We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I think this was the second finial I ever did. It's on a piece of pear that Jim Pugh sent me. I hated it as well, so I chucked it up and gave it a trim too. New version on the left, obviously. Glad I had not glued any of these things in yet. Guess I still won't since I might look back 6 months from now and say "yuck!" again. LOL
>a finial, do you turn the topmost part first... like that little pointed end at the very top? Or do you have to wait until you have the basic shape finished before you finish the top?
I keep breaking things, before I can even get the basic shape turned. :o(
Just curious what I'm doing wrong... other than trying to turn a skinny little shape as shaky as I am. :o)
>A big improvement Carole. In Fact, a very nice finial. I've done the same thing a few times. I think that most of us start out by turning finials that are too large. A too-large finial will overpower the piece, which detracts from the whole piece.
>Carole I can't tell you how many finials I've turned over the years. The one you just did is excellent. It fits the piece very well. I think you nailed the shape.
>Allen, always start at the tip and work your way down. That way you have plenty of wood supporting it. Of course these remakes, started out as finials so I had to be careful. Fortunately they were clunky without any really thin sections to deal with!
>These two are not from the pen blanks, Dick. They are reworks of original finials I did a long time ago. But don't worry, I am using the pen blanks too!
I like the shape of the first one better with that HF, it was just to big IMO, what I'm saying is if the first one had been smaller, than that would be my first choice.
The second one isn't bat, I just like the shape of the first one better.
>HI Carole, Wow, that's quite a difference! It's quite remarkable what a few subtle changes can make.
To me, the key that makes the finial on the left successful is the transition from the vessel up to the finial. The vessel is separated from the lid by a small step, the lid then follows the contour of the vessel up to the finial. The finial on the right just sits on top of the form, it's not an integral part.
By removing two of the v-grooves as seen on the right finial, the finial on the left has been given a cleaner, less cluttered appearance...the remaining v-groove serves to separate the elements above and below it. The slimmer finial on the left is far more proportional to the form, in fact the finial has the familiar appearance of a handle.....it makes the viewer want to grab it and pick it up. I'd be tempted to remove the spike at the top.....
A comment on v-grooves on spindle turning...you almost never see v-grooves used as details on classic or antique turnings. Beads, coves, and filets, but not v-grooves. I would suggest to any turner who is attempting to create attractive finials....avoid them as much as possible.
I am going to mention something that will probably be controversial.. (who ME?) I think most viewers would agree that the left finial is far more attractive than the one on the right. Yet, the were both turned by the same person. Now, did your turning skills suddenly improve, or did you simply put more thought into the design on the left?
My point? Anybody can begin making better turnings. It doesn't have to take five years of trial and error. It can happen from one turning to the next. Good technique balanced with an appreciation of design elements. I think you are an excellent example of that.
>Thanks, Keith. I know you are going to fuss at me when I say I did not sketch this out or plan it before I started re-turning it (what??!!!). ;) I am still a seat of the pants turner most of the time. When I did my first finial, I thought it looked pretty cool. What did I know? LOL Why, a few months later, did it look so horrid to me? I think that happens to all of us during the early years of turning and to some extent later on. The "eye" develops as it is exposed to more and more "eye candy" but the technical skills may lag behind somewhat. Eventually, the technical skills develop in response to what the changing "eye" perceives as good. I believe a significant part of both is subconsious.
>Hmmmm....You know Carole, I must confess, I don't always make sketches either. There is nothing wrong with improvising; perhaps that is the ultimate goal.
I think you're right, over time, one begins to discover what works, and what does not. You subconciously skip over the bad stuff and strive to use the things that have worked for you previously.
To me, sketching a plan is important for the turner who is having a hard time visualizing the outcome of their work. It gives them a goal to shoot for. Once one gets the hang of it, a drawing may not be all that important. Sketching is important to me because I can put an idea on paper before I forget it. Many times I'll think of something, and quickly write it down before it's gone. Every one of my best turnings came about that way.