Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

I've never had this much trouble!

Posts

I've never had this much trouble!

#1

I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>I'm hollowing out a small( about 5x5 in.) HF through a 3/4 in opening. None of my larger tools with constraints, lasers, etc. are any good for this one, so I've been making various tools from 3/8 in. hardware rod and 3/16 in machinists bits. The wood is dry buckeye burl, and it's taking FOREVER. I'm trying for 1/8 in thickness. (Also the bits keep coming loose.) I don't feel confident at all, and find myself wondering why I'm putting myself through this. I guess I'm crying in my beer like this because you are the only ones who can sympathize.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#2

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

john lucas

>Eliot I think 3/8" is a little too small I think 1/2" would be better for a 5" piece. You get chatter which makes it hard to cut. I drill 1/4" holes for my 3/16 bits and haven't had any of them come loose. I just barely knock off the corners so it's somewhat of a press fit. Then I glue them in with Medium CA glue.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#3

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

GeeSeaWhy

>I agree with John, 3/8" is too small to go that deep and that far out. I just spent this evening digging halfway down a similar form in cherry - not fresh and wet but not dry either. Mine is a bit under 4"x4" but I've already had to switch to the 5/8" Keltons - the 1/2" tool is just screaming and is about as far over the tool rest as it will go.

Graeme

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#4

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

Leppikallio

>Depending of what kind is the form it would really help and obviously speed hollowing if you could hog most of the waste with something... I have been roughing some hollow forms and boxes lately and Berger's hollowing tool is really nice for rapid waste removal... Depending of form only waste which has to be removed with bend hollowing tool like keltons is under the shoulders but the "egg shape" can be hollowed with "Berger hook" alone. After waste removal those 3/8" shanks are just enough, I have used those mini keltons (I only have those) succesfully.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#5

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>Thanks for the help. I was beginning to suspect the 3/8 in tools. But now I'll have to either purchase some 1/2 in curved tools or go to a mapp gas torch to make my own, because I understand that 3/8 is about as large as you can bend with propane. Most of my tools are 3/4 in. -- too big. I have sort of made it point of honor to not enlarge this opening. Incidentally, I measured the size of the piece: 5x5 is not quite correct. It's 4 1/2 in. high and six in. wide near the top with a nearly flat top that curves back into the vessel a little. So it's one of those kinda flat river stone shapes.

You know it's funny -- if I ever get it off successfully and sell it, it won't go for much because it's small. I guess I'd keep it.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#6

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

Carole Valentine

>Never underestimate the price of small. You'd be surprised. ;)

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#7

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

Allen Neighbors

>Eliot, drill and tap a hole for a set screw. Then you don't have to worry about the cutter coming loose.

The others are right about the size, too... 1/2 inch is better. You can easily bend it with a propane torch. I do. If you off-center the hole for the tool bit just a little, a 1/4" set screw will be hidden below the surface of the shaft, and will not give you any trouble at the opening. And off-centering the hole will not weaken the use of the tool. I've got several that I've made for different things, and never had a failure. If you make the hole to fit a 1/4 inch tool bit, you can still use a 3/16" bit in it.

Allen

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#8

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>Alllen, People have been advising me to glue a square bit in a round hole.To do it your way, how do you grind the small round tenon on the end of the bit to fit nicely into the hole that 's drilled into the shaft? I've been fooling around with a little grinder in a Dremmel , but it's not a precise method.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

Brad Vietje

>Hey Eliot,

Hang in there and sharpen/hone often. I agree with the comments so far that 1/2" shafts will be more stable, but I've made HF's of this size using 3/8" tools, both straight and angled tip, as well as a curved-neck tool for smoothing the ridges later. Keeping those little bits sharp can help a lot.

I also coach people to lower the rest, angle the handle downward and SHAFT upward (don't rotate the tip upward) to cut a little above center, rotating the tip CCW (down) to give you a little more shear angle than a blunt, 90 degree scraping cut. If you're anywhere near your final thickness, say down in the 1/2" range, you can brush some mineral oil in there, and sorta lubricate the cutting action a little. This will mean a little more difficulty getting the chips out (they'll be a little soggy and oily), and oil might even come out the pores and end grain of the wood. Doing this can affect your finishing options later, and as Russ has pointed out, will tend to soften any of the polymerizing oil finishes, but may allow you to finish the piece with a gentler cutting action. Whenever I apply mineral oil to a piece, which I sometimes do when wet sanding a green piece, I remove some of the oil after the wood has dried by applying mineral spirits and drying a few times before soaking in a hardening oil finish.

Good luck !

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

Keith Tompkins

>Eliot, maybe this will help...First, ask yourself...why am I attempting to hollow the piece through such a small hole?

Consider using a larger hole, maybe 1 1/2" or so. That way, you get the ability to see and feel how the tool cuts. As you gain experience, you can eventually make your entrance hole smaller and smaller, if desired.

Hollowing through a small entrance hole is considered by some as a sign of skill...however, I feel the size of the opening should be kept in relation to the size of the hollow form.

Hope this helps.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#11

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

Russ Fairfield

>Besides echoing what Keith said, these things always are easier to do early in the day when we have more patience. This is not something you want to hurry to get it done before supper. Go slow and measure often.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#12

Re: Turn it! ;)

Ed in Leaside (Toronto, Ontario)

>Drill a hole in a block of wood, on a faceplate, or in a chuck. Tap the square bit in the round hole and have at it with your Dremel or an angle grinder. Be careful and watch where the sparks go.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#13

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>Keith. Of course, you're absolutely right: the size of the hole should be determined by design considerations. -- not showing off skill. In this case the piece is quite small (4 21/2 high, 6 wide); so a small hole really is called for. Also , I have done many with bigger holes, so I thought I could sort of "move up to " the next skill level to meet the design requirements of this particular piece. I just didn't realize how much difficulty I would have.

By the way, I did get it off successfully; and I'm quite pleased with it. A wall thickness of 1/8 in turned out to be in the too- hard category. but it's 3/16 and feels very light. When my son comes by this Sunday ( I think) I hope he will help me get a pic out so people can see what all the fuss was about.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#14

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>Russ, Boy, are you right on! And that's exactly what I did. I found myself stopping every few minutes to check progress. And I did stop early each evening so as not to push too hard and move the piece into the fire wood pile.

I have to admit, also, that I was inspired by a David Ellesworth video, where he hollows through a 3/4 in. opening without any jigs, restraining fixtures, lasers, etc. He gets 1/8 in wall thickness. On this video he makes a much larger vessel. Actually, I think a larger one may be easier in some respects.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#15

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>Brad, Your suggestions have the feel of genuine craftsmanship. Oil together with using the machinist's bit in a sheer mode is something I just wouldn't have thought of. I will try it next time for sure.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#16

Re: It's easy to round over.......

JamieDonaldson

>.... a 3/16" machine square bit by sticking it into the chuck of a drill and grinding with both drill and grinder running. A little practice and it's a piece of cake. I also sometimes mount the bit in the jaws of a threading tap holder- it holds square pieces well and allows good control for shaping bits on the grinder.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#17

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

Russ Fairfield

>The difference is that Ellsworth has made about 10,000 of these things. The rest of us need calipers, lasers, and a lot of time, to get thin walls

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#18

Re: Not a round tenon, Eliot,

Allen Neighbors

>I'm talking about a square cutting tool. If you make the hole large enough to fit a 1/4" square cutter, the set screws will hold it in the proper angle for cutting. And you can still use a 3/16" cutter, because the set screws will hold it, too.

Make sense?

Allen

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#19

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>But isn't it a shame that the price ( read value to others) that a piece will fetch seems more or less mathematically proportional to its size ( excepting , of course, those turned by the "big hat" turners. ) After my ordeal, I think the price should be INVERSELY proportional to wall thickness and size of the opening!

Strangely, I feel differently about my turnings now. I don't know if I can explain it. The extreme difficulty of this particular piece seems to have taught me some kind of lesson that I'm still thinking about. It was a humbling experience.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#20

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

eliot d

>Well, I can tell you that I have a new appreciation for this craft. I don't think I can go back, whatever that means. It seems that many are very worried about Art and Design, my self included, which is not a bad thing. But I'm beginning to think that there is something profound in the pure craft of the thing --as I suspect you have discovered in the craft of fine finishing. I'm scheduled to take his three day class next June. I hope some of his special gift will rub off.

Re: I've never had this much trouble!

#21

Re: Not a round tenon, Eliot,

eliot d

>Yes, it makes perfect sense. I had a fixed idea about part of it being round because that's the way my John Jordon ones are made. Thanks for your help.