Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Question

Posts

Question

#1

Question

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>On another forum a sculpter asked a question about preventing checks. One respondent replied that normally turners harvest logs, seal with AnchorSeal and store for 1 year per inch of diameter. He also presented other options.

Has anyone ever heard of this? In my experience no matter how much AnchorSeal you put on the ends of logs, if you keep them around that long you will have a mess. In fact some of us would die before a 30" log was "ready". Also, most logs will not dry when whole except maybe after they had rotted.

No other respondent questioned the response.

I think he may have confused air drying lumber with turning wood.

Re: Question

#2

Re: Question

John Lucas

>Barb I do agree but I'll bet the year per inch is probably not that far off it's just how do you keep the wood in good shape until that time. Like you said after a year or so the log is getting pretty punky. You would have to go to extaordinary lengths to dry a whole log without damage. Even splitting the heart out most logs check so bad from the ends that If I cut them 2 feet long I'll be lucky to get a 1 foot bowl out of it if I wait longer than a few months. Thats with endgrain sealer put on the same day I cut them. Granted I don't have good place to store wood. It sits on the ground in full sun all day. I'm working on a solution for that but for now that's what I have to do.

I know from personal experience that the 1year per inch doesn't apply to bowls. My big bowls that are roughed out to 1 inch or more are almost always ready to re-turn after 6 months. 3/4" rough outs are done sometimes in as little as 3 months. I think the large surface area releases moisture better than in log or board form. I usually seal the endgrain areas of the bowls after roughing.

Re: Question

#3

Re: Confused

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>Which he certainly is. 1 inch per year for lumber.

I have held logs for a year or more 'till I had enough to make it worth paying my Woodmizer Guy to haul his wagon out to me. Lost a bit off the ends (that were A-sealed), but that's all.

m

Re: Question

#4

more on drying

John Lucas

>Barb Sorry I had to run and remove some film from the machine. My good friend who makes rocking horses has his wood cut into 5" thickness and then air dryes it in his barn. He stacks it in big piles labeled with the time they are cut. He figures he can use most of it in 4 years. There are losses on each end. Those areas become smaller details on the horses so there's very little loss.

He's actually producing and selling more work now than he used to so he's having to sort of kiln dry the wood. He lets it sit for a year in the barn and then moves it to an insulated room with a dehumidifier in it. I don't know how long he's letting it sit in there but he did tell me it gets hot enough to kill the bugs. I'll try to remember to ask next time he comes in for photos.

Re: Question

#5

Re: Question

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>John

You need to remember the rough out bowl at one inch dries from both sides. 1/2" per side = 6 months to center of 1" At least this is how I always thought.

As I live in very dry areas I have to dry my rgh. outs in plastic tubs with lids on. Daily I remove the lid for a short time to remove moisture and re lid.

Good turning and be safe.

Bill in Dolores, CO.

Re: Question

#6

Re: Question

Keith Newton

>Barbra, I think he was trying to sound like an authority on something that he doesn't really understand.

When I have done sculpture, or large turnings, that take a long time, I will keep a spray bottle to mist it with during the day, then at night, I cover it with something like an old bedspread or something that greatly slows moisture loss, but doesn't stop it completely like plastic, which will encourage mold.

As far as the year per inch thing, that is favoring the dense end of the spectrum. some of the softer woods like cedar may only need about a third of that time.

Re: Question

#7

Re: Question

Russ Fairfield

>There is a difference between theory and reality. What he says may be true in theory. The reality is that, if it doesn't crack apart, most wood will form an internal moisture barrier when it is stored in the whole log form. Once this barrier is formed the movement of moisture across it will be much slower, and it can stop altogether. The wood between this barrier and the outer bark can be bone dry, while the wood inside of this barrier is still at the green moisture content. This same thing happens to kiln dried dimension lumber when it is dried to rapidly.

I recently saw this in several pieces of 18" Walnut that had been stored for over 20 years in log form. There was a 10" core that was just below saturation moisture content, while the outside was dry. There was no cracking to allow the internal moisture to escape. So much for the 1" per year theory.

Re: Question

#8

Re: Question

RobinCorell

>There is is lesser known axiom that says that the one year per inch only holds true for 4/4 stock. Not only was Murphy a wood worker he also dabbled a bit as a sawyer, me thinks.

Robin

Re: Question

#9

Brad Vietje

Confused and usually wrong

Brad Vietje

>Barbara,

Others have commented on the drying schedule -- 1 year per inch, and various species, etc... (funny aside -- I just went to proof read that, and I had originally typed "crying schedule"...)

I would take an entirely different approach in answering this. Most non-turners, and many new turners, especially those that have only used KD or air-dried stock, COMPLETELY miss the mark on how to use locally-harvested wood for turning (bowls). There is this notion that one must put the wood up and store it until it is dry enough to use -- utter nonsense.

MOST turners would rough turn the bowl out of green wood (in my humble view the sooner the better), and THEN seal or bag it and dry it according to a drying schedule that takes into account local climate, species, thickness, etc... And that's only if you intend to re-mount the piece to true it up after it dries; non-turners (as well as many new and not-so-new turners!) have a hard time conceptualizing a once-turned, thin walled bowl or vase that's allowed to warp and distort as it dries -- HERACY !!!!

Many on this forum may not do this, or may not like the result, which is fine, and has more to do with preferences than understanding the process. Of course, we get newbie questions every few weeks or months asking how long they should wait until trying to turn a bowl from some found wood ... I say: "don't wait a day, turn it today !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Question

#10

Leo Van Der Loo

It's just not possible, longish

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi Barbara

One thing no one mentioned, it is physically impossible to do whole log drying without splitting/shecking.

OK lets draw this out on paper,draw a let say 6" circle with a lot of smaller circles in there, just like a slice from a log, now mark the centre 4" the hearth wood, and the outside 2" is sap wood, you now dry the hearth wood 7% and the sap wood 9%, as what happens in real wood, the difference is often much bigger, not only that but also the outside moisture exits first.

Now how would it be possible to have one part of the whole log get shorter/smaller while the rest does not ???

If all the wood was sap wood and soft and open wood and you where able to get that moisture to leave evenly right from the very center it would be possible, so never say never, but for all practical purposes it's just not possible.

As for the 1 year per inch, yes that's a rule of thumb for sawn lumber and is used also for turned wood, but in my experience you could cut those times in half or better in most cases, if thinner you can almost wait for it.

For thicker wood the waiting times are much higher, wood is a very good insulator and like Russ mentioned the moisture just does not have a reason to leave, it will stay there for a long long time.

The large life sized wooden sculptures that I looked at as a boy growing up in Holland, where made up out of long pieces of wood in sizes ranging 2" to 6" by 2" to 6", these sculptures where made in a time when the time to dry wood was just that, if it took 6 years than you would wait for 6 years, or at least use wood that had sat that long.

Also they (sculptures) where hollow, either the back and center or at least the center if they were smaller dimensions.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Question

#11

Re: Confused and usually wrong

John Lucas

>Brad I agree with you and turn to completion whenever possible but sometimes I simply can't. I can rough turn 5 to 10 bowls in one day depending on size but can only finish turn half that many or less depending on the details etc. Therefore I when I get a load of wood, in order to save as much as possible I split the wood, seal the ends and then during the rest of the weekend I rough turn anything I can.

Any exceptional pieces that I don't want to take a chance on losing I put in a plastic bag and make sure I turn it within a week or two or maybe 3 you know how it goes.

I don't worry much about drying times anymore because I just put them on the shelf and get back to them when I can. As long as I do this frequently there are always plenty of dry ones to work on when I run out of green wood. In fact I tend to turn more fresh green wood to completion so I'm acutally building a stock of rough turned pieces because I never seem to get back to them.

Re: Question

#12

Ric Taylor

Re: Question

Ric Taylor

>Barbara,

To answer your question, yes, I have heard of the one inch rule from several sources, and I have also read about it in several places.

I have several log sections of pecan, hackberry, ash and redbud in my garage. Each is about 9 inches in diameter, 15 inches long, and the ends are anchor-sealed. All are drying nicely with no checking. I live in humid Houston, and there is no a/c in my garage.

They have been stacked there for about six years. They're almost ready! :)

Ric

Re: Question

#13

Brad Vietje

Absolutely

Brad Vietje

>John, I do just what you do -- I didn't mean to suggest that people ought to turn to completion from wet wood, just that some people would never even think of it. Mostly my point was that there is no need to wait a few years before rough turning a bowl from fresh-cut wood.

I tend to turn natural edge pieces to completion in one go. Most everything else I turn twice, with a few months to a few years in between. Ocasionally I'll turn a bowl or hollow form from figured wood or a burl to completion, just to get the rippled effect when it dries, or to make it impossibly thin and translucent. Like you, I sometimes rough turn a few dozen pieces in one session, date 'em and box, bag or wax them and set aside to dry, and there always seem to be a good crop of older, dry pieces around to finish when I need to finish off some. The problem is, I love to rough turn green wood, and I'm not so enamored of finish turning and sanding, so I'm accumulating quite a stock of dry and drying bowls !

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Question

#14

Brad Vietje

Answer

Brad Vietje

>Ric,

You can certainly wait 6 years if you want, but you could have finished these as bowls 5-1/2 years ago, with no waiting to get started:

1. Rough turn and leave them much thicker that you want the final bowl to be -- for an 8" bowl perhaps you want a final thickness of about 3/8" to 1/2", so rough them to about an inch or so. Avoid the pith (center of the tree) by staying well to one side or (and) the other.

2. Wax the end grain sections. If really valuable and/or highly figured wood, consider waxing the whole thing.

3. Dry for about 6 months (depends on the wood, etc...)

4. Finish turn, sand polish. Most people put the warped, dry bowl on a jam chuck of some sort, such as a disk of wood held in a chuck or faceplate, which drives the bowl from the inside while the tailstock supports the foot. Once the outside and the foot is made round again, smoothed, sanded and polished, the bolw is turned around and the insides are trued up, sanded and finished.

5. Enjoy your fine craftsmanship, or give as a gift !

There is no need to wait until the wood is dry to rough turn bowls or other turned forms -- really. The wait is after the bowl is rough turned, and before finish turning. The finish turning is thus done on air-dried wood. There are actually quite a few pitfalls in trying to dry whole log sections, as Leo pointed out. You may have cracking inside the logs that you don't see from the cut ends, or spalting, rotting or mineral staining that you might not intend. The biggest loss is your time.

I strongly recommend Turning Green Wood, by Michael O'Donnell for lots of good information on drying logs and bowls.

Best of luck with those logs,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Question

#15

Re: Absolutely

john lucas

>Brad I have the same problem. I get excited about turning that particular piece of wood but once it sets on the shelf for a while it's hard to get excited about it again.

Re: Question

#16

Re: Absolutely

George Van

>Brad, I understand what you and John are saying about roughing! I think it is the addictive hunt to see what is under the bark that keeps me going. Got over 2,000 bowls roughed and just recently went out to the woodlot and hauled more logs to the decking area, not to mention the 30+ logs spalting that I turn three times a year. I really do have to do some finish work this winter after I finish panelling the house I am building.

Re: Question

#17

Re: Confused!

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

>I think you guys are addicted to making mulch rather than finished turnings. Have to agree that green wood makes much better shavings!! |;-}}}}

Re: Question

#18

Ric Taylor

Re: Answer

Ric Taylor

>Brad,

I've been doing this for quite a few years now. My preference is to turn dry wood, for many reasons. I don't do green wood, and I don't rough-turn anything.

All of my projects are straight-through start to finish.

This works for me, and I'm sticking to it.

Ric

Re: Question

#19

Re: Answer

Allen Neighbors

>Ric, that'd be the way I'd do it, but I never have any cured wood.

Allen

Re: Question

#20

Ric Taylor

Re: Answer

Ric Taylor

>Thanks Allen. From one aviator to another, I always enjoy reading your postings.

Ric