Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

OK, I may have been wrong

Posts

OK, I may have been wrong

#1

OK, I may have been wrong

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Several of my WC friends and several manufacturers have been educating me to the facts about some of the very newest (and in at least one case - very expensive) Waterborne (WB) lacquers. In fact, most of the new ones DO burn into the layer below as long as the recoat time is less than 24 hours (downside is you may not recoat before 30 minutes vs 10 minuts for NC).

So, Keith and others, I appologize about my assertions about WB Lacquer.

But I do have another question: With NC Lacquer to clean up dried overspray in my spray area (when I am in a cleaning mood), I can just moisten a rag with thinner and welt/wipe it all off. What about the WB lacquer? They talk about using a stripper to clean up a spray gun.

Thanks

Mark

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

#2

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

Rusty

>Lacquer thinner will soften and lift dried WB lacquer.

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Mark, Not a problem, this is really a new technology, and something I'm just becoming aware of myself. Industry is swithcing over to WB: mandatory, there is no choice.

The switch to WB finishes is affecting all industries, including the woodworking sector.

The neat thing about the newest equipment is there is virtually no overspray....nothing visible to the eye! The savings in material will make up for the costs of equipment. Another good thing: no more cloudy finishes on humid days! the finish starts out opaque, and dries clear...it just takes longer to dry on a humid day. Moisture won't be trapped under the finish as in solvent based lacquers.

Once cured, it's impervious to water. I'm curious about the long-term reliability of the stuff...

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

#4

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Mark: I've been using Waterborne lacquers for about 3 years. I use Crysta-Laq which was recommended by a cabinet maker. It provides an excellent, very hard finish and remains clear over several years (I can't verify how long, but understand it is about indefinite). The down side is that you must use their Thinner and their Retarder. The retarder is necessary when spraying in order to slow down the drying time to allow the media to flow better. Also, you cannot use a stearated sanding paper before finishing as the stearate will cause "fisheye".

On the other hand, fellow club members really like a "water based" finish (they use Resistane from Highland Hardware). No retarder necessary, and you thin it with water. Also, there are no warnings about using stearated sandpaper with it. I've yet to use this product but plan to order some soon.

On another note, I read in some periodical a couple years ago that the Sherwin Williams water based lacquer fared better than most others in a "test" by that periodical (I can't remember which one) staff.

When I use it on darker woods that I want the grain to "pop" on, I put on a coat of Tung oil first, let it dry a couple days, then spray it on. I sand with 600 between the 5 or 6 coats, then Micro-Mesh to desired shine.

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

#6

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Ed,

Good info and definately worth checking into.

I would like to caution all woodturners, that the finishes made for the cabinet industry may not always be good for the type we do.

At the risk of repeating myself:

A couple of years ago, I was down in Houston, TX, and had dinner with Sam Simpson, who used to moderate the Finishing Chat when we had them on Thursdays. He is a restoration EXPERT, and is an expert in finishing as well. We discussed lacquers on turned wood over dinner one night. I talked about wanting to try some of the new lacquers, pre-cat or otherwise. He cautioned me against most of them. He told me that most of the new development work going on in the wood finishing industry was focused on the cabinet industry - i.e. people making things out of composite materials (MDF, etc) that do not move much, and they want to be able to spray finish one day, and ship the next.

Our turned work, is much more flexible/movable than anything that the cabinetmaker has to deal with, and not only that, our work gets much more handling, hands, fingernails, thinks placed in them, etc.

He told me that the industry most closely our requirements is the fretted musical instrument industry - volins, guitars, etc.

So that is what I have tended to do. I am now seeing waterborne lacquers coming up in their finishing forums, and so I am trying to follow their lead. They are doing some really cool things. I am lucky to have a great custom guitar maker here in town. I have not talked to him for a while. This might be a good time to see him.

This not a rant, and certainly not directed at you, Ed, just some information I wanted to put out....again.

Mark

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: OK, I may have been wrong

Keith Tompkins

>HI Mark, I checked out the site...looks pretty good. I guess it can be referred to as an acrylic lacquer.