footed hollow form with finial
Dennis Yoder
>Redwood burl and blackwood foot and finial. 6" tall with 2x3" hollowform. Thanks for looking comments welcome. Dennis Y
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
footed hollow form with finial
Dennis Yoder
>Redwood burl and blackwood foot and finial. 6" tall with 2x3" hollowform. Thanks for looking comments welcome. Dennis Y
Re: footed hollow form with finial
Carole Valentine
>Hi Dennis,
The photo looks like it is overexposed so we can't see the piece too clearly but as I recall, Redwood Burl is a beautiful wood. Looks like you put a lot of work into that base and finial! Couple of comments though, since you asked: the main form is a little flat. I had a couple like that and the folks at the Gathering (David, Molly, Mark and Jen) told me they looked like hockey pucks and by golly they were right! LOL Try more of a curve from the shoulder to the base. Don't be afraid to do away with some wood for the sake of form. My other comment would be to reduce the number of details on both the finial and the base and reduce the overall size, height and width, of the base stem. It also looks like the collar needs to be undercut to fit flush with the top of the vessel. Just my two cents which is not worth much. :)
Re: footed hollow form with finial
ken chase
>I recently did a piece like this without the foot. Now I'm thinking of going back to it and adding one. I like yours so much. Beautiful!
Re: footed hollow form with finial
Keith Tompkins
>Hi Dennis, I am assuming that you welcome any critiques as well as comments. Lots of good stuff happening here, your choice of woods really compliment each other, and your overall proportions are quite good.
Looking at the redwood form, I come to the conclusion that you focused more on utilizing as much of the burl as possible rather than on creating a pleasing shape. If one was to draw a horizontal line through the form, it is very symetrical; the top and bottom are nearly identical. I would suggest making a few practice sketches to see the difference just a bit of tweaking can do....it won't take much to create a sense of "lift" in your form. Don't be afraid of removing wood where it needs to be removed. I can give a few examples if you wish.
The finial and foot are well balanced, but I would suggest a couple of minor changes..... The bead in the center of the finial seems to be overwhelmed by the decorations around it. I would consider making the bead the prominent detail by reducing the diameter of the details above and below the bead.
Classical spindle turning (including finials) demands the use of beads and coves. I think the use of these will soften the sharp changes in your finial, and will fit better with the shape of the redwood form while reducing the "busy" appearance. A long, flowing cove, from the outer diameter of the lid to the finial would tie the finial to the form as well; uniting them. As it is, the lid and finial seem to sit atop the form, rather than being a part of it.
The pedestal would benefit from the use of beads and coves as well; a cove that matches a cove in the lid would unite the overall effect as well, and would serve to lighten things up a bit. I would enlarge the foot as it does't appear to be big enough to support the form.
Cindy Drozda is the master of this type of form, I would suggest studying her work, especially her use of some of the details I mention here, beads and coves...she also has an excellent article in a past aaw magazine.
I hope you don't take this as a critcism of your work, as it is quite nice as is. Keith
Re: footed hollow form with finial
Dennis Yoder
>Keith, I do not take offense to your comments. This is why I post a few of my works. I would appreciate some of your ideas in sketch form. I didn't think I was trying to save wood but to be symetrical. Since both you and Carole pointed this out I will definately rethink the form.
Carole, Thanks for your comments also. I regard your opinion highly.
Re: Keith, I understand
Allen Neighbors
>your comments to Dennis, and don't disagree. My question is, how can you take a finished form, and put it back on the lathe and turn it again, unless you have a vacuum chuck?
I have several pieces that I wish I had done a certain thing to change the form, and would still try it, if I only knew how.
Allen
Re: footed hollow form with finial
Barry Turner
>I'm certainly not an expert on finials or hollow forms, but I will offer a couple of comments. The finial, and especially the foot, look a bit "busy" and maybe a bit too angular. The base or foot appears a bit too small for the piece. It looks as if it might tip easily.
I would probably simplify the details a bit and maybe lean towards the classic shapes of bead, cove, fillet and ogee. Sometimes, less is more. Where the finial meets the globe, I think I may see some daylight. Undercutting the bottom of the finial where it mates to the globe will help the fit be tighter, but it could just be the photo.
With that said, its a very nice piece. I love redwood lace burl. It turns beautifully. Finials are difficult to do well. They are just so danged small and if the details aren't impeccably shaped, it really shows. Larger items are much more forgiving.
Re: footed hollow form with finial
Keith Tompkins
>Hi Dennis, Here is a quick free-hand sketch which I did over your image. Notice that I drew a line through the form. The line is the new emphasis point; instead of being right on center, it is now raised up a bit. The hollow form seems to have more "life" to it.
I kept the same proportions overall as your finished piece, this shows how well proportioned your piece indeed is. I enlarged the foot a bit, simplified the base, and matched the curve to the base of the finial. I think it simplifies things a bit, and gives a feeling of lightness. I made the bead in the finial a bit larger, and made it less uniform as well. Reducing the size of the element above the bead really makes the bead stand out. I enlarged the tip of the finial, following through on the same theme.
Notice in the pedestal how a cove and bead,separated by "filets" work well together,and carries the same theme. It is asymetrical as well. These are not "my" designs, I simply borrowed some classic bead and cove shapes which are commonly seen on antique spindle turnings. I hope this helps.....what do you think?
Re: Keith, I understand
Keith Tompkins
>Hi Allen, Sometimes a piece is what it is. Instead of attempting to remount it, study it. Make a sketch of it.....then, modify your sketch, trying to visualize what may work to improve the piece. This way, the early turning inspires the next, and you begin to refine your design skills.
That's what I did with Dennis's piece, and what I do with my work, and encourage students to do. I think it's a great way to improve one's work without constantly attempting to "fix" your pieces.
We all have early work we are not proud of!
Re: Keith, I understand
Allen Neighbors
>Thanks, Keith. I saw your last post to Dennis, and do understand, now.
Allen
Tomorrow Night's Chat
Stuart Johnson
>This photo along side the orginal would be a great addition to tomorrow night's finial chat session.
Re: footed hollow form with finial
Dennis Yoder
>Thanks Keith. I printed out both pixs and will hang them behind the lathe and will ponder and ponder (takes me a long time for something to sink in) as I make my mext piece. I appreciate the time you took to point me in the right direction. Dennis Y
Re: Tomorrow Night's Chat
Dennis Yoder
>Stuart, If I knew how to post them I would be happy to have them used. Please feel free to post them and use for discussion. I will try to remember to be at the chat on Wed. never turn down help or advise, you may not use it right away but someday the light bulb in the head to finally glow and ideas will flow. Dennis Y
Simple *LINK*
Ron in Drums PA
>
click here
Re: Simple
Stuart Johnson
>Ron, I just sent you copies of both Dennis and Keith's photos.