Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Coring system recomendations

Posts

Coring system recomendations

#1

Coring system recomendations

rj anema

>I have a Jet 14" lathe with a 1 hp motor and am looking for a coring system. I emailed Oneway and they said they had nothing that would work. Are there other options? Is this lathe not powerful enough for coring? Your advice would help a newbie along. Thanks is advance. I usually just lurk around the turning forums but would like to get more active especially seeking advice.

rj

Re: Coring system recomendations

#2

Re: Coring system recomendations

Ron in Drums PA

>I have the McNaughton setup that I use on a Jet 1236, Should work on a 14" Jet.

Re: Coring system recomendations

#3

Re: Coring system recomendations

Lloyd in California

>Check out the Woodcut Bowlsaver. Pretty easy to use.

Re: Coring system recomendations

#4

Re: Coring system recomendations

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>I would guess that with either of these you will only be able to core wet wood. I believe the McNaughton to be the most flexable of the two. Only buy the small set.

Good turning and be safe

Bill , Back in Dolores, ( cool ) CO.

Re: Coring system recomendations

#5

Re: Coring system recomendations

robo hippy

>I own all three of the coring systems. When it comes to horse power, the answer is can you cut a 3/8 inch wide kerf?. With the exception of the KM (McNaughton) mini set of blades, they all remove about a 3/8 inch wide shaving when coring. As long as you don't push it, 1 hp should work. I have done demos on the Oneway 1224, and it had no problems with any of the systems, especially if the cutters are sharp.

Oneway does/did make a system for a 12 inch lathe. The full big set is the most expensive of the 3 systems. For the bigger bowls (16 to 14 inches) I prefer it. The down side of it is the price and sharpening the cutting tip (they have to be removed from the blade, and put on the grinder by hand, and then you have to touch up the point on it). The support finger under the blade makes for no vibration. When coring, you have to turn off the lathe to advance the finger, and on a large bowl, this can be 3 to 5 times.

The Woodcut system is pretty nice. It is made for smaller bowls, with the biggest blade having a 5 inch radius. You can remove a larger core with it, but the bottom of the core will be concave, which isn't much of a problem, but does leave the bottom of the cored bowl a bit thicker than I like. The blades (there are 2) are a bit of a pain to change. You have to move both of them in the jig to change them. It is a small inconvenience. The thing that I don't like is that it is designed to work with the tailstock used to help steady it. I never use the tailstock when I turn bowls, as it is in the way, and if you secure the bowl blank properly, it isn't needed. It will work without the tailstock, and on softer woods like cherry, it works fine, but on something harder like locust or osage, it will chatter. There is some chatter with it anyway. I would like to see one bigger blade with it, but don't that the mechanics of a bigger blade will work with this system. Sharpening is simple, the cutter is concave on top, but touch up the face on a grinder, or with a hone, and you are good to go. When the cutter wears out, order another one, or get a new tip brazed on.

If I had the option of only having one system, I would take the KM as it is by far and away the most versatile of the lot, you can core a platter, standard bowl, or a cone shape. It is the fastest to set up and core with, and I don't think that it is because I have a lot more experience with it. I use it for all of my medium (14 inch and under cores). The biggest difference with this set up is that it is opperated free hand, and the others are on a fixed pivot point. You can't see where the tip is, and you have to aim and shoot. This can lead to making some lamp shades, or as other call them, funnels. There are ways to rig up a laser pointer over the cutter which will help some. There is a learning curve with this one. The instructions that come with it are lacking, and if possible, find some one who knows how to use it, and ask for guidance. There is a DVD out by Mike Mahoney who is a master of this tool. Bill Grumbine also shows it in his latest DVD, and I will have one out some time soon also. For your lathe, I would get the 2 tightest curved blades with the medium set, and the same two with the mini set. The flatter blades are more specialty tools. The points of the cutters are spear points, and each side needs to be sharpened. I solved this problem by grinding the point off square. It cuts fine. The hardest thing to master with this tool, is to make a smooth clean cut. The blade wants to wander off course as you go in. You can learn to correct this, by pulling the handle towards you to counter the drift. Little pressure is needed.

One turner (I don't remember who) said that coring with the Oneway is production, and coring with the McNaughton is an adventure.

robo hippy

Re: Coring system recomendations

#6

Re: Coring system recomendations *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I have seen the McNaughton system used a number of times and a few on lathes with only 1 hp motors. The lathe struggled with the system. In 1997, when I was looking for a coring system, I had a table at the AAW Symposium in San Antonio, Texas right across the isle for the Craft Supplies booth. They were doing coring on a lathe with a 1 hp motor using the Woodcut Bowl Saver. After three days of watching, I purchased one of the systems at the special show price. At the time, I had a CL-3 lathe with a 3/4 hp motor. It worked with that, but I learned quickly that you need at least 4" jaws on your chuck to keep from tearing off the foot when coring.

The Mcnaughton system with the small blades might work on a 1 hp lathe, I'm not sure because I've not tried it yet. I recently got the McNaughton system, but have not had time to play with at this time. From observing it used many times, it appears to be the most flexible of those available.


Fred Holder's Domain Site

Re: Coring system recomendations

#7

Re: Robo, that was an excellent

Allen Neighbors

>post. Answered the man's question, along with some very good advice. Kudos!

Mind you, I'm not knocking the other posts, I'm just complimenting yours. :o)

Allen

Re: Coring system recomendations

#8

Re: Coring system recomendations

rj anema

>Thanks to you all for your interest, education and advice. I am going to really enjoy being a part of this community. I just need to save up for that coring system and get to work. Thanks again, any mentors in western Michigan?