Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

A poll on gluing

Posts

A poll on gluing

#1

A poll on gluing

Thad

>It's coming...in the past 24 hours it has made it from Long Island to Charlotte and will be at my doorstep in central GA when I get off work tomorrow. My first wood lathe is crated up and on the train to Dixie (it's an old Magna with me as the proud 2nd owner). As I am a poor mental healthcare worker for the state, and I have yet to impress my wife with my turning skills so that she loosens the purse strings, I am going to be turning on a faceplate for an undertermined length of time; eventually using the compression and longsworth chucks demonstrated in the articles here. For anyone else who started of this way, or still uses this method occassionally, what gluing method is best/preferred for gluing a turning blank to a sacrifice block screwed to a faceplate? Wood glue? CA glue? Hot Glue? Paper joint?

...or should I go ahead and pawn her engagement and wedding rings while she is pregnant and can't wear them so I can buy a serious chuck?

Re: A poll on gluing

#2

Re: A poll on gluing

Carole Valentine

>Show her the numbers! The amount you saved by buying a used lathe should more than pay for a good chuck. :) I use Titebond. Have not had any problem with it. Many use CA, but I don't trust it's shear strength.

Re: A poll on gluing

#3

Oh, and congratulations!

Carole Valentine

>

Re: A poll on gluing

#4

Re: A poll on gluing

John Lucas

>Thad Depends on the size of the blank. For bowls I use either titebond or 5 minute epoxy. For my hand mirrors and things like small boxes I use medium CA glue. For platters it's either CA glue or double stick carpet tape (the cloth backed stuff).

Congratulations on getting a lathe. It totally changed my life so look out.

Re: A poll on gluing

#5

Re: A poll on gluing

john Kyler

>First of all congrats on the new baby on the way and the lathe too.

I would tell the wife a chuck would make it easier to turn a baby rattle.

Make due otherwise with what you can afford.

Re: A poll on gluing

#6

Re: A poll on gluing *LINK*

Bob Fawcett

>Create a screw chuck.

Put a piece of scrap on the faceplate. Turn it round. Find the center and drill a hole. Put a large diameter heavy sheet metal screw (stronger than wood screws) in the center. Now you can drill the center of the workpiece and screw it on.

Check this site for homemade tools, etc.


Darrell Feltmate's page

Re: A poll on gluing

#7

Re: A poll on gluing

Allen Neighbors

>Thad, I use Titebond II. Have also used Industrial Strength Hot Glue.

Congratulations on the new baby coming... and on the lathe.

You know you're in real trouble, now. Once you get into turning, it's too late... you're hooked.

Don't hock the rings. She'll come around when she sees what you can do. She'll want you to turn more of them, faster, and the chuck will help you do that. :o)

Allen

Re: A poll on gluing

#8

Congratulations....

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Your first lathe...an exciting day. You don't need a chuck to do quality turning. The 4-jaw chuck that's so popular today was first put on the market in about 1990. Believe me, there were many thousand of bowls turned before that. A faceplate used with or without a glue block will do the job. I've been using glue blocks for years with great success. Med. CA glue (use lots of it) works well and is fast. Just be sure that both surfaces are true and flat. You are making a glue joint after all. Don't use a clamp. Just a shot of accelerator and firm hand pressure for 10 seconds will do it. Forget using paper. That just weakens the joint. For screws I like size 12 self tapping sheet metal screws. Don't use regular wood screws. When the piece is finished just part it off the glue block using a parting tool. When the glue joint is almost parted through, pop the bowl off with the heel of your hand. Couldn't be simpler.

Good luck and have fun,

Wally

Re: A poll on gluing

#9

Re: A poll on gluing

Fog Tanner

>My preference is to use a chuck. For doing the outside of a bowl I use a screw most of the time. I have the new Escouleon(sp??) chuck for which I have to use a faceplate/wasteblock for both inside and outside. Faceplate for the outside, wasteblock on faceplate for the inside. For glue I use Titebond I or II, whichever is closer.

For doing some spindle work like making boxes, a chuck is a convience which is necessary if you want to make them in a short time frame or save wood. If not then you can even use a faceplate for those too. Once the addiction really takes hold, you will find yourself with a chuck - or two - or four and needing just one more.......

Re: A poll on gluing

#10

Re: A poll on gluing

Gil Jones on Lake Seminole Georgia

>Congratulations!! on the lathe, and the new life on the way too. For waste blocks I use Titebond, and sometimes generic-Gorilla glue. I will sometimes use CA if the piece is quite small, and time is a problem, but CA (IMNSHO) is too brittle.

Re: A poll on gluing

#11

Re: A poll on gluing

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Actually, after turning many hundreds of bowls and vessels using a glue block and CA glue, I can tell you that the rumor that CA is too brittle is not deserved. Works fine for me and has for several hundred students of mine.

Wally

Re: A poll on gluing

#12

Re: A poll on gluing

Fog Tanner

>It is not so much brittle as the shearing load on the joint. A number of years ago, I read an article on the various glues and their strengths in glueing wood. Of epoxy (long setting), CA, and the glues such as Titebond and Wilhold. The order of strength in shearing actions was Wilhold/Titebond, epoxy, and CA.

The order of least elasticity was CA, Epoxy, and then Wilhold/Titebond. At the time I was dealing with high performace racing aircraft and was able to stress the glue joints to their limits. The findings of the study were pretty much in line with actual experience. In building a raceplane that would be subjecting the glue joints to a 52 "g" load, I would use five different glues, including CA, in the areas where they provided their greatest strength and kept them from the areas where they would have the greatest sucess at failing. Never lost a 200mph airplane due to a glue joint failure, pilot error yes, occuping the same space as another plane - a few times (some number greater than one).....so I approach a bowl as being just as lethal and the same respect.

Re: A poll on gluing

#13

Re: A poll on gluing

Earl

>For what it's worth, you are in good company. David Marks, who certainly does outstanding turning and has several lathes, including the big Oneway, says he prefers a faceplate and glue for most projects. Chucks are certainly nice and I use one all the time, but certainly not necessary. It won't improve your turning skills one bit. LOL So don't feel bad, you can just screw the faceplate on to most projects and use glue blocks for the rest.

Earl

Re: A poll on gluing

#14

Re: A poll on gluing

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Very interesting Fog. I guess that the stresses encountered with woodturning just aren't enough to cause problems. In all of my bowl turning classes the students use an alder glue block and CA glue. I always demonstrate the use of a chuck but I want the students to know that an expensive chuck is not necessary to turn bowls. In the beginners classes especially, we sometimes have a flying bowl from a large catch. The alder glue block always breaks...the glue joint always holds. We frequently can glue the block back together, using CA glue, and the student continues turning the bowl.

Other glues work just as well, but in a class we don't have time for clamping and waiting for a glue joint to set up.

Wally

Wally

Re: A poll on gluing

#15

Re: A poll on gluing

JamieDonaldson

>I have determined through years of turning that a CA joint is more brittle when used with accelerator. If you take the time to let a CA joint set on its own schedule it will be stronger and less subject to impact failure. This has been discussed with many turners and could best be discribed as a concensus.

Re: A poll on gluing

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: A poll on gluing

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Thad, as one who has used faceplates exclusively in the past, I will tell you...there is NOTHING you can turn using a chuck that you can't turn with a faceplate. And a faceplate is more accurate.

Re: A poll on gluing

#17

Re: A poll on gluing

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>Jamie, I've never had a problem and I always use accelerator. I always wait at least 30 seconds before applying it. Don't know if that helps or not, but it keeps it from fizzing

Wally

Re: A poll on gluing

#18

Re: A poll on gluing

john lucas

>I have to agree with Wally on this one. For several years I taught workshops with nothing but glue blocks because we didn't have the chucks for the lathes (we do not thankfully). I used CA for all glue ups and only had problems one time. I had some bad glue. We started the class and had pieces flying everywhere. I opened up a new bottle and not one bowl came loose.

I will agree that CA is brittle. I use that to my advantage on my hand mirrors. I use CA with Accelorator because the Accelerator makes the glue brittle. I can break the bond between the glue block and mirror by hitting it very sharply with a chisel and mallet. It almost always breaks right through the glue line. I've never lost one while turning however.

Re: A poll on gluing

#19

Re: A poll on gluing

tm

>lots of better brains here than mine.

i use faceplates... mainly because thats what i learned on.

i stopped using the paper joint when i found out it wasnt really needed. my wasteblocks are poplar and im experimenting with fir. titebond for dry wood, gorilla glue for green turning. i have a talon chuck and im using it more often now but a faceplate or screw chuck can do pretty much anything

and feels more secure to me.

now that you have a lathe don't forget to spend equal time with your wife ;)

tm

Re: A poll on gluing

#20

Re: A poll on gluing

George Van

>I started using glue blocks following Wally�s suggestion on an earlier thread a few months ago. I have used them on about 50 hollow forms without a problem. I even used it on a few burl bowls where the blank was small and I did not want to give up any height by creating a foot, I also seem to get better access to finish the foot or base of the object without the jaws in the way. There are times when I think glue blocks are the best method to use. I thank Wally for recommending them. One time while rough hollowing I had a bad catch on a natural rim piece of spalted wood and tore the form off just above the base. I was surprised that the glue joint held this built my confidence! I use aspen and basswood as glue block material.

Re: A poll on gluing

#21

Thanks all

Thad

>I really appreciate the encouragement and advice from you all. Thank you for welcoming me to the turning family. I hope to be posting pics soon and look forward to losing my mind in shavings.

The UPS website says "Out for delivery" as of 6 AM...I think I may have to knock off early today.

Thad

Re: A poll on gluing

#22

Re:But Wally,you don't have catches!!

JamieDonaldson

>

Re: A poll on gluing

#23

Yeah, But My Students Do..,Big Time

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

>

Re: A poll on gluing

#24

Re: A poll on gluing

Bill White

>Thad,

I have a Magna Bandsaw. It ain't big, but it sure is dead accurate. Give your new lathe a good home. You will have a ball (round-funny-Huh?) Oh well. That's my humor for the day.

Bill