Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

sanding test

Posts

sanding test

#1

sanding test

john lucas

>I finally had time to do a brief sanding test. The idea was to sand from 220 grit to 1500 grit and then finish with a thick body finish and and oil finish and see if I could see the difference between 220 and 1500 with either of these finishes. Well I'll know more after tomorrow night when I let the club look at these samples but here goes my analysis.

I resawed 4 boards, maple, cherry, walnut, and curly mahagony. I chose 2 open pore woods and 2 smooth woods to see the differences. I sanded each board to 220 grit and then sanded 3" sections to 400, then 600, 1200, 1500 grit, so each board has 5 sections sanded to different grits.

I sprayed lacquer on 4 of the boards using 4/0 steel wool lightly between each spraying. I put on 4 coats. The other 4 boards I applied low gloss tung oil, 6 coats again rubbed lightly with 4/0 steel wool between coats. didn't buff out the finish on either finish because I wanted to see the results as is. I will buff them out later to a higher quality and see what happens but I don't think it will change the appearance of the wood, only the finish itself.

The results. When I first looked at the boards I could barely see a difference between the 220 and the rest of the board. I took them outside into better light and could make out a little difference between the 220 and 400 step but from 600 on up I could not tell any difference in the look of the wood. Even the chatoyance of the curly mahagony doesn't show any difference between the 600 on up.

I wish I could have done this same test with some exotics but wasn't willing to waste that wood. My conclusion at this stage is I don't need to waste extra time using higher than 600 grit unless I change my finishes and the way I'm finishing. These finishes look very good. They could be improved by using the beal buffing system or by sanding the finishes to a finer grit such as the way Mark Kauder does his finishes. I was more interested in how the sanding of the wood affected the final finish.

I have done the same test when making wine stoppers using Hut abrasive. I made about 30 or so and finished 10 by sanding to 400 grit, 10 to 600 grit and 10 to 1500 grit. I applied the hut abrasive to these to finish them. When I finished I could not tell any of them apart. These were woods from maple and cherry to dogwood and ebony.

I'll let you all draw your own conclusions. I would photograph them for you but you won't be able to tell the difference in a photo.

Re: sanding test

#2

Re: sanding test

Dinyar Chavda

>Hi John:

Very interesting test, and the results are something that I have often suspected. In fact, I don't know if it is feasible for you to cut the pieces apart and then pass them around at the club, or put them on a table in random order, and ask each member to identify what each piece was sanded upto. It would be really interesting to see how distinguishable these truly are. (I did a lot of experiments like this cwith consumers to find out how good was good enough, and when you were wasting time and money providing something that the custoemr could not detect).

The one thing you said that I'd like you to clarify is your sentence:

They could be improved by using the beal buffing system or by sanding the finishes to a finer grit such as the way Mark Kauder does his finishes. I was more interested in how the sanding of the wood affected the final finish.

I think I understand it, but I would like to know exactly what you meant by that, as well as your view of whether Mark Kauder's approach would invalidate your conclusion, i.e., the various grits above 200 are indistinguishable.

D

Re: sanding test

#3

Re: sanding test

eliot d

>I had practically the same question in mind as Dinyar; then I saw his post. Certainly for flat work it's long been held that it's a waste of time to go beyond 180 --at most. 220. I have always thought the higher grits are for sanding the FINISH -- not the wood. That said, lately I have been sanding my turnings to 1000 using Astro Dot, which is new for me, and ( I believe) I see a clear improvement in the sanded surface of the wood.

I would love to hear what someone like Russ Fairfield has to say, or Michael Dresner.

Re: sanding test

#4

Re: sanding test

eliot d

>It just occurred to me that my last post could be construed as "highjacking" Dinyar's post. I don't mean to do that. I only mean to say that I have the same concerns and that an answer to his question is an answer to mine , as well.

Re: sanding test

#5

Re: sanding test - with or across the grain?

Rick Allen

>That is a terrific test. Thanks for shareing with us.

You didn't mention if you were sanding with the grain or across the grain.

Re: sanding test

#6

Re: sanding test

john lucas

>Dinyar My thoughts are that that buffing or fine sanding of the finish will improve the clarity of the finish somewhat but won't improve how the grain appears. I've done this experiment seperatly when turning my mirrors. I needed to see if spending more time on the finish quality would improve the appearance of the grain and figure in the exotic woods that I use on my hand mirrors.

I took a bunch of mirrors and tried more layers of finish for a higher build. Not a really thick finish but enough to fill all the grain. Some were left with just the spray lacquer, and some were sanded to 2000 grit following Mark's method of sanding to higher grits between each layer of finish until done. Then I rubbed it out with pumice and rhotenstone and finished with swirl remover. It was a thick looking glass like finish that really looked good. However it didn't seem to me to pop the grain any more, only the finish was clearer.

Don't get me wrong, the clear finish looks really good and worth it on high end pieces. On my production work I try to keep the time element to a minimum without hurting the quality. On hand mirrors especially, the really high gloss finishes don't hold up well to all that handling. I find that a thinner finish that's buffed to a gloss works just as well for the customer. It leaves some pores showing which kind of adds to the natural finish look which the customers seem to like.

Now back to the original question. I can cut the boards up and will try that some time just don't have time today. I really don't think you can tell the difference in the grain, only less imperfections in the finish. I looked really hard. Buffing the finish out will get rid of some minor streaks in the finish but I don't think it will enhance the way the grain pops only the clarity of the finish itself. Now I know this is like looking through a dirty window. When you clean the window things do look better but we are talking about a mildly dirty window vs a clean window. The difference is very subtle.

I will continue testing and don't want to suggest that everyone stop thier favorite sanding technique. I really expected a big difference between the grits. It just wasn't there.

Re: sanding test

#7

Re: sanding test - with or across the grain?

john lucas

>After the planer I sanded with a random orbital sander from 120 to 220 grit. Then all the boards were sanded by hand with the grain.

Re: sanding test

#8

Re: sanding test - with or across the grain?

David Galloway

>I agree with the others in thanking you for posting these results. I have really been struggling with my finishing since this spring. I sat throught Russ' wonderful DVD's that gave me great information, but I am still struggling.

I just saw the amazing pictures of Mark Kauder's work in the new AAW magazing. He has been helpful to me in pushing the need for hand sanding in upper grits. It sure seems to pay off for him. I think he has the best finishes I have seen, along with Don Derry.

Again, thanks for the posting.

Re: sanding test

#9

Re: sanding test

Russ Fairfield

>There is nothing that gets me cranked up faster than someone saying that the wood surface doesn't matter. It does matter, and the difference is in those qualities of a finish that we call "depth", "grain accent", and "chatoyance". These can be subtle differences that really add to a special piece of wood. Obviously, this requires that the wood have a grain to accent, and a natural chatoyance to enhance. Given 2 pieces of flame Maple, I would put mine that was sanded to 2000-grit up against one that was sanded to 220-grit any time.

"Depth" is an optical illusion that happens when light is reflected from the bottom of the surface film and the top surface of the film equally. It is that same thing that happens when you get a double reflection from a window glass when it is dark outside. Sometimes we can see it in a mirror. Getting that reflection from the bottom side of the surface film requires that it be as close to being as smooth as the top surface as possible, and that means sanding to finer grits and polishing the wood to where it has a gloss BEFORE the finish is applied.

Having said all of that, there are a three requirements here. I used the term "surface film". Before we can see the "depth" of the finish there has to be two reflective surfaces that are separated by some distance, and that means a film finish or one that is thick enough that there is a top and bottom.

Another requirement is that BOTH surfaces, the one next to the wood and the top surface, have to be the same high reflective gloss. If the top surface is not the best that it can be and there is no gloss because the light is scattered rather than reflected, there will be no "depth" to the finish. Sanding the wood past 220-grit could be a waste of time for a flat finish on the wood, or one that has had the gloss removed with steel wool.

The 3rd requirement is the "clarity" of the surface film. That means as little color as possible, and NO fillers or sealers to scatter the light inside of the surface film.

Having said all of that, "depth" is of little importance with a finish that doesn't have a build up of a surface film. That is why "depth" is an important part of a lacquer finish. "Depth" can be an important quality with a shellac if it is done right. It can be important to an oil finish if it is built up to the same gloss as a lacquer, but that means 10-12 coats with an oil finish that has enough varnish resins to build a substantial surface film. You will never get "depth" from 2 coats of a Watco oil. You will from 12 coats of Waterlox.

The other reasons for sanding to a finer grit are "accent" of the grain and the "chatoyance" (seeing movement in the wood as it is moved). There are 2 ways to accent the grain of a piece of wood. One is to use an oil finish and depend on the deeper penetration into the end grain. The other is to use the fact that sanding to a finer grit will reduce the penetration of a finish. Sanding to the finer grit reduces penetration on all wood, both end and flat grain, and that means the wood that was sanded to 2000-grit will be a lighter and brighter color than the one that was sanded to only 220-grit.

Sanding to a finer grit has two other effects with an oil finish. Sanding to a finer grit reduces penetration of the oil. That reduces the amount of blotching, and because there is less finish in the wood, there will be less darkening with age.

The "chatoyance" effect follows the accenting of the grain, and it will be brighter with the lighter color and polished surface of the wood under the finish.

I sand everything to the 1500-2000 grit level just in case there is some quality in the wood that I can't see. Sometimes we can't see what the wood has to offer until it has been polished or until after we have put a finish on it. Sanding to only 220-grit before finishing will insure that I NEVER see it. The difference between 320 grit and 2000 is only 4 sheets of sandpaper and another 10-minutes of sanding, and you will never convince me that it isn't worth the extra effort.

Re: sanding test

#10

Re: and....

Russ Fairfield

>I have yet to have a finish fail because the wood was sanded to to fine a grit.

Re: sanding test

#11

Re: sanding test

robo hippy

>I have always wondered if there was a difference in how you should sand a surface finish (lacquers, poly, etc), and a penetrating finish (oils and waxes).

robo hippy

Re: sanding test

#12

Re: and.... more

Russ Fairfield

>One thing I missed in my discussion is that there is more end grain exposed by the curved surface on a piece of turned wood than on a flat wood surface. Some turned wood can be 80& end grain to some degree. That means there is more opportunity for all of the things I discussed to happen and to a greater degree on turned wood.

I would say that any finishing test on flat wood surfaces would be relevant to flat surfaces, but have very little relevance to turned wood unless you were looking at what was happening to the ends of the flat pieces, and not the flat grain.

Re: sanding test

#13

Re: and.... more

John Lucas

>Russ I understand everything you are saying and I will agree that it never hurts and you definitely could be right about the flat wood verses round, especially end grain. On these particular pieces of wood there isn't any difference in the look from 600 on up. 220 yes, 400 boy that's really close on the walnut and maple, barely noticeable on the mahagony and cherry. from 600 on up no difference in the the color, depth etc.

Now this was definitly not a conclusive test with only 4 types of wood so I want everyone to listen to what you have to say and make thier own decisions. I just wanted to run this test for me. Before the next club meeting I will "finish" the finish to the N'th degree and cut up the wood and let the members look again, and myself to see.

I honestly expected to see big results from sanding to the finer grits because I trust you and keith. So far my results have been different.

Re: sanding test

#14

Brad Vietje

End Grain test ?

Brad Vietje

>John,

I wonder if a series of sanded and finished slices -- like buttons -- taken from the end of a wood cylinder, all end grain, would show the same result ? Since a lot of turning is presenting end grain at various angles, and not that much side grain, I'd be interested to see the result of that sort of test. I could perform such a test, but it would be even better if you and your club, already experienced in this sort of evaluation, could take your test method in that direction.

Thanks for the results you've posted.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: sanding test

#15

Re: End Grain test ?

John Lucas

>Brad I think that's a good idea. Since this turned out to be somewhat controversial, and that was not my aim. I fully expected to prove Russ correct in that finer sanding would prevail, and that still may be the case in the long run with more controlled and careful testing.

Next time I'm doing a wine stopper run I will try to make several from the same exotic species and try the test again only this time it will be turned pieces instead of flat.

Re: sanding test

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: sanding test

Keith Tompkins

>Hi John ...interesting post. Since I've been involved in this topic for years, and have been a proponent of sanding to excess, I'll give my take on the subject...

First, the success or failure of a finish is determined before the first coat is even applied....especially with a lacquer or polyurethane finish. Every minute detail will be telegraphed through the finish. A bright light will uncover scratches and defects unnoticable to the casual observer. Over time, the finish will settle, making defects even more glaring...pores that were initially filled smooth with finish will begin to show, and scratches in the wood will appear as indentations.

For a good test, I think each block being tested should be done as separate pieces, then thoroughly sanded to remove ALL previous sanding marks. A lacquer finish should be applied as the test finish, as it is the least forgiving, and shows defects readily. Several coats of finish, sanded and buffed, then examined under strong light......

Staining a piece of maple a dark color will REALLY show sanding marks when the finish is applied.

Is there really a difference? I believe so.

Re: sanding test

#17

Re: sanding test

bob davis

>DUH

Re: sanding test

#18

Re: sanding test

john lucas

>Keith I fully intend to follow up on this test when I have time. There are too many holes in my testing procedure to be a definitive answer(if there actually is one).

I passed the samples around at the club meeting and everyone agreed that they couldn't see a difference between 600 and up and most couldn't see a difference between 400 grit and up. I think I spent more time and care on finishing these boards than most turners spend on thier work so I don't think I chinced out on that end.

I think the next test will be more turning related and I'll try to use highly figured woods. This has been an interesting test and I look forward to trying it again with more control.

Re: sanding test

#19

Re: sanding test

eliot d

>John, do you know the finisher( now deceased) named George Frank? He was one of the great masters. Your testing reminds me of Frank's methods. Frank did flat work and was famous for spending hundreds of hours making and displaying board samples with varying kinds of finish. You should be complimented. You are working in a great tradition.

Re: sanding test

#20

Re: sanding test... Robo

Ruth Niles

>If there is anything you need to know about sanding, finishing, oils, waxes, varnish, ingredients, etc. etc., I have to suggest you purchase Russ's "Finishing Secrets" DVDs or VHS (3 disc set).

TD gave the best testimonial, "If what you need to know about finishing isn't there, you don't need to know it."

I am not affilliated nor get any money for telling everyone how wonderful this video is to every woodturner. It's like watching the best book on finishing! really