Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Time to upgrade?

Posts

Time to upgrade?

#1

Time to upgrade?

Edward in Vancouver

>Been lurking here and on the handtools site for a while, but I guess it's time to come out and say Hi.

Anyways after my last turning project which was a "cannister" of about 4"diameter and about 10"tall, made of laminated teak, I "assesed" my handiwork and my lathe, and being the first to blame my tools figured it's time for a decent lathe... Current lathe is one I bought almost 30 yrs ago with money earned as a dishwasher, a Craftsman 12" with tubular steel bed. It's the bed that bugs me, have to customize accesories (spindle steady, extra tool rest, sanding platform) for it, and they don't work very well. Neither does the tool rest base either, for no matter how much I tune and file, fiddle and fit, I still can't get a rock-solid base which means the tool rest moves slightly all the time. Ironically enough I've seen "new and improved" versions of this lathe (CDN Tire, Rigid) which are virtual carbon copies, but with cast iron tool rest bases. Once bitten, twice shy I guess.

I've scouted around and looked at some new models: Nova, and other brands, but am still struggling to accept the $3,000 + price tag. I've also seen some ones made in Tiawan going for around $600, and while they look good,i.e, rotating headstock, variable motor drive, cast iron construction; I am reluctant to consider because I have no feedback on the quality.

Any suggestions where to start out on a quest for a good lathe, or is a $3,000 price justified?

Re: Time to upgrade?

#2

Steven Antonucci

Nova's don't cost $3000...

steve antonucci

>A Nova 3000 used for resale should be about $600-800 and is a great lathe for the money. (I own one)

You can also scout the papers and Ebay for other such bargains.

Steve

Re: Time to upgrade?

#3

Re: Time to upgrade?

Rick Davenport

>I am a HUGE Powermatic 3520 fan.

The most lathe for the money that I could find.

Before you buy anything, try it out first if you can.

Just my opinion.

Rick

Re: Time to upgrade?

#4

Re: Time to upgrade? *LINK*

E Tabachek

>Check this out:

http://www.kmstools.com/main.php?scripts/products/cat.php?4&2

KMS is, of course, a supplier in Coquitlam, which is next door to Vancouver. This page says that the Nova company will be reintroducing a lathe equivalent to the Nova 3000 this fall. No pics, however.

Edward in Winnipeg


http://www.kmstools.com/main.php?scripts/products/cat.php?4&2

Re: Time to upgrade?

#5

Re: Time to upgrade?

E Tabachek

>Go to lathes and click on LL3000 Nova 30000 with 1.5 hp motor etc.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#6

Re: Time to upgrade?

Bill Luinetti

>In case you had not considered the Stubby (made in Australia), check out the USA website: www.stubbylatheusa.com

Re: Time to upgrade?

#7

Re: Time to upgrade?

Edward in Vancouver

>Thanks for the info gentlemen. Incidentally, KMS tools is the place I checked out and got the $3,000 price for the Nova. Maybe I got the "relacement" guy instead of the regular sales guy on lunch break, dunno, but that's the price he gave me. Not in a huge rush to buy one right now, just trying to get a "feel" for the prices and what's available.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#8

Re: Time to upgrade?

E Tabachek

>Ed: From the lathe page, it looks to me as though the DVRXP is going to be about $3K, $2599 plus PST and GST. The Nova 30000 sold for $999 incl. motor and I can't see Teknatool putting an intermediate lathe on the market for $3K.

BTW how much is a Stubby anyway. A local checked it out and said he would not have much left from $10K by the time he factored in exchange, shipping and taxes.

Ed.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#9

Re: Time to upgrade?

john lucas

>The Jet 14" and Jet 16" have gotten fantastic reviews by most people. I got the powermatic 2035. Here in the US the 2035b is still less than 3K. The two jet models I mentioned are lower in price.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: Time to upgrade?

Keith Tompkins

>Edward, have you considered a big General? 20"swing, v/s, reliable as an anvil...and made in Canada.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#11

Re: Time to upgrade?

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Edward: I own a Nova-3000. I also own a Powermatic-3520a. I can tell you there is a huge difference. I love and use them both, but realize their individual nuances. The old adage, "buy your first lathe as if it is your last" always applies. If you can afford the Powermatic at about $2700 US, then go for the gusto! You won't be sorry.

Ed

Re: Time to upgrade?

#12

Richard Allen

Re: Time to upgrade?

Richard Allen

>You are absolutly right that $3000 for a woodworking tool is a LOT of money. Justify spending that much for a lathe? Even half that much is a LOT for a woodworking tool.

I have a 2436 with most of the attachments. The gross I have made from woodturning paid for the lathe and such which is how I justifyed the cost.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#13

Re: Time to upgrade?

Barry Turner

>Look at www.stubbyusa.com for prices and specs. Very nice machine. It will be a bit over $5000 with shipping.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#14

agree, 3520 PM

Mike Nelson

>

Re: Time to upgrade?

#15

Re: Time to upgrade? *LINK*

E Tabachek

>Ed: I really think you should have a look at the General 25-600 or the 25-650 lathe. The first one is mechanical VS and the second is electronic VS. I have seen them in the stores and have powered one up and I am impressed with the quality of machining and the smooth quiet operation. I don't recall the exact price but as I remember you should be able to have one delivered for well under the $3000 mark. Another machine you should have a look at is the Vicmarc 175, if KMS has any left at $2999. This is a lot of machine for $2999. I don't remember seeing any Powermatic dealers in or near Vancouver. I think it is always good to have your machine supplier in the same country.

Ed.


http://www.general.ca/pagetitre/ang/lathes.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#16

Re: Time to upgrade?

robo hippy

>The main thing that I like about the PM is the sliding headstock. As far as I am concerned this is more stable and mechanically sound than the pivoting headstocks. It also makes it into an excellent bowl lathe by sliding it down to the tailstock end. You don't have to lean over the lathe to turn, and this is a huge back saver. You can slide it back to the headstock end for turning spindles. Compared to the Nova, it is a lot more lathe for a little bit more money. I am a full time woodworker and have abused mine severely. After almost 7 years I have worn out one set of headstock bearings. I did turn mostly chainsawn wet bowl blanks (I now have a Laguna 16hd so the blanks are a lot more uniform) without using the tail stock.

robo hippy

Re: Time to upgrade?

#17

Re: Till the new one arrives.......

Pete LaBelle

>As an engineer by trade, suggest till the new lathe (which I am very happy with the recent arrival of my JET 1642), suggest turning your Craftsman up on end, plugging the bottom end, inserting a piece of re-rod, then filling the tube with concrete. Your tube is pretty thin and spongy on a side load. In the engineering world, filling a thin tube with concrete keeps the walls from moving and significantly stiffens the tube. Might make for a stiffer "bed" for a while. It's done on doorway barriers in commercial buildings all the time.

My 3 cents worth (adjusted for inflation). Pete

Re: Time to upgrade?

#18

Re: Time to upgrade?

Edward in Vancouver

>O.K. Now I've got some hard names and models to go by. I'll take my time sniffing out the "right model", meantime I'll blame the Creafstman 12" for my mistakes....

I have "upgraded" it somewhat, filed the rivets off of the metal guide on the bottom of the tube and drilled and tapped the holes to accept macnine screws. Countersunk the guide rod and epoxied it on as well as the machine screws. Also found a giant washer, anchored it in the tube near the headstock, threaded a 35"length of threaded rod through it and bolted it through onto the tail casting wich is bolted onto my bench. It's the toolrest base that gets me, made of stamped steel and no matter how tight I clamp it it still moves 1/4" to and away from me, moving the rool rest as well. This has been improved somewhat with the guiderod being bolted/epoxied on (rivets, huh! who woulda thunk?!) but the toolrest wiggling while I'm hollowing out a vase still gets the 'ol sphincter muscle moving...

Re: Time to upgrade?

#19

Re: Time to upgrade? General?

Ruth Niles

>I have to agree with Keith on the General 260 VS. I upgraded to this machine a few years ago and can't think of a thing to complain about! It's green, made in Canada, heavy, good footprint, 20" swing, quiet, variable speed and, best of all, doesn't cost as much as lathes with comparable features. You could always paint it black or white?!?

Re: Time to upgrade?

#20

Re: Time to upgrade?

robo hippy

>Edward,

just noticed that you are in Vancouver. Is that Washington, or BC. I am down in Eugene. If you come this way, you can play on my lathe.

robo hippy

Re: Time to upgrade?

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Time to upgrade? General?

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Ruth. I've had mine three years now...my machine has seen daily use, from four to twelve hours a day, nearly every day. Absolutely perfect. Not a glitch. Centers still line up just as new.

I have had the pleasure of using almost every lathe out there (haven't tried a VB yet) and the General compares very favorably. The motor, speed control combination is as good as any, better than most. One of the smoothest lathes as well.

The biggest problems: company seems stuck in 1960's. They don't seem to be on top of what's happening in the turning scene.

Re: Time to upgrade?

#22

Brad Vietje

Question for Keith or Ruth...

Brad Vietje

>Do General lathes all come with a gap in the bed, or have they stopped doing that? Are there inserts to fill the gaps in the older models ? I learned on an older Delta/Rockwell lathe with a most annoying gap -- hard to get the rest in there to do small stuff, or work the backside of a bowl between centers.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Time to upgrade?

#23

Re: Question for Keith or Ruth...

Keith T

>Hi Brad, the General still comes with the gap...but they sell a block to fill it.. I believe it fits all the bigger models.

There is some talk of General coming out with a new lathe, just a rumor for now. I have been in contact with them, as they asked my opinion on how the lathe can be improved, and what features the new machine should have.

I have a list, but haven't had the time to respond.