Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Turning punky wood

Posts

Turning punky wood

#1

Leo Van Der Loo

Turning punky wood

Leo Van Der Loo

>There have been questions about what to use on punky wood, so that it could be turned without ripping the wood fibers out, when sharp tools and good tool position will not do.

The usual answers of water, wax or oil, CA or PEG and life is to short to ^*&%$# around with bad wood.

However I have used before the thinned white glue with water approach, with some success.

Couple a months ago I had to make more room in the shop for more wood again, short story is I found some elm in a plastic bag that was past due, turned it anyway and made some pictures of the result when the wood was dry after immersion in the glue soup, and after turning it again, no sanding, just off the tool result.

The glue soup I use is 50/50 white glue/water and the rough turned wood was dried first for a day or two then immersed in the soup for a day, then left to dry for a couple of weeks till fully dried, then finish turned.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: Turning punky wood

#2

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: Turning punky wood

#3

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: Turning punky wood

#4

Re: Turning punky wood

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole Georgia

>Thanks, Leo, it turned out real well.

When you say "white glue", is that like Elmer's glue for paper?

Re: Turning punky wood

#5

Leo Van Der Loo

Home Depot 1 gallon glue for paper wood cardboard

Leo Van Der Loo

>

Re: Turning punky wood

#6

Re: Home Depot 1 gallon glue for paper wood cardbo

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole Georgia

>Thanks, Leo, I'll check it out tomorrow.

Re: Turning punky wood

#7

Finishing?

Jack Savona

>After the glue mix has dried, will an oil finish penetrate the surface as well as on an untouched surface?

Re: Turning punky wood

#8

Re: Turning punky wood

Peter Hyde

>Leo, I have used the same mix with the same results but had finishing problems with oils. I have also used a 2lb shellac that I applied until it stayed wet. After a few days of drying it gave the same results and I was able to get a beatiful finish by wet sanding with diluted BLO allowing to dry and buffing. The 2 cherry bowls I posted earlier were treated this way.

Re: Turning punky wood

#9

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Finishing?

Leo Van Der Loo

>I'll post some pic's in a couple of days, and you can see the results.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood

#10

Re: Turning punky wood

GaryG in MD

>Peter: And I thought you were going to say you used hyde glue. ;-)

Thanks for the tip on shellac. I tend to like shellac, in general, and sometimes use it (sprayed) to retard drying (and cracking) in some of my rough outs -- it works pretty well. It seems logical that a good soaking in liquid shellac would firm up a punky piece very nicely. It will be interesting to see how Leo's bowl takes oil. I've got a piece of heavily spalted maple that I soaked in 50/50 white glue, so I have a vested interest in that too.

...Gary

Re: Turning punky wood

#11

Re: Turning punky wood

George Van

>Thanks Leo, I am anxious to see the results with oil on the bowl.

Re: Turning punky wood

#12

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood

Leo Van Der Loo

>Thanks George, but you'll have to wait also, just like me, the oil needs its time, and I'm not that much in a hurry, usually .

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood

#13

Re: Turning punky wood

George Van

>I plan to live a long time, I can wait!

Re: Turning punky wood

#14

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood

Leo Van Der Loo

>As promised, here are a few pictures of the outcome of the punky wood bowl that I gave the glue/water treatment.

I finished the little bowl with pure tung oil and today sanded and finished it, made a couple of pictures, first just the sanded and polished wood and then a couple after putting on some carnauba wax.

I did not cut enough of the punky wood away after I had hardened the punky wood, and there is still spots that are low for that reason, however the wood is solid and took the tung oil pretty evenly, considering the wood is figured and wild grained.

The wood also sanded just fine with no uneven spots like you get when sanding punky or spalted wood, however I can still tell that there was soft punky wood, even though it now is solid.

So it works for saving wood with some too soft wood, if it is worth doing it, is for you to decide.

I certainly will continue to use the glue/water mix for the times that I do get some small checking while or after rough turning, that has worked very well for me.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo


img

Re: Turning punky wood

#15

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood 

Leo Van Der Loo

>


img

Re: Turning punky wood

#16

JL

Re: Night and day...

JL

>That turned out really nice! The visual depth of the bowl, what with the grain pattern is very appealing.

Re: Turning punky wood

#17

Re: Turning punky wood

George Van

>Wild grain is an understatement Leo. It appears your efforts were rewarded! Thanks for posting.

Re: Turning punky wood

#18

Re: Turning punky wood

George Van

>Leo, you never mentioned the type of wood or size? Just curious.

Re: Turning punky wood

#19

Re: Turning punky wood

Ruth Niles

>Wow, Leo, that piece of wood was certainly worth the effort and I don't care what John Jordan says about life being too short and crappy wood!

Re: Turning punky wood

#20

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi George

Thank you George, sorry for not mentioning the size and wood used

It's made from some Siberian Elm and it's approx. 7" X 2"

The process and outcome, where what was mostly on my mind.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood

#21

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Turning punky wood

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi there Ruth

Thanks, Yes it worked out OK, but it would have been easier if I had not let the wood sit so long and get all punky.

How are you doing Ruth ?? and hows your new place coming along ?? miss your posts on the rec site.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo