Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

removing nubbin at bowl center

Posts

removing nubbin at bowl center

#1

removing nubbin at bowl center

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>My wife is turning small hand bells for Christmas tree ornaments. They are about 1.5 inches in diameter, of various hardwoods. She is having problems removing the little nubbin at the center of the bowl. She has used her gouge and small scrapers. I suggested pre drilling a center hole and then not hollowing any deeper. She doesn't like my answer. Please let us know your favorite method of solving this problem. Thanks

Bill in WNC mountains

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#2

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

Carole Valentine

>Bill, I use a round nose scraper, toolrest above center. Start with edge below the nub and come up (very light cut), swing slightly to left back to center, down and repeat til nub is gone.

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#3

JL

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

JL

>At the risk of angering the true bowl people, I'll give you my way. Get as close as you can with a gouge. Then run a 1/2 round scraper across the bottom.

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#4

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>Bill,

Carol and JL have it right as far as I am concerned - Carole's discription of the technique is about the same as Bill Grumbine's.

HOWEVER, if the appearance of the bottom is of importance (I assume it is or you would not be asking), do not over do it and turn the pimple into a dimple. Pimples are much easier to sand out than dimples.

Mark

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#5

Same Technique As Carole

Barbara Gill, Remlik VA

>Except I use the Sorby multi tool scraper.

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#6

a tool for removing the nubbin

Gregory Haugen

>Our club Pres. found this somewhere. If you have or can find one, a good use for carbon tool. Find a shallow (continental or forged) spindle roughing gouge about 3/4", not a tradional SRG the shallow ones. Grind it like a scraper, upside down, so the underside of the bottom of the flute if you will is the pronounce edge. Sweep the back into a normal round scraper profile. With it upside down on a tool rest, resting on the high points of the orginal arch. In other words it looks like a stepped on "n" on the rest. Use it like a scraper in scraper configuration, a little below center or at center. What the "arch" gives you upside down is a shearing angle on a scraper, more cut less tear. I have used this inside and outside for shear scraping. A soft light touch will give a shearing cut.

One use for a old 3/4" carbon steel shallow fluted gouge.

just a thought.

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#7

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

robo hippy

>I cut it with the gouge, or some times with a scraper that has a 1/4 round point and is cutting at a shear angle with the point down. The most important thing to remember is that the center is moving so slowly that the feet per minute rate approaches almost zero (bringing up the debate does the center really move at all?). This means that the feed rate of the tool is much slower, and you really have to slow down and feel the cut, and not push the tool through the center. Since the bowl bottoms are flatter, the cut tends to be more along the grain rather than through it, and tear out more. Shear angle, and very light pressure.

robo hippy

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#8

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

John Lucas

>Bill I'm going to be really different here. Most of what I've seen above is really good advice for getting rid of the nubbin inside a hollow vessel. I find the best way to get rid of it on a bowl is to turn the flute of the gouge so it faces the tailstock. The cutting edge will then be straight up and down. If you move the gouge very slowly (the wood is moving very slow at this point as was mentioned above) the gouge will cut through the nubbin and simply stop cutting. If you have the cutting angle any different it can catch the upspinning part of the wood and may cause a very slight dig in. If you keep the cutting tip totally vertical it won't do that, it will just stop cutting. The main secret is to simply slow down the cut and be patient, it will eventually cut the nubbin off.

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#9

1/2" Round-Nose Scraper

Barry Turner

>

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#10

Re: Thanks everybody, gonna try all

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

>

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#11

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

eliot

>I use a somewhat unconventional method. What I do is use a swan neck hollowing tool -- WITH THE LATHE RUNNING IN REVERSE -- and approach the nub from the RIGHT side of the nub. In other words, you swing the swan neck tool from right to left starting on the right side of the nub. I find that all the other methods run the risk of having the tool whip around the nub so that the tool shaft can bang against the opening and wreck the piece. If the opening is large, the other methods are safe enough,

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

#12

Re: removing nubbin at bowl center

HarryB

>Drill a 1/4" to 3/8" hole down the center of the work. Make depth of the hole just a little less than the final depth of the piece. This helps you two ways:

1. When hollowing, you know when the proper depth is reached. (You run out of hole!)

2. There is no nubbin in the center of the bowl, you drilled it out.