up, this causes a slight rounding over of the heel of the tool, which is usually a very good thing. If the belt runs down (typical of woodworking belt/strip sanders), the roundover occurs on the edge you're trying to shrpen ! Many people sharpen this way, and get decent results, but when reversed, the result is much better. If you get a less costly machine, make sure you can get a CCW motor, or find some way to reverse the rotation.

BTW, this sort of system can work very well with jigs, and can be accurately indexed for repeatible results -- Jon Siegel in Central NH sells such a system (www.bigtreetools.com, I think). I also think expecting this tool to come complete with a motor for less than $70.00 is pretty un-realistic, especially if you want any decent quality at all. Most $29.00 machines are pretty cheap (both meanings), a la junque, IMHO.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#9

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Bob Fawcett

>Derick Cohen over on the hand tools side made a sharpening system from a 4 x 48 belt sander. This is the type where the belt can run horizontally or vertically. His system was for hand tools, but you could probably adapt it to turning tools. The rest was a metal cabinet door handle. He mounted it across the belt near the middle. He had the belt running away from the sharp edge as required.

I have one of this type sander in my shop anyway, so was interested in the possibility of using it to sharpen.

As I remember, there is a good write up with photos. I thought I had a link, but can't find it now. I am sure you could ask the hand tool guys, or maybe search the archives.

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#10

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Herman de Vries

>Craig, I see that someone pointed you to my setup for sharpening using the Lee Valley 1" belt sander.

I've used the system for a lot of years. My first fine grit belt finally broke after 9 years of use. At the end, I was basically using it to hone, but it would still raise a spark now and then.

I like the fact that it came without a motor, because I went out and found a 1/3 HP motor from a refit store. Most people use a 1/4 HP and that works but I like the extra power.

The advantages of the system are a very consitent edge. On mine, I have the tool rest permanently set at 35 degrees for most of my gouges. It's a simple matter to make MDF wedges that you just slap on the tool rest, held in place with dowels in 1/4" holes, to switch to the angles you need for your other tools, like scrapers and parting tools. I still use a wheel to do my skews because I like a curved edge. I also use a wheel for my Ellesworth bowl gouge. Otherwise, everything is done on the belt.

Other advantages are price and flexibility. The belts cost far less than a wheel and last a long time. They don't need to be dressed, are always flat, and you can change to a different grit, or to a wood sanding belt or to a honing belt in just a second or two.

By the way, if you decide on the system, get the blue zirconium belts for sharpening your tools. They are outstanding.

I need to update my webpage and show the wedges I use.

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#11

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Craig Daymon

>Herman,

Thanks for the first hand response. One thing confuses me, you set your table to 35 degrees, which is going to put a 65 degree bevel on your tool (assuming you are measuring from horizontal). The Lee Valley site and you have mentioned a counter-clockwise rotation on the motor. Watching Leonard Lee in the video, the belt is still moving down toward the table. Clockwise or counter-clockwise depends on how you are looking at the motor. I'm guessing you are looking at the spindle and you want the belt moving down toward the table. Well, does that mean you are facing the cutting edge of the gouge up, toward the the downward movement of the belt with the tool against the table?

I can see that for scrapers, but it seems like it would be very easy to cut a belt trying to do that with a gouge. Am I understanding this correctly?

Thanks for the help,

Craig

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#12

Wow! For $395 there are several options available.

Craig Daymon

>Based on the Leonard Lee video, the Lee Valley system runs with the belt turning down toward the table. They refer to this as counter-clockwise, which makes sense if you look at it from the spindle the same way a motor on a clock would drive the hands.

I can see running up as possibly more convenient for sharpening, but I'm not certain it is necessary. The price of the Big Tree Tools system is much higher than I had plans to spend. I could get the JET wet system for that price, or close. Besides, I could just pick up a sander like the one used by Big Tree Tools, probably for less, and use my Wolverine with it.

-Craig

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#13

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt

Herman de Vries

>Craig, I've never yet cut or nicked a belt with the gouge. I know, everyone says the same thing you just did, but it's never happened, even in all the classes I teach and newcomers are sharpening on that system. The belt is pretty tight, and there's a flat steel plate behind it for support.

Hope that quells your concerns.

Re: Sharpening with Lee Valley Sander/Grinder Belt *LINK*

#14

Thanks Herman.

Craig Daymon

>