Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Hard headed persitance

Posts

Hard headed persitance

#1

Hard headed persitance

john lucas

>I'm sure someone else has done this. I started an off center piece that was supposed to go with another turning. I started it out without a drawing or even a really firm idea of what it would look like. So naturally as I proceeded I kept changing it slightly as the design emerged. It just wasn't looking right so I changed it more. I carved on it, put it back on the lathe, turned some more, carved some more, turned some more. I refused to give up on it even though it just wasn't working with the original piece.

Fortunately I finally decided that it would never look right so I tossed it. I feel silly for spending that much time on something. When I first saw that it wasn't going right I should have tossed it, grabed another piece of wood and started over. It's too easy to settle for a mediocre piece when you try to save a piece of wood.

I'll paraphrase John Jordan and Richard Raffin. Life's to short to waste time on a mediocre design. Sit down, think it over, make some sketches and you will probably come up with a decent design. At least that's how I hope it will work with this one.

Re: Hard headed persitance

#2

Yes, and no.....

Molly Winton

>I've been there many a time John. Sometimes I realize after investing too much time, I should have cut my losses much earlier. HOWEVER, on occasion that persistence pays off. I've also had times where I think, "I'll try just one more idea..." and BAM, it's gorgeous and something new. Granted, it doesn't happen very often, but I've found it's worth the effort for the possible outcome. At the very least I chalk it up to one more learning experience of what not to do in the future. We can learn as much from our mistakes as we can our successes. Hang in there, it was worth it!

Re: Hard headed persitance

#3

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Hard headed persitance

Leo Van Der Loo

>Hi John

I think in a case where you have to make a part that has to go with another part, one should usually have the dimensions and shape established beforehand, but I go by the seat of my pants mostly when I chuck up a piece of rough wood, not until I have gotten a round form do I mostly look for the final form, even than I do run into the "Back to the drawing board" occasions, and that is really what keeps it interesting for me, always new and always different.

And no you can't win em all, but I keep trying.

Have fun and take care

Leo Van Der Loo

Re: Hard headed persitance

#4

Re: Hard headed persitance

Ron in Drums PA

>When I get to the point where I know a shape is not worth the time, I start practicing different cuts and shapes. Sometimes, I might even learn something different.

A bad day turning is better than a good day at work.

But then, I'm not turning for the income.

Re: Hard headed persitance

#5

Re: Hard headed persitance

George Van

>Hi John, I chuckled when I read this because I had just done that with a maple burl piece. I was determined to keep it because it was burl but every time I re-sketched it didn�t work. Finally the all the design opportunities were ending up as shavings on the floor. I saved the last for tooth pick holders! (;-)

Re: Hard headed persitance

#6

Re: Hard headed persitance

don in central IL

>At least you have a toothpick holder and not just a couple of toothpicks!

Re: Hard headed persitance

#7

Re: What makes it worse is.....

Jamie Donaldson

>....that was a big piece of brown mallee burl that cost big bucks! I have only heard of such things happening to others, and now I wonder if I can get a refund on this defective piece of burl I bought??!!

Re: Hard headed persitance

#8

Re: Hard headed persitance

Merv Graham Richmond BC Can

>Well having seen Richard Raffan start out with 2 pieces rejected from another session and winging it to a gorgeous lidded bowl I have come to the conclusion that there is not a really lousy design just some that need refining. I mostly start with the wood and a rough idea of what might be in that piece of wood as far as shape and let it dictate to me to some extent what the final shape will be. Less dissappointment that way

Re: Hard headed persitance

#9

Now, now ! ! !

Barry Turner

>Now, now........not so fast. Think of all the practice you got along the way.....

Re: Hard headed persitance

#10

Re: Now, now ! ! !

john lucas

>Barry Your right about that. I don't turn many off center things like that so it was a good skill builder. A really lousy piece but a really good skill builder.