Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

edge retention

Posts

edge retention

#1

edge retention

TDaniel

>I have followed the thread about the new tool companies offering blades that hold their edge longer. In my experience, those who are having problems with edge retention are sharpening to a keener edge than necessary and this results in an edge that won't last. If you can add just a few degrees to the angle that you are sharpening to, then the edge will last a lot longer. Another thing that will contribute to a longer lasting edge is keeping the gouge (or whatever) slicing instead of shearing. Keep making those "corkscrew curls" and your edge will last a lot longer. Save the big bucks and get a long lasting edge the easy way.

TD

Re: edge retention

#2

Re: edge retention

Merv Graham Richmond BC Can

>I thought slicing and shearing were the same thing do you mean scraping????

Re: edge retention

#3

no

TDaniel

>slicing and shearing are not the same. Picture a handplane pushed staight ahead, that is shearing. Now picture a handplane pushed straight ahead while the body is at a 30 degree angle; that is slicing. The curl that is produced when slicing will look like a corkscrew, the curl produced when shearing will look like an old clock spring. There is a world of difference in the cut.

Re: edge retention

#4

Re: edge retention

Jerry Hall

>Terry,

It appears from tests measuring the volume of wood for a given distance of turning hard and soft woods reported by Lyn Mangiameli that "18 minutes of continuous turning in softwood, the well ground tool was still cutting more than three-and-a-half times faster than the dry ground tool.�

I have found it worth reflecting on his carefully thought out article:

http://www.fholder.com/Woodturning/sharpen.pdf

His analysis is surely true for flat work, and I found it to be true also for turning. Even more so because of the larger volume of wood cut. It doesn't seem to matter how you get a keen (sharp) edge, wet grind or honing. Lacer hones, others use Tormak, some use homemade buffing wheels. For me honing as Lacer does is faster and much cheaper.

I am coming to believe that it is an unsubstantiated myth that it doesn't pay turners to hone or really sharpen a tool. It may be a rationalization to avoid building honing skills. Honing sure saves steel and can save lots of time! It is perhaps easier for me because of my flat work experience. For turners it may not be obvious since a dry ground tool seems to do the job, and without weighing the chips and measuring your time the difference is not apparent.

Just a point of view from a fairly new turner.

Jerry Hall

Re: edge retention

#5

Jerry, the statement made was not honing....

TDaniel

>a keen edge and a honed edge are two different things. The amount of metal supporting the edge is what is important. The more acute the angle of the edge the quicker it will wear (or roll) away. How we sharpen affects the life of the edge just as much as the edge holding ability of the steel; maybe even more. Honing can also lengthen the edge holding ability but may reduce the "bite" of the tool. Lynn explained the "bite" of an edge in one of his posts.

TD

Re: edge retention

#6

Keen vs. Sharp

Jerry Hall

>Terry, I see your distinction. I guess you grind to a cutting angle that is more or less "keen" , and hone to a "sharp" edge. I jumped on the term "sharpening" in your post without reading the rest of the post carefully. Thanks. Jerry

Re: edge retention

#7

Re: Keen vs. Sharp

John Lucas

>I'm confused. When you hone an edge you aren't changing the sharpening angle (unless you produce a micro bevel) you are simply reducing the size of the scratches in the metal so it cuts cleaner. This is totally different than changing the sharpening angle which I think is what TD is talking about.

I think what TD is talking about is the difference between how you would sharpen an ax vs how you would sharpen a knife. An Ax may be sharpened at 45 degrees and a knife blade at 25. An ax will hold an edge(blunt as it is) much longer than the knife if you chop at wood in the same way. If you reduce the size down the the wings on your bowl gouge, you can sharpen the wings at different angles to produce the same affect as the knife and ax.

I have one gouge that has very sharp long wings. This is for doing pull cuts in my hand mirrors which often have problems woods. It will usually cut very clean this way. My usual bowl gouge has the wings sharpened a little thicker. This one holds up much better when roughing bowls.

Re: edge retention

#8

pretty much correct

TDaniel

>John, you are mostly correct. The one possible exception is that the honed edge does not guarantee a smoother cut though sometimes it will. The thicker edge will last longer. Sometimes the honed edge will cut better but there are times that an edge with bite will cut better. It is like a serrated edge steak knife or a bread cutting blade. Sometimes the edge as it comes off a 36 grit wheel will cut better and faster than a honed edge. I like an edge off a 100 grit wheel as a good all around compromise. Much depends on tool presentation as well as the wood and how the wood was cut into a turning blank. One size does not fit all.

TD

Re: edge retention

#9

Keith Tompkins

Re: edge retention

Keith Tompkins

>Hi Jerry , one must distinguish between bowl turning and spindle turning....most bowl turners do not hone, while all veteran spindle turners hone their edges.

the skew chisel especially benefits from proper honing...it will not work correctly without honing. I hone all my spindle tools, but seldom my bowl gouges.

Most bowl turners do not hone, because the amount of wood being removed makes a quick trip to the grinder more practical, if not more durable. In special cases, such as twisted grain that tends to tear out, I hone my bowl gouges. As you know, an occasional hollow grinding of your tools makes honing easier and faster as well.

Re: edge retention

#10

Bowl Gouge Honing?

Jerry Hall

>Keith,

Thanks for your sorting out honing applications. It is helpful. I do have the following novice, but persistent, thoughts: I find it to be faster to reach in my apron pocket, grab my diamond hone, sweep the hollow grind on front, a lick and a promise on the flute and hardly move from my lathe. I'm good for two or three such touchups before hitting the grinder. I work (practice!) with a lot of black oak. It sure is nice to have every cut be a sweet one with a honed edge in that sometimes difficult, but readily available wood. I feel I learn tool control faster with an always truely sharp tool. I'm not as inclined to procrastinate sharpening. Sometimes it seems that some bowl gouges are "sharpened" more as fine texturing tools rather than a cutting tool, and then followed with a lot of scraper and shear touch up work! Does this make any sense?

Jerry

Re: edge retention

#11

Re: Bowl Gouge Honing?

john lucas

>Jerry One thing I see is pushing the gouge too fast. This produces little tiny spiral lines that look like a texture from a bit that isn't sharpened properly. Simply slow down the cut. Fast cutting is desireable when roughing out the shape. it's the final cuts that need to be controlled, and ideally with a freshly sharpened tool.

Re: edge retention

#12

Ripples?

TDaniel

>Hmmmm. I can show how to eliminate these but I cannot tell how. If you sharpen your gouge like mine and use it like I do you will not have these. Consider the gouge as being identical to a jackplane; the sole of the plane is the same as the heel of the gouge, etc. If you have metal before and aft of the contact point of the edge you will not have ripples; if you cut with the tip you will get ripples. This is pretty easy to teach in person but very difficult to put into words.

TD

Re: edge retention

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl Gouge Honing?

Keith Tompkins

>Jerry, sounds to me like the hone works well for you. A couple of thoughts concerning sharpening that I have noticed:

1. Many turners, including some with a bit of experience, have trouble sharpening their tools. Big facets along the grind, and angles that vary do not give predictable results. A tool that seems to cut well one minute is hard to contol the next, resulting in catches. There are turners who insist on grinding by eye, and insist on teaching new turners to grind that way...I say use a jig. Seriously, once my jig is set up, I place the handle in the jig, rotate the tool one time against the wheel, and I'm done. Many times the grinder hasn't come to a stop before I need to resharpen. My favorite bowl gouge is over eight year old, and is about 1/2" shorter than a new one. An Ellsworth grind takes a bit longer to grind, but not much.

You probably are skilled at grinding and sharpening anyway by the sounds of it.

Terry is correct on how the tool approaches the wood. A slicing cut, although a bit more prone to a catch, will give the best results especially on the last pass. MY secret weapon is a razor sharp continental-style spindle gouge making the final cut in a slicing mode. End grain looks like glass when done this way.

Re: edge retention

#14

Re: Bowl Gouge Honing?

Jerry Hall

>Terry, Keith, John,

Great observations and advice which I am taking in hand tomorrow morning with some great green oak crotch pieces I picked up today by chance just across my street! Thanks for your help and discussion. Will I ever have time for flat work again?

Jerry

Re: edge retention

#15

Re: no

Dinyar Chavda

>Terry:

For those of us who never were flatlanders, could you translate what you said int o the world of turning, specifally bowl and hollow form turning. I'm not sure how these two cuts look like in practice.

Thanks

D

Re: edge retention

#16

Re: no

John Lucas

>Dinyar I don't necessarily agree with the terminology but understand what TD is saying. pushing the plane straight forward gives one cut (with a block plane for example the blade is 25 degrees. If you skew the plane sideways you are in effect lowering the cutting angle. This is like driving straight up a ramp vs driving sideways off the ramp. You have lowered the cutting angle.

If you held a bowl gouge so the wood was coming 90 degrees toward the side grind you get the first ramp. If you lower the handle so the wood is hitting the side grind at say 45 degrees you are getting a more shear cut and a cleaner cut because the angle is lower.

If you do a push cut with the tip of the wood coming across the cutting edge at this same 45 degree angle you get the same cut, just as clean.

Re: edge retention

#17

the answer is in the chips (curls)

TDaniel

>Dinyar, if your cutting edge is 90 degrees to the work you are shearing, the same cut that you use when shaving. If you angle the cutting edge to 45 degrees then you are slicing, (don't do this with your razor or you will cut yourself badly). A slicing cut is easier on the cutting edge and the wood fibres. I always watch my chips (curls) and always maintain spiral, corkscrew shaped curls, even when roughing out. As far as the push cut and the pull cut go, these are the same cut as far as the gouge knows....the only difference is whether you stand on the left side or the right side of the gouge and whether you like the taste of wood chips or not. The gouge will be in the same position either way, you are merely stepping out of "the line of fire" and the path of the debris coming from the tool. I get flack constantly on this but I have never failed to prove this point.

TD

Re: edge retention

#18

Re: Bowl Gouge Honing?

George Van

>Keith, forged gouge works for me also. I was taught by a turner in the UP to use the forged spindle gouge when problems arise. I use the Henry Taylor forged HSS gouge. I use it as F. Pain teaches in his book, skewed and producing fine curls with light cuts.

Re: edge retention

#19

Re: the answer is in the chips (curls)

Dinyar Chavda

>TD & John:

I want to make sure I understand what you are saying, so let me put it in terms that I can understand re the 45 degree angle. You're right in that this would be a lot eeasier to explain in person.

There are three angles at which the gouge touches the wood. The first is controlled by twisting the wrist, and affects how close the non-cutting edge comes to the wood. The second is affected by how much you raise or lower your elbow, i.e., whether your elbow is in line with the cutting edge, or whether it is below the cutting edge. The third is the one between the wood (if it were a cylinder) and the direction in which the gouge is movingacross the cylinder.

I hope that is clearer than mud!

Now, which of these defines the shearing vs the slicing cut?

D

Re: edge retention

#20

Re: the answer is in the chips (curls)

Allen Neighbors

>You proved it to me, TD, at your place in April. First time you demoed, you showed the pull cut (eating shavings) and the push cut (covering up someone sitting close by) and it really hit home with me. I'm one that got it. :o)

Now, if I could only learn how to push cut, from inside to outside, when hollowing a bowl with the tailstock in place.....

Allen

Re: edge retention

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Bowl Gouge Honing?

Keith Tompkins

>HI George....works good, huh? :)