Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Holdfast vacuum chuck

Posts

Holdfast vacuum chuck

#1

Holdfast vacuum chuck

Lynne

>Does anyone have any experience using the Holdfast vacuum chucking system, which uses an air compressor rather than a vacuum pump to create the vacuum? I think it's a pretty new product. I'm thinking of buying one and want to know what to expect.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#2

Hiku

Rick Allen

>Compressor vacuum?

Loud and wears out compressor

Stand alone pump better

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#3

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

John Lucas

>I'm not familiar with that particular model other than seeing it in the adds. Several years ago when I was looking for a vacuum system I went over to a friends house who had a similar system to the one your looking at. It was very loud and required a compressor about 3 time the size of the one I had. I searched the web looking for a Ghast pump and then found one at the flea mkt. Much much quieter and doesn't tie up my compressor. I do some air sanding and my compressor can barely keep up with that. It certainly wouldn't handle both.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#4

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Arch

>Lynne, I once made a vacuum system using a $9.00

Harbor Freight venturi box. It worked ok, but I soon gave it up for the reasons Rick & John mentioned. I've played with reversed compressors and vacuum cleaners, even a vacuum cup used for carrying plate glass, but I recommend that you profit from my bad ideas and go with a pump. :)

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#5

Rick, That Is Too Good! :-)

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#6

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Lynne, I've had one of their earlier models in the shop to do some testing. It seems to work as advertised. I was using a 5 HP (hah!) compressor with a 27 gal tank, and setting the regulator to the specified pressure, I was able to keep vacuum on wood throughout the cycle of the compressor without any loss of vacuum. I also got the thing to pull as much as 27" of Hg, so I will say it works. In fact, I did say it works to the people who gave it to me to test - not the manufacturer by the way, although I did speak with him on the phone and again in person in Louisville. I do not have any information on longevity or durability, although it looks to be reasonably well made.

If you have any other questions, let me know.

Bill

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#7

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Pete LaBelle

>Compressed air is a very inefficent means of transmitting energy. We use them here at our manufacturing facility for various reasons and they work well, but there are cost penalties for using them.

Yup, Bill's 5 hp air compressor (2-3X larger than most lathe motors) may keep up with it, but you're running a 5 hp air compressor to do what a 1/3hp vacuum pump will do.

Go with a pump.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#8

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck *LINK*

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Lynne,

I looked at their set-up at the AAW in KY. The rig that I looked at in Packard's booth was listed as 15" hg. max which is OK for larger stuff and platters, but not for smaller items with less cross sectional area. Note also that the induced CFM flow through the venturi is not all that much, so the system will not tolerate leaks or porous wood.

Add to that the cost to run an air compressor motor as compared to a real vacuum pump, and this doesn't look like much of a deal. You can contact the Surplus Center at the link and do a search for vacuum pumps as they have very good Gast 5cfm vacuum pumps for $90 if you have 220v available in your shop. You can also contact Bernie at hydrolicparts.com as he rebuilds Robinair pumps and had some 115v 6cfm vacuum pumps for about $175 delivered which is a great deal. [Usual disclaimer here]


Surplus Center

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#9

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Gary Gardner

>This is not a commercial add but I do sell the Stikfast and Holdfast products. I have both a vacuum pump and vacuum generator system. Some notes on the generator system: It only uses 2.2 cfm and 60 psi of air and I use a pancake compressor to demo the unit. During a demo the compressor only runs once after the initial running to build up pressure. I live in rural Georgia and have power flashes and with a vucuum pump the piece flies off the lathe but with the air buildup in the tank no problem. The generator has no moving parts so it should last forever. again this is not an add for the product but I use it very often and sold many without a complaint. So I say buy the unit and forget the loud pump.