Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

sanding sealer

Posts

sanding sealer

#1

sanding sealer

gary s clarke

>When should one use sanding sealer and on what type of wood? Any advantages or disadvantages on the different type of sealers? I have had good results finishing without using sealer and wonder if I am missing something. Thanks

Re: sanding sealer

#2

Re: sanding sealer

Gregory Haugen

>I turn alot to Bob Rosand's thoughts and theories. I use Sherwin Williams interior sanding sealer thinned to 50/50 with a good turpentine like kleanstrip. I brush it on a piece, let it soak for 20-30 seconds and do a final, lubricated, clean cut. More as a cutting aid for a clean final cut. I have done this with a variety of finishes and haven't had an issue yet. I have used the same mix a few times as a sanding sealer or for wet sanding, like burl, as it dries and the sanding dust is in the pore it seals it off and gives a more even surface.

Sealers are usually shellac or shellac based, Minwax's and Sherwin William's though are different, I don't know what they are. They are the only ones that will mix with turpentine.

Try and get a hold Russ Fairfield, he's the man for finishes.

Hope it helps.

Re: sanding sealer

#3

Re: sanding sealer

Mike Brazeau

>Gary - I like Mylands Cellulose Lacquer sanding sealer on light coloured woods that I do not want an oil finish to make amber. Box elder for example or spalted beech. It works best on small objects, but will work on larger things too. Apply first, cut back with 320, 0000 steel wool or grey synthetic and then follow with another finish like General Bowl Finish or just wax. That is all Chris Stott uses during his demos. Also you can apply and sand immediately and fill grain on an open grained wood. This was advice I picked up a few years back after searching out the best alternative and have not regretted it. You can live without it, but it gives you that something extra.

Mike

Re: sanding sealer

#4

Re: sanding sealer

Russ Fairfield

>The "finishing gods" giveth, and they also taketh away. In other words, there is no magic, and every gain has its cost.

Sanding sealer is a finish to which a lubricant has been added so it can be sanded before it has totally dried or cured. Most of the sanding sealers are shellac, but there are also lacquers and varnishes. Shellac can be sanded without a lubricant in 30 minutes to an hour, lacquer can be sanded in 2-hours, and an oil varnish can be sanded without a lubricant in 24-hours. Adding the lubricant allows them to be sanded in just a few minutes. That is the "giveth".

The "taketh away" is that the lubricant that is added to the finish is an opaque material, and the brilliance and clarity of the finish will not be the same as it would have been without it. The lubricant of choice for the finishes is stearic acid, a white opaque powder. If you can't see the bottom of the can, there is something in there that will be left on the wood.

Whether you consider a sanding sealer as a finish is a personal choice. To me, the color and opacity of the finish do matter, and I can tell the difference. If you can't tell the difference, then use the sanding sealer as a finish because it is faster.

Re: sanding sealer

#5

Re: sanding sealer

gary s clarke

>thanks for all your interest and information.

Re: sanding sealer

#6

Re: sanding sealer

don in central IL

>Since I'm a new turner, let me get this straight. When I get ready to finish sand, I can put on one of the finishes you mentioned and then finish sand in the 30 minutes, 2 hours and not worry about 'sanding sealer'?

Re: sanding sealer

#7

Re: I make my own sanding sealer....

Jamie Donaldson

>.. out of the old thicker Deft lacquer at the bottom of the can. I dilute slightly with acetone, just a glub or two will do, then wipe on and wipe off the sealer on the surface. The lacquer will improve a final cut where tearout is a problem, seal the pores, and serve as a primer for the final finish.

Re: sanding sealer

#8

Re: sanding sealer

Ed Heuslein

>Howdy Gary: Ask a hundred turners about their finishes and you'll get a hundred different answers. Read Russ Fairfields response. Then read it again. He's right. My input is like "cheaper isn't necessarily better", "Quicker ain't necessarily better" either. You've taken the time to turn and sand it, take the time to finish it. It'll show.

Re: sanding sealer

#9

Re: Jamie, is Deft Lacquer

Allen Neighbors

>nitrocellulose based? I'm wondering, because I didn't think you could thin lacquer with anything but lacquer thinner. Just curious.

I know that acetone cleans the lacquer off my eyeglasses, but didn't know I could thin with it.

Allen

Re: sanding sealer

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: sanding sealer

Keith Tompkins

>A sanding sealer question(?) I haven't used sanding sealer under an oil finish; I have some reservations concerning the practice. Part of the beauty and durability of an oil finish is the fact that the oil penetrates below the wood's surface before polymerizing.

If we apply sanding sealer to the surface before applying an oil finish, are we not just putting a coat of oil on top of the sealer? (that would explain why light woods don't seem to turn yellow) The sealer to wood is a mechanical bond, and the oil to sealer is a mechanical bond as well. I wonder about the long-term durability of that combination.

End grain absorbs oil at a different rate than side grain, so many coats are usually necessary to get a uniform finish. A coat of sanding sealer seems to solve this problem, a couple of coats of oil and it's done. It's quick, but is it durable?

Anybody experience long-term problems with a sealer-oil finish?