We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>While organizing my files I came across this piece; mulberry burl form with an ebony collar and finial. The finial threads into the collar. I think this would have been a good example to discuss in the chat on finials. This pieces is a "study" of a squat, compressed form mated to a long finial...just to see how they look together.
I think it's interesting to note the "filets" that separate the elements within the finial. I borrowed the shapes from classis forms.
>Keith, I had decided to attempt a tall finial (though probably not as detailed) on a "space ship" form I turned today and was wondering if a really tall one would look right. You just answered my question before I even sketched it. Will I succeed? Who knows. If not at first, then eventually!
>Keith, this is a beautiful finial -- no limb excursions there ! Here's the "out on a limb" part: I'm not convinced that Cindy Drozda is the master of the long, delicate finial. People can attack me if they wish (but hey, be nice about it !), but that's just my view. More about your finial in a moment...
Don't get me wrong -- I LOVE Cindy Drozda's work, and admire the whole creative use of figured/burled wood, beautiful forms, gold leaf, AND her elegant finials. But, truth be told, some of her work, cited as examples of near-perfect finials, could be improved. She makes long and thin finials, but sometimes the proportions of the figures in a given finial could be better. That is, she sometimes has a large element leading to a small element which leads to another large element -- and something's out of balance when the mass of one element doesn't seem supported by the ones below it. Maybe I'm just too rigid in my sense of design, but I like to see the turned elements relate to each other, and lead the eye upward from larger, more massive elements to lighter and smaller ones.
Now back to your finial... the finial shown has a lovely progression from larger to smaller figures, and excellent small details seperating these elements. I agree -- these little fillets and stops add a "snap" to the whole piece, and help to set off the turned figures. I can't make out in this photo what's going on just below the flame figure at the tip, but the progression and the sizing of the elements is spot-on. In other words, IMHO, this is a better finial than some of Cindy's that are so raved about. I'd need to search about to find an example of what I consider a less-than-excellent Drozda finial, but this one is on the money.
BTW: I like the long, delicate finial to lift up the more squat form below it.
>Keith, this is a very well done finial. I like if very much However, I'm questioning the too-tall look of it for this form. How tall is too tall? This finial would look better on a tall slim vessel. With this vessel I think that it tends to overpower the piece. When I look at the piece I see the finial first. I feel that some of Cindy's finials are too tall for the same reason. Also, I like a curved surface wherever possible and the long upper portion of this finail doesn't allow it. It's almost like a contest to see who can make the tallest finial.
I guess that what I'm saying is that in my opinion this piece would be more attractive to me if the upper portion of the finial was shortened by quite a bit.
>Keith, I'll venture my reaction. Both the form and final are pleasing and first rate. At first glance the tall dark delicate finial reduced the form to being a mere base for displaying the finial. Then I observed with pleasure the proper and pleasing shape, lines and finish of the form and saw the finial as an an inappropriately delicate appendage. To me, and only me, the form--finial combination is not complementary, ie. neither makes the other (or the entirety) more perfect. To some extent the form--finial combination is supplementary. ie. each is a forced addition to the other. Meant in good spirit knowing that I could not have turned either
I'm inclined to agree with Arch. I went back and looked at the picture again and I realized that I see the form as merely a base for a very nice finial. To put a scale on things, let's assume that the overall height is 10. Then the finial is at least 6 and I think that 4 1/2 would have been more in proportion.
As Arch suggested, it's less of a marriage than it might be. Maybe it's a modern marriage with each having their own career.
>Hi Brad, thanks!If you study antique chair designs, you will find similar turnings....if you doubled the finial, it would resemble chair stretchers I've turned in the past, where the big bead is right in the center.
Below the point is a filet with a half-cove...hard to see in the photo.
I think you all expressed pretty much the same thing: the finial seems a bit too tall. I'll admit, I'm pushing it a bit. But, it's a necessary evil, I think....to see how things are really going to appear in the finished piece. I think I'm at the limit, or even a bit beyond. I really wanted the effect of the form showcasing the finial...sorta' like a fountain of water in a pool.(my other piece in the chat had that effect as well.) Arch picked up on that.
I considered an ebonized lace pattern surrounding the collar to unify the piece, but didn't want to distract from the beauty of the burl, or make the piece too busy.
Wally, I tried to make a gradual taper along the longest part of the finial....I should try my publishing program to modify the image, just to see how the shorter finial would appear. Hmmmm....I wonder how the golden rectangle would apply here....the height of the finial to the width of the form? I appreciate the input, thanks all.