Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

cracked bowls

Posts

cracked bowls

#1

Keith Tompkins

cracked bowls

Keith Tompkins

>A poll of sorts...I posted a rough sketch of a bowl blank with the pith area situated at the rim. This area is end-grain, and will move radially as it dries. If the bowl is going to crack, it is usually in this area.

A blank with the pith situated with the pith in the base, such as is common with natural edge bowls, eliminates this radial movement. The blank may crack in a straight line across the bottom, if at all.

I turn most of my bowls with the pith towards the base, and have very few failures due to cracks.....(if I don't want a nat. edge, I remove it, which wastes some material)A larger blank is required to turn the same size bowl, but my success rate is good.

Anybody else's experiences similar?


img

Re: cracked bowls

#2

Re: cracked bowls

john lucas

>Keith I turn a lot of natural edge pieces with the pith just below the foot. I turn them to 3/8" or less in thickness and then turn away the pith area when I reverse turn them. I have had very few failures this way. If I turn a bowl like your drawing I almost always cut the pith away and prefer to cut at least 1/2" beyond that. You get a lumb where the pith was but usually no cracking. If I don't want the lump I rough turn it and put it up to dry.

I turned some oak pieces for a lady and had to leave the pith in because of the size of the log. I placed the pith about an inch or more below the lip, kept it wet the whole time I was turning and then sealed this area really well with thin CA when I was done. I turned them to slightly less than 3/8" and then put them in plastic bags when done. I reversed the bags every day for about 2 weeks and then pulled them out and set them on the floor while I was in the shop. I would rebag them at night. Don't remember how long I did this but it was around 2 weeks. Then I just pulled them out a put them on the workbench for another few weeks. One cracked about 1/8" or larger and the other 2 had smaller checks that were easily filled. 6 piths and no serious failures. I felt pretty good and she loved them.

Re: cracked bowls

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: cracked bowls

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks, John, That's what I do as well, removing the pith plus about a half-inch or so. I guess "pith area" wasn't a good description!

HOwever, I'm starting to turn all my bowls with the pith in the base...I turned several large cherry bowls ranging from 12" to 20" oriented this way with no losses...without bagging or alcohol soaking. I just discovered a large fallen wild apple tree...I'm curious to see how this works out...I may turn both ways to compare the success rate.

Re: cracked bowls

#4

Re: cracked bowls

eliot d

>I once attended a demo by John Jordon. He hollowed a vessel with the grain parallel to the lathe bed with the pith in; so it was in the base when he finished. He made a point of telling us that we should not be afraid to just drill it out and fill it. He said that too many turners were too worried about getting a hole in the bottom and should concern themselves more with the aesthetics of the vessel. (I'm just passing on what I learned from a "big hat" turner)

Re: cracked bowls

#5

Re: cracked bowls

eliot d

>Sorry to respond to my own post. But I just remembered that you gals/guys are also "big hat" turners. I often forget just who I'm corresponding with on this excellent site.

Re: cracked bowls

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: cracked bowls

Keith Tompkins

>Hey Eliot, John was hollowing end-grain with the pith on the base. That presents a similar problem to the diagram I posted....the pith may develop radial cracks. So even though one is turned end grain, and the other is turned side-grain, they both have the same chance of cracking on the pith. ON the other hand, a bowl turned with the pith towards the base may help eliminate the problem. I'm curious to see if others agree with my observations.

Re: cracked bowls

#7

Re: cracked bowls

Ken Grunke from SW WI

>Sure, you get a nicer rim on a non-NA bowl if it's facing outwards, with less tendency to warp in weird ways. I sometimes look for log chunks that have "flattish" areas on the outside, where I can get the most bowl furthest away from the pith.

Facing the bowl inwards towards the pith is really nothing more than a material-saving measure, and little else.

Re: cracked bowls

#8

Re: cracked bowls

Hooligan

>Keith, that is one of my primary concerns when I start cutting. Before I am even thinking about going to the lathe. I try to saw my blanks in a manner that is going to allow me to turn the foot/bottom with what would be leg center.

I've also been very fortunate lately, to get a lot of logs that I am able to quarter. I did a brief comparison, and I have about 90% less movement, and NO loss when turning quarter sawn. I tried it with a walnut log recently, and had zero loss on wet 1/4 sawn walnut, from tree to finsih in 2 days. As well, the bowls have stayed nearly perfect round, and perfect flat.

Anyhow to the original topic at hand, I follow you, and I concur.

Re: cracked bowls

#9

Re: cracked bowls

John Lucas

>Eliot I am definitely not a big hat. In fact my head is so small I have trouble buying hats. I have to go to the boys department to get hats and then they are too big.

Re: cracked bowls

#10

Re: cracked bowls

eliot d

>That hat guy, another "big hat", J. Michaelson, could certainly fit you with a proper -sized hat!

Re: cracked bowls

#11

Re: cracked bowls

robo hippy

>As far as I can tell, there are always some cracks off of the pith. If you don't want cracks in your bowls, you have to cut these out (cut out all you can see, then remove a little extra). Reaction wood, which is under stress, can also crack more than straight grain pieces. Often on larger log sections, I will remove a 2 to 6 inch quarter sawn piece out of the center of the log. This can be good for platters, or individual sized eating bowls. The remaining pieces can be used for big salad bowls. I don't like to turn regular bowls from the outside in, as it wastes too much wood, but on woods with strong medulary rays (spell?) like oak and sycamore, this is how you get the rays to show up. I don't like to leave pith in any bowl that is intended for daily use. You may get it out the door in good shape, but there is no guarantee that it will stay that way. Given that wood moves, the pith areas, from the center of the log or from a branch will move differently than the straight grain, and will fail some time.

robo hippy

Re: cracked bowls

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: cracked bowls

Keith Tompkins

>Thanks for all of the comments. I guess what prompted me to post this was the amount of times I see people post about cracks ruining their pieces. I seem to be unusually lucky when it comes to this, so I'm trying to understand why. I think one problem may be that people start with a small-diameter log, which forces them to turn a bowl with the pith facing outward in order to get any decent size out of the bowl. This may account for some failures.

I'm aware of the problems associated with "reaction wood" but I'm wondering how many people don't take that into account when they saw up their blanks.....it's possible that many (cherry for example) blanks crack because they contain reaction wood, and the species had little to do with it. BTW, I have fun making goblets from reaction wood branches, just to see how much they distort.

I think I'll turn some apple blanks, and just let them do what they want, and observe how, why, and how they crack....paying attention to grain orientation. Might be an interesting subject..

Re: cracked bowls

#13

Re: cracked bowls

eliot d

>Hi Keith,

Could you explain your next to last sentence? I'm afraid I don't understand it.

Re: cracked bowls

#14

Re: cracked bowls

Keith T

>HI Eliot, my comment about apple blanks was meant to study how many bowl blanks cracked when turned with the pith in the base as compared with those turned with the pith at the rim. ...apple is notorious for cracking, so seems like a good candidate to study.