Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

To make or buy? (somewhat long)

Posts

To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#1

To make or buy? (somewhat long)

Dominic Greco in Richboro PA

>Greetings all!

With the baby and starting a new job, I haven't had much time to spend in the shop. However, I did manage to spend a hour or two last week working on some peppermills for a demo I'm giving at the end of next month. I intended to have (5) of them, in various stages of completion, all ready for the demo. This ardous task reminded me why I stopped making peppermills in the first place! I think the worst part is the drilling!

What I really wanted to be doing was finishing up a white ash burl bowl that has been waiting for the past month. Or making a set of 3 point tools. Or re-vamping my waterstone sharpening setup (for flat work). OR, maybe....dare I say it? Work on the long delayed Dust Collector upgrade (it's only been hanging around for 5 years!)

But I digress. I find that with my new commitments, shop time is at an all time premium. When I get the time to spend, I have to use it in the most efficient manner. Some tasks get put to the side until later. Others just cancelled.

For example: making a 3 point tool. At Bill's 5 Barns BBQ last month I tried out William Duffield's shop built 3-Point tool and was very impressed. So much that I wanted to make one (or several of different sizes) myself. Being a do-it-yourselfer I've made several shop built tools and have had a alot of fun.

So I get all excited and look for the drill rod. No one local has it. So that means ordering it. And from MSC, it's a $25 min order. Not a big deal. It's only a 3 day wait. Then I need to find the brass nuts to use as a ferrule. Again, not a big deal. But still it takes up time. Then there's drilling the blank, turnig the handle, grinding the profile, and then actual assembly.

Now Packard Woodworks and Craft Supplies USA sells a 3/8" diameter HSS 3 Point tool for about $26.00. See where I'm going here? Depressing as it sounds, it appears that buying the tool is more economical, and will yield more efficient use of my shop time.

So it's settled.

Done!

I'm going to buy a 3 point tool from one of these vendors.

So there!

In a stunning display of logic I've determined the best course of action that will maximize my shop time.

outstanding!

I should be proud of my capicity for deductive reasoning.....

yipee......wahoo

Then....could someone please explain to me why I'm so bummed out?

It feels like that time when I was 8 yeas old and my younger brother snuck downstairs, opened all the cereals, and stole all the prizes inside.

See ya around,

My ugly mug


Dominic

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#2

Steven Antonucci

See my reply on the Messages board, Dom.

steve antonucci

>

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#3

Re: Yer shoppin' at Tiffany's 'stead of Walmart.

Al Crandall (NE of Indy)

>Dom, if you had only told me soon enough, I would have picked up a 3/8" x 8" round hss tool bit for you at Wholesale Tools yesterday when I was down there. It's only $2.15 each and I'd mail it to you for a couple of bucks. If you are enamored with drill rod, try on line at use-enco.com for a 3/8" x 36" piece at $2.79 each. No minimum order amount. Jen lives a lot closer to WT than I do. Maybe she could be your "go to" girl.

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#4

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

Lan Brady

>Dom,

I like to make tools.

But I like lathe time better.

I wanted a hollowing rig, but priced out of my range, so I built it.

My 3/8" round skew was only 19 dollars with the store discount, so I bought it.

Time is the one part of each equation that I cannot change.

Good Luck with your decission, Lan

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#5

Steven Antonucci

The answer you seek...

steve antonucci

>is one of "the Engineering Way". You can't see paying $26 for $0.50 of steel- and neither can I. I ground my 3 point on a belt sander in 5 minutes, and I haven't bothered to harden it (it's hard enough).

Grinding 3 facets in .50 of steel just ain't worth $26. Plus, I've got enough left over to make a few Ellsworth style hollowers. Go Enco.

Steve

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#6

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Dom, The tool I built has an advantage over the commercially available tools. Specifically, the hex compression nut ferrule makes it self jigging when you need to regrind the bevels. The three bevels are automatically indexed at 120� degrees to each other. That means that the cutting angles are consistent, and do not perform just a little differently, no matter which cutting edge you present to the wood.

Steve, there is a difference between drill rod and the drill blanks I use for mine. The drill blanks are fully hardened. Drill rod is sold in the fully annealed state, or soft. That means it takes longer to grind the initial bevels in the drill blanks, but the tool holds an edge signifiantly longer. You spend most of your time with the tool cutting wood, instead of resharpening it. Alternately, with the drill rod, you have to find someone to heat treat it to harden it.

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#7

Well...

Raymond Overman in SC

>That's why I work so darn near a Wholesale Tool location. Lunchtime at the candy store! Funny thing is, my wife bought me some drill bits for Christmas at WT Tool and ordered them online. She paid shipping from Maryland to Charlotte.

But, that said if I was in your shoes Dom and I wanted a 3 point tool and I had $26 in my pocket, I'd have me one delivered pre-made and not worry with spending $25 on a minimum order. That is if my lovely wife said it was ok.

I've got a 10" or 12" piece of 3/8 drill rod I'll send you if you email me your address if you just feel dirty about spending the $26 though.

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#8

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

Ron in Drums PA

>I know exactly what you mean.

Sometimes it's just easier and quicker just to buy a tool instead of making one.

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#9

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

Mike Brazeau

>Dom - I made a triple point last fall out of a shock absorber and when I turn anything now, I am always looking for a beading opportunity. Grinding is very easy once it is made. Initially I wrapped a piece of masking tape around it, unrolled and divided into thirds with marks, reapplied and ground holding the mark on the top position. For about a $1 Cdn I buy nice brass ferrules from Lee Valley now and it makes my tools look totally professionally made. I love making tool handles, especially if I have some Osage handy. It is always nice to pick up a tool you have made and most of the wood I have collected has a story behind it that comes back to me.

I am retired and can never find enough time to turn, so I know your circumstances. You would think it gets better with age, but so far not true.

Mike

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#10

been there done that-screwed up anyway

John Lucas

>Dom I've been there so many times. I spend way to much time making a tools. I made my first 3 point tool from a screwdriver. I was never happy with it because I didn't know how to use it. I gave it away. Then I learned how to use one so I built one out of 3/8" drill rod. I use it some but still don't see any advantage over a small spindle gouge or skew so I use it very little. Sometimes on platters that need a lot of beads I find it useful.

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#11

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

John Lucas

>Mike you should have left the shock absorber assemble. It would have a good handle and if you get a catch the shock absorber would Absorb it. We could also add some lead shot to reduce vibration.

Re: To make or buy? (somewhat long)

#12

Re: Belt Sander?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>A belt sander would certainly work quicker than the 8' white wheel I use to make mine, but somehow I get the feeling that these work better with a hollow grind. In any case, I've got some more drill blanks, so I'll give the belt sander a try, if I can figure out how to jig it to give consistent bevel angles.