Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

How sharp is "sharp"??

Posts

How sharp is "sharp"??

#1

How sharp is "sharp"??

Russ Fairfield

>These discussions on sharpening always confuse me because everyone is using different terminology. I can add to that confusion with the following.

My opinion is this, and I have no idea whether it agrees with anything that has already been said.

There are only three (3) things to remember:

1. There are only two (2) ways to separate wood fibers - we can tear them apart or we can cut them apart.

2. Sharp tools cut better than dull tools, and the sharper they are they better they cut.

3. The lower the tool angle to the wood, the cleaner the cut, and the better the finish it leaves behind. Skewing the edge of the tool at an angle reduces the cutting angle.

Skews and spindle gouges with low angles cut the wood fibers apart and therefore sharpness is a virtue. The sharper they are the better they cut, and honing and buffing the edge is justified.

Withe the angles on a bowl gouge, an how we use the tool to remove a lot of wood, we are getting very close to tearing the wood apart and the sharpness of the edge doesn't matter as much, and we can get by with a more ragged edge on the tool. In fact, the edge on a bowl gouge might give a better "bite" in the wood if it is a bit rough along the edge, and an edge that is straight from the grinder can be the better. Honing and polishing are a waste of time.

Finishing cuts with a bowl gouge are no different from finishing cuts with a skew or a spindle gouge and the sharper tool with lower angles at the cutting edge leaves a better surface on the wood.

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#2

Paul Porter

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

Paul Porter

>Russ, can you illustrat number 3. I'm having a hard time visualizing that one...it might be something I'm already doing and not know it.

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#3

that pretty much nails it.

John Lucas

>

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#4

Re: that pretty much nails it.

David Galloway

>Russ, you are always helpful to me. Whenever I see your name next to a message, I click it. I have never been disappointed. Thanks for your gift.

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#5

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

robo hippy

>I am not sure about #3 either, but I think it refers to the difference between a shear cut, and a scraping cut. Then also, if you can skew the shear cut, like the difference between using a hand plane straight ahead, and at a skewed angle, the skewed angle is less than the straight angle. I have had a theory that when using a bowl gouge that when cutting, since the end is curved, part of the blade (closest to the cutting surface is shear cutting, and part (away from the surface) is scraping.

robo hippy

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#6

Hone

W.C. Turner

>After using the grinder, I don't hone. But, in between using the grinder, I'll use one of the Diamond sticks(the ones with a handle, ezlap, I think)to freshen the edge, instead of grinding.

Is this, also, considered "Honing"?

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#7

Just My Opinion

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>I agree with Russ 100% (I do 99% of the time, BTW Did you know that 96.5% of all statistics are made up?).

My opinion on a couple of these subjects:

1) Scraping = rough finish. That depends - if we are talking about the type of scraping cut we use to remove wood rapidly - hollowing, etc. Yes, it is rough, and tears the fibers deep and is to be avoided. However, if we are talking about "Shear Scraping" or "Negative Rake Scraping" We are VERY MUCH talking about cutting. That is why they are best used as the final finishing cut after our final cutting with the gouge. It is only that we are cutting with that fine burr created by fine sharpening -not honing. Honing to raise a burr, is possible, but unnecessary IMHO (if you do this, you might want a 120 grit stone on the other side of your grinder from your 80 grit)

2) Again, MY opinion, I find that honing a bowl gouge to a decent level to save the time of touching it up on the grinder - takes more time than just touching it up on the grinder. Stuart Batty makes the case even more compelling case when he sharpens by hand (no jig) - 10 seconds off and back on the lathe, if your grinder is right near your lathe. Now, all that goes out the window if you hone to avoid grinding because you have mobility problem (wheelchair, etc), and even then, I would probably use the roughest diamond hone I could find.

3) And as I said above, if I am going to finish with a light scraping (Shear or negative rake) followed by a thorough sanding routine, why would I bother honing my gouge unless all I want to do is bragg that "I can start sanding with 150". I usually use either scraping method to take the final tool marks out of the wood, and even then may start sanding with 60 grit if I want to minutely fair a curve. I find it less dangerous when the bowl is already thin. The only thing that matters is what the surface looks like when I apply the finish. I think my sanded surfaces are as good as anyone in the world.

4) Lastly, even a sharp tool can cause problems if you ride the beval too hard. It will look smooth and shiney, but all you have done is brose the wood, and that is really hard to get out.

Mark

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#8

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

TDaniel

>You can adjust your gouge by rotating or by lifting or lowering the handle until you find a point along the nose that will yield corkscrew like curls, For roughing out I find the best point to be the corner but for finishing cuts I move back half way from the tip to the end of the grind. Others who sharpen their gouge to a different profile must present their tool differently. My method works for my grind; others do things differently and that is fine. No matter how we attain it though, the slicing cut will always be the superior cut. It is not a scraping cut nor is it a shear cut.

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#9

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

Russ Fairfield

>Number 3 relates to the geometry of compound angles.

Think of the cutting tool as a inclined plane sliding across the surface of the wood. If the inclined plane approaches the wood perpendicular to the direction of travel, the cutting angle will be that of the plane. When the inclined plane is held at a skewed angle to its direction of travel, the effective cutting angle will be less than that of the inclined plane.

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#10

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

eliot

>Something that no one has mentioned: if you sharpen, say, a skew, on a wheel, then, clearly your are going to get a hollow grind on each side of the edge so that the actual angle that you cut with will be quite acute. When you hone, you will be increasing this angle somewhat. (I am making the distinction between the grinding angle and the sharpening angle.) I learned this from Mike Darlow in Louisville.

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

Keith Tompkins

>Maybe this will help...the image shows my grind, which is swept back at ABOUT a 45 degree angle. I grind it on a home-made fixture, similar to a wolverine, just rolling the tool from side to side does it.

Image "a" shows the tool approaching the turning with the flute 90 degrees away from the wood. Cuts quickly, removes wood well, no chance of a catch. ( well, maybe a small chance)

Image "B" shows the tool rotated so the flute is nearly straight up. This causes the edge to contact the wood at a 45 degree angle, making a cleaner cut. There is much more chance of a catch here. This cut is easy with a straight grind such as this; an Ellsworth grind makes this a very difficult cut to perform.

does it really matter how clean the cut is, since sanding will remove tearout anyway? I think so, because torn grain will become obvious when the finish is applied; the wood fibers have been damaged well below where the piece is sanded. A heavily sanded surface never looks right....consider fine cabinetmakers, who scrape their surfaces rather than sand for the same reason.


img

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#12

Bite me....?

Jerry Hall

>Russ,

I agree 100% with your three principles. But bear with me if I ask what they have to do with a tool "sharpened" to a rough ground edge so that it "bites" during rough out? A sharp tool will always cut better and longer than a less sharp tool. The only issue it seems to me is whether the time to achieve a given sharpness is worth it for the task at hand. If refreshing an edge by honing can be done in a timely manner isn't it is better per your principles.

It seems to me to be a possible rationalization to introduce this undefined concept "bite" as being an improvement over a truely sharp edge. It doesn't square with my flatwork experience. I know as a novice turner I will most likely have to back off, but I need to raise the question.

Sure we can get away in many situations with driving a bowl at 2-3 HP and high speed thru that pitiful, ragged ground gouge edge, but I don't see how that becomes better by calling it "bite." Roughing out a flat piece with a scrub plane or a heavy chisel does not benefit from "bite." Even a cabinet scraper properly used will be honed.

True we can cut or tear (or split?) Why is anything near tearing to be preferred in any situation? Surely not in an endgrain cut. And in most any bowl you will be cutting some endgrain, and repairing the tears if they occur, however deep. I agree hogging out wood doesn't require sharpening to obsessive levels. But again if it is just as fast with a hand hone, or mdf wheel why not get the benefit of a good cut with a longer lasting edge?

Go ahead, bite me....

In good humor,

Jerry

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#13

Bite explained

TDaniel

>Jerry, picture a super sharp handsaw with no teeth....just a blade honed to razor sharpness. It would have no "bite" but would be scary sharp. Put this beside a less sharp handsaw with 9 teeth per inch. Which would cut the fastest? The honed saw would likely cut cleaner but not nearly as fast. The tiny serrations that you have on and edge that is straight off a 100 grit wheel or even a coarser wheel will give the "bite" like that of the handsaw. I do have a Tormek with all the leather wheels for honing but it sits in a corner collecting dust. I even tried a Japanese water stone wheel on the Tormek. I think I have tried about everything and I have found nothing better than just a well balanced 100 grit blue wheel on an 1800 rpm 8" grinder for bowl gouges. The one thing I see wrong more than anything else when people are having trouble with their bowl gouge is that they are sharpening to too steep (acute) a side angle.

TD

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#14

Re: Bite explained

Jerry Hall

>Terry,

Great analogy to explain "bite". Your experience is the bottom line, and is making me think.

What you are describing I guess is the reciprocal of a circular saw. With the lathe the toothed blade is fixed and the work rotates. Here tool presentation matters. It seems you would want to take advantage of as many of those serrations (teeth) as you could before they wear off, and adjust a bit to present different parts of the serrated edge.

I still wonder how long those serrations last. And how this compares to the analogy of a sculptor hogging out big thick curls of wood with a heavy gouge, sharp. Of course a major function of saw teeth is to clear out the wood and make a guided path for continued cutting. It produces "saw" dust. It is not cutting and wedging out large curls of wood as we do.

But I believe in your experience. And a rotating vise holding wood is a different situation than fixed work. I think on my next bowl I am going to try a little hand turning with the two cases and see if I can feel a difference so I can reconcile my intuition with new experience. I am still hung up on the sculptor analogy.

Thanks for your discussion leadership! It's of real value.

Jerry

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#15

Yes, use the whole tool

TDaniel

>Yes Jerry, you do want to use the entire end of the tool when practical before re-sharpening; you can't always do this but sometimes you can. The tiny teeth do wear away pretty quickly, especially if you grind to an acute angle on the side grind. Nothing beats experimentation though so try it all....I do. You go to shows and someone there says if you hone your tools they will last longer, someone else says they will cut better if sharpened on a 36 grit wheel, someone else swears by the 120 grit wheel.....we each have our opinions. I just say try several and see what works for you. For me the honing of a bowl gouge is a total waste of my time.

Re: How sharp is "sharp"??

#16

Re: Just My Opinion - Not CET

Mkauder, Phenix City, AL

>When I posted this on Wednesday, I said "I usually use either scraping method to take the final tool marks out of the wood, and even then may start sanding with 60 grit if I want to minutely fair a curve."

Wally emailed me about it, and I realized that had I proof read it for content, I might have seen that I was not making myself clear. What I meant was:

"I usually use either scraping method to take the final tool marks out of the wood, and but if I start sanding, and finde that the curve is not fair, I will fix it, maybe even may start sanding that part with 60 grit."

Sorry for the confusion.

Mark