Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Glue failure & flying bowls

Posts

Glue failure & flying bowls

#1

Glue failure & flying bowls

Thad

>Due to recent life experience, I have removed Gorilla Glue from my arsenal for turning supplies. I've used it with great results in the flat world o wood, and understood that it works best with moisture present so when I needed a strong glue to hold a green blank to a glueblock for reverse turning Gorilla glue seemed to make the most sense. I know I used plenty of glue, and let it dry for about 20 hours. I mounted it and trued the blank up removing all the dried glue that had expanded and began hollowing. I hit a small catch which hardly kicked back,then I hear "thwap thwap thwap thwap thwap" and the blank is wabbling for a few rotations before coming completely loose, hitting the banjo, and slamming into the wall.

As we say in rugby, "No blood, No foul!" but even though I did not get hit, I think I'm gonna save all my gorilla glue for flat work that only has the potential to drop me from a sitting position instead of a blank that can result in concusions.

Anybody else been here?

~ Thad

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#2

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

robo hippy

>I've never been there, but I called up Franklin Glue (makers of Titebond) and was asking a few questions about glues, and asked about the urethane glues. The guy told me about an experiment they did. They laminated up pieces to make baseball bats, using the titebond, and their urethane glue. In every case, when used, the urethane bats delaminated, and the titebond ones held up. Urethane glue doesn't take shock loads well.

I have a friend who shipped some things to Japan which were glued up with urethane glue. The altitude caused all of the bubles to expand, and the glue also failed.

I have used CA with success, and some use hot melt glue with success.

robo hippy

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#3

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

Norm Smith in Nova Scotia

>Thad, Sure glad that you didnt get hurt bad. I use tightbond and have never had a failure.

Turs safely,

Norm

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#4

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

eliot d

>Yes it's happened to me a few times with different glues. In each case I'm fairly sure the problem was not the glue but that I hadn't gotten the two surfaces really flat. Now that I'm aware of the problem , I've been turning the two surfaces really flat and haven't had any more such failures. And the next to last one( that worked fine) was Gorilla glue. The last one was medium CA. I do think turning them really flat, using ordinary yellow glue( or stronger) and clamping overnight under pressure from the tail stock is about as good as you can get.

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#5

I use Titebond always

Carole Valentine

>The thing that makes me do that is a long time ago I had something I was trying to knock apart that had all Gorilla glue joints except two which were Titebond. The GG joints just popped apart with a couple of sharp blows. The Titebond joints came apart with much greater effort and only after the wood itself gave way - not the glue! In that case, the TB glue was stonger than the wood. I threw my GG away.

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#6

Re: I use Titebond always, me, too!

Ruth Niles

>

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#7

Re: I use Titebond always

Bob R

>I have had glue (Titebond) joints come apart but after looking close it is always the wood and not the glue that failed.

Bob R

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#8

Re: No Glue for Me over 3" dia.

Jake Niedling

>Items that are 3" and larger in diameter, I put a tenon on it for my scroll chuck. For larger hollow vessels, I would use a face plate and some screws. On smaller items under 3" diameter, I use CA glue making sure to get two flat surfaces. I have never had a flying object, but I am always cautious.

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#9

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

Don Henthorn

>Of course I am old fashioned, but I bought one bottle of Gorilla Glue and used it several times and threw it into the trash. My favorite glue is hide glue and for convenience I'll go to Tite-bond. Just my personal prefernce.

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#10

Don! You're back!

Carole Valentine

>Where the heck have you been?

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#11

Heck, Carole,

Don Henthorn

>I have been back for a week or two. I shouldn't post too much, though since I have no shop and I'm not so sharp any more. It has been good reading your posts again.

Re: Glue failure & flying bowls

#12

Bull!

Carole Valentine

>You don't need a shop to post! We all consider you part of the family here - shop or no shop. Welcome back! :)