Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

Posts

Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

#1

Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

NA330

>In the market for my last lathe. Which would you coose? Why?

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

#2

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436 *LINK*

Ed Moore

>I found myself in that position recently and my decision was to get a Robust 25 x 28 with Tilt-Away, which will arrive in late September. If my primary work was furniture parts, then I would have looked more closely at the Pinnacle in Louisville.

My second choice was the Vicmarc 300. That said, I think you also get an excellent lathe if you choose the Oneway or the Stubby. The Robust had the features I wanted and it does them very well, so for me the choice was an easy one. Think about the kind of turning you want to do and go with the lathe that suits that choice the best. I am concerned about lifting the tailstock, so I checked out the Tilt-Away feature of the Robust at Louisville very carefully. It is a great feature.

Ed


ROBUST lathes

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

#3

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

Bill Hale / Woodspinner

>Considering the investment amount and that you want it to be your last lathe, I would say to try them all if you can.

I would post a request here to have anyone in your area let you use their lathe for a little while. You know this group is great for offering help.

I turn on a Oneway 2436 ac variable 3 hp and a Vic 200 dc variable 1 1/2 hp. Both are great but the Oneway is by far the best.

Buy the best you can afford you will never regret paying for quality.

Good turning and be safe

Bill in Dolores, Colorado

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

#4

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

Merv Graham Richmond BC Can

>I have turned on the Oneway and the Vicmarc Both are great lathes but if I ever get the dollars I am heading for the Oneway store for the best my money can buy. To me the bigger the better!

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

#5

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

Fog Tanner

>I went through the same thing. I handled a number of the lathes and ruled out the Chinese made for a number of reason. I narrowed the choice between a Vic 300 and Oneway. I went with the Vic 300 longbed and have not regretted the choice.

Of course part of your decision will include what you want to do. If you are strictly bowls, then a Stubby or VB36 would be the top of the line. The Vic and Oneway are spindle machines which can turn bowls. The Stubby is a bowl machine which can turn spindles. I do both, which is one reason for the long bed Vic.

Another thing that was of help to me, I contacted a number of the professional turners I have met and asked what they use and their opinion of the lathes I had in mind. I found there is no perfect lathe and their is no single lathe which is the best - regardless of advertising claims. I did get a number of answers as to good, the bad, and the ugly. I also decided, that if they can trust the machine to make a living, then it will certainly last me for what time I have left on this rock....

Just my two cents worth, and air is still free..

Fog

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

#6

Re: Pinnacle VS Oneway 2436

Jim Swank

>Money not being a major issue, and no overriding factors pointing you in another direction, go OneWay. The merits of different brands from a performance standpoint have been debated ad nauseum in forums beyond count. All have their own merits, but no one I've seen has complaints about the OneWays. Odds are, "OneWay" or the other, the lathe will eventually be up for sale, and I doubt anybody will argue the resale value of the Oneway.