Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

Posts

Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#1

Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Any of you ever watch it? Dave Hout is the host. Since it's difficult for me to avoid watching anything that has to do with working wood, I don't know whether other people consider it worthwhile or not. However, there've been a couple of things bugging me for a while that perhaps someone might be able to help me with.

He did an episode once where he (and the student) made a lidded box with threads. The first time I watched it, my eyes sort of glazed over the micrometer cross-slide chuck holder attachment that he used (the subject of Question #2 shortly) and I didn't really grasp some of the other material. Also, this was pre-DVR for me.

The second and third time I watched it, I sort of fell asleep during the critical part (measuring for the diameter of the mortise in which the female threads are to be cut). The fourth (or fifth) time I watched it I finally stayed awake for the critical part, but it just seemed wrong (if you've seen it, you may know what I mean—if you haven't the explanation may be tough to follow). In the critical part, he used a dial caliper to measure the outside diameter of the male thread on the jar. He then used the caliper's inside jaws to mark the blank for the female threads. But that makes the inside diameter of the female threads the same as the outside diameter of the male threads, and in my pea brain, that doesn't work (think drill diameter necessary to tap for a given thread—has to be smaller than the nominal thread diameter).

Finally, I caught it again yesterday and I think I know what the problem is. I believe an edit was done eliminating a crucial adjustment that had to have been made to the caliper before scoring the blank. I could see that there was an editing discontinuity in the video, and I'll bet that some post production weenie utterly non-conversant in the mechanical arts cropped it out of there to meet time constraints, having no idea how critical that operation is to that task. Anyone else agree?

Question #2: where can one get that micrometer cross-slide chuck holder attachment (he used it on a Jet Mini)? And do you have to be Rockefeller to get one?

Thanks.

Rod

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#2

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

john lucas

>Rod Can't answer all your questions but can help a little. I've been looking at the threading machines for a while and bought Fred Holder's book on threading wood. He shows how to do it by hand, has some photos of hand built machines and shows one of the real threading machines.

Bestwoodtools sells one that is an excellent machine. It's called the Baxter threading machine. They aren't cheap but are extremely well made. Dave was good friends with Willard Baxter so I'm guessing that this is the machine he used but it could have been a Klein. Best wood tools is a little behind on production of the threaders right now because he made some modifications to improve the quality and had to work out all the details. I talked to them about the theader at the AAW symposium. Since I wasn't ready to buy one just yet I didn't ask about actual shipping dates.

Bonnie Klien also sells one but I don't know what all lathes it will fit. It's not as versatile as the Baxter machine but does the job well.

Al Crandall built a homemade version and had plans on the internet somewhere. Perhaps someone saved it.

Sorby sells a special caliper to be uses for sizing while using thier thead chasing tools. I've never looked at it closely because I own 3 sets of dial calipers and figured I could use those.

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#3

Steven Antonucci

It's a Bonnie Klein jig

steve antonucci

>I'm pretty sure he mentions it on the show. (you may have nodded at this point :-)

I really miss Modern Masters...

Steve

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#4

Re: It's a Bonnie Klein jig

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Thanks, guys. Having that info and doing a search found the product. It's not quite Rockefeller money, but it's close enough that I don't presently need to pursue this aspect of turning (especially not having mastered any of the others).

By the fifth viewing, I had pretty well finished nodding off. I'm fairly sure he never mentioned the name.

Thanks.

Rod

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#5

Re: It's a Bonnie Klein jig

Carole Valentine

>I don't even bother to check that show out anymore. It has been nothing but re-runs for as long as I can remember.

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#6

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

Barry Irby

>I'm Pretty sure it is a Klein Jig. I don't have one, but a friend does and Having seen both (at a glance) i think they are the same.

I saw the show and I believe he says something like, "We measure the outside diameter of the threads here and they are 1.85 (something) here and then we make the inside 1.75 (something smaller) here." I have plastic calipers and was sort of taken aback by the fact that he marked the wood directly with the calipers.

Apparently I watch these shows somewhat differently. The way I saw it was: Oh, HE uses a threading device (similar to the one my friend has), and does not do the hand chasing of the threads. Ahh!, there are tricks for adjusting the fit and grain alignment. Oh, yes, the female part would have to start smaller then the male part. Then I conclude that if I wanted to do this, I would have to acquire a threading device and practice using it.

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#7

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

don lewonczyk

>I'm glad I am not the only one that has to watch something 8 or 9 times before I get to see the whole VHR or DVD with out falling fast asleep. I even fall asleep on my tractor raking hay, you should see my windrows. Have a good one! donl

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#8

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs. *LINK*

Fred Holder

>I don't have the DYI channel available on my television and don't watch much television anyway, but I wrote the book on "Making Screw Threads in Wood." When it comes to making threaded boxes or bolts, always make the female thread first; i.e., the lid or the nut. Then measure the inside diameter of the threads in the lid and call this measurement "D". The dimension for the threaded area for the male thread is then D+A. Where A is an adjustment equal to 1.38 divided by the TPI. For example for a 16 tpi thread A= 1.38 divided by 16 = 0.08625. See the drawing for more details.

Robert Sorby has a thread fitting caliper, which may have been the one used. You can measure the inside threads and then size the tenon for the outside threads for several thread pitches. However, if you have a digital caliper and use the formula I've mentioned you can come out ok every time.

Bonnie Klein has a threading jig, which she has been revising; The Baxter Jig is a rip off of Bonnie's jig and is supposedly good; Craft Supplies Ltd. in the UK has a thread jig that fits into the tool rest and works but is a bit fiddly; and Soren Berger of New Zealand is coming out with a new jig that fits into the tailstock and will fit any lathe with a No. 2 Morse Taper. I reported on it in the August issue of More Woodturning and have ordered one which should be shipped the end of September. It looked real good when I saw it at the Utah Woodturning Symposium this summer.

All of these, except the one from the UK, are a bit pricey. I personally use hand thread chasers. I can cut threads in a piece of hard dense wood like boxwood while someone is trying to set up a threading jig. I personally recommend that every woodturner add thread chasing to their set of skills, because it is so useful.


img

Fred Holder's Domain Site

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#9

Thanks, Fred.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>Very informative post and great visual aid. I love visual aids (see earlier reference to pea brain).

Rod

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#10

It's really sad.

Rod Peterson -- Ormond Beach

>As you may or may not know, I am a huge fan of Norm Abram and The New Yankee Workshop. It came as a great shock to me to find that I fall asleep during that show almost universally. It's a good thing I've recorded all of them.

Rod

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#11

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

Dave Belser

>Thanks Fred.

I read about the tailstock thread device in your last issue. Can you tell us the price and/or where to find it?

You state that the lid has the female threads and also show it that way in the diagram, is there any other reason for this besides tradition or personal preference?

- Dave

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#12

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs. *LINK*

Fred Holder

>Hello Dave,

Supposedly, Craft Supplies USA will have them eventually. I don't know when. At this time, you can order them directly from Soren Berger. Soren's address was given in the article as was his e-mail and web site. I believe we paid $275.00 for it, but didn't know whether that included postage. I simply told him to bill us for the postage and I would send a check. He said it would be ready to ship on the 15 of September, but I asked him to wait until the end of September when we would be home from our trip to Australia.

The only reason for the lid being a female thread is because I've always done it that way and most of the people that I know who make boxes do it that way, except the French, and they seem to have a tenon on the lid which fits into the box bottom. I don't think the threads care which way it is done and the diagram answers the questions for sizing whichever way it is done.


Soren Berger's Web Site

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#13

Please take careful naps...

Barry Irby

>You may have been joking, but I just met my brother's girl friend and she is an Emergency Room Trauma nurse and told us she had treated a fellow who fell asleep running a bush hog. Whoduthunk that was even possible? He will live but had some terrible damage including the lose of a leg. Be careful. Wear a seatbelt. Take a NoDoz.

Re: Woodturning Techniques (on DIY), coupla Qs.

#14

That explains it....

Dave Belser

>I guess I've allways made French boxes without knowing it! :)

- Dave