Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Question about Hollowforms

Posts

Question about Hollowforms

#1

Question about Hollowforms

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>How far (to what grit) do you sand the interior? I'll sand the outside to at least 600 or even more, but does the inside need the same treatment? Also, do you finish the inside with the same finish as used on the outside?

Thanks.

Scott

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#2

Steven Antonucci

at least 12000...:-)

steve antonucci

>and through a 1/2" hole...

Truth is I don't sand the insides at all, but I am turning through smaller and smaller holes every year...

Occasionally, I will sand the immediate, finger-reachable area to maybe 220.

Steve

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#3

Re: Question about Hollowforms

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>TD has rigged a motor to turn the hollowform slowly with stones inside to smooth the wood. It is a great idea and as soon as I can get my hands on one I want to set it up in my garage where I can keep an eye on it since my shop is some distance from the house.

I always finish the inside with at least one coat of oil.

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#4

Keith Tompkins

Re: Question about Hollowforms

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Scott, I realize that many turners sand the inside of their vessels, but as a rule, I don't unless it has a large opening. I realize this goes against the advise of many respected turners here, but here is my reasoning.

I come from a furniture background, where the backs of cabinets, drawer sides, etc, are made of secondary woods, and do not receive the same attention as the "show" wood. The backs of casework, even the top museum pieces, show planing marks; no attempt has been made to remove them. This shows the hand of its maker...and makes the rest of the piece even more impressive when you realize the whole piece was crafted by hand.

Likewise, I like the look of the toolmarks inside a well-turned vessel. You KNOW the piece was turned by hand, and the craftsman left the marks as a signature of his skill. A wonderful example of this is an Ellsworth hollow form.....A look inside reveals the toolmarks left by a master turner. I've studies several of his pieces...and I'm still in awe of that display of skill.(by hand, no lazer, supports, captured rigs, etc.)Yet, they appear to have been made by automated equipment.

If I had the choice of producing a perfectly sanded interior, or a uniformly tooled interior, I'd choose the tooled surface any time.

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#5

Re: Question about Hollowforms

Carole Valentine

>Oooh! Ooh! oh! I like that philosophy, Keith! Do I have to get as good as Ellsworth before I can adopt it to my own turnings and throw away my forceps? ;))

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#6

Re: Question about Hollowforms

Dinyar Chavda

>Keith:

Having taken David's class, I go for the tooled look also---I'm just not fussy enough to worry about the "uniform" part! I think ripples give even more credence to the handmade label. :-)

D

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#7

Right on Keith!

Jorge Castaneda ~ Downeast Maine

>I subscribe to that philosophy myself, being turned off by sanding and don't mind leaving the exterior of the piece sporting the tool marks as well, think of it as a more honest look and indeed some people like that, don't know anout the galleries, we must educate them... :)

Jorge

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#8

Re: Right on Keith!

don in central IL

>I've only turned two HF so far (and love it). I have not bothered with sanding the interior. I can't see much point, personally. As long as I can get it fairly smooth with the tools, I'm satisfied. Besides, most of the people I've shown the HF to, never looked inside. Just my $.03 (adjusted for inflation).

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#9

Re: Question about Hollowforms

Craig Daymon

>I'm still working on not having a hole in both ends of my hollowforms, but I did buy two large hemostats/forceps to use to sand the insides. They're about 12" to 14" long and one has a curved tip. The idea being you grab some Scotch-Brite in the jaws and you can sand inside with it. So, about 10" is the farthest I'll likely go...once I get one that doesn't allow easy access from the bottom.

-Craig

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#10

Re: Question about Hollowforms

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>Thanks for all your quick replies! Not sanding the interior (or at least not much) will make the job much easier.

Scott

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Question about Hollowforms

Keith Tompkins

>Absolutely not, Carole. Otherwise, I'd have to sand mine too. Not to say that there is anything wrong with sanding either.

Re: Question about Hollowforms

#12

Re:Attention Craig- DO NOT.....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. use hemostates or any other device which encircles or otherwise wraps around your fingers, because you stand a good chance of losing them!! If the sanding material, and Scotch Brite is not for sanding, is grabbed by the wood, your fingers will be twisted at whatever RPM the lathe is running, and the results are potentially devastating!