Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Posts

Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#1

Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Jake Niedling

>I was turning a small 7" dia. walnut bowl today and when I went to clean up the outside of the bowl, I noticed I would only get a clean cut surface in one direction and not the other. I have shear scraped many items and direction never seemed to matter. I use a high angle about 45 degrees with the tool rolled almost completely over. The rest of ya'll seen this or have comments?

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#2

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Carole Valentine

>Direction definitely makes a difference. Go with the grain.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#3

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

john lucas

>Jake Sometimes I get a stubborn piece of wood that simply has to be cut in the opposite direction. On really curly woods you may find that either direction gives you some minor tearout in one are or another. Go with the direction that gives the least. some woods just won't shear scrap. I turned some really dry box elder today that looked really nasty when shear scraping. I turned it as best I could and then just went to sanding. The tool marks were easier to sand out than the minor tear out created by the shear scraping.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#4

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Barry Turner

>On dry Box Elder, I find that a 60-grit scraper works very well.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#5

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

john lucas

>Barry I have a full selection of those scrapers from 24 to 1500. I believe in having the right tool for the job. :)

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#6

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Arch

>For repairing torn grain or just for a fine finish you might want to try using cabinet scrapers instead of turning tools for both shear and lag scraping. I find sets of straight and curved cabinet scrapers an inexpensive and useful adjunct to traditional shear scraping. Trailed along the grain at a 'sweet angle', they can go where turning tools can't and are very forgiving.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#7

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

John Lucas

>Arch I find that card scrapers are the best tools for leveling surfaces where you have repaired a small defect with CA or epoxy. It's also excellent for leveling knots that have warped a little while drying.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#8

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Dave Belser

>Arch, are you doing this with the lathe running? If so what speed? I have cab. scrapers and think they are great for flat stuff and touch ups but I've never tried them on a running lathe.

I have to admit that I'm still squeamish about touching spinning wood with anything other than gouge, sandpaper or pencil. Calipers on a spindle for example, I just can't get the image of arms stuck in the spindle whipping around and whacking my hand... Mind you I've never seen this happen and I have seen many demos where a turner uses calipers in one hand gouge in the other. I need to work on this phobia.

- Dave

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#9

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

eliot

>Jake,

Are you shear scraping with your gauge or with a separate tool? If with a separate tool, are you using the burr right off the wheel, or do you hone the burr off and raise a new burr with a burnisher? I'll bet if you burnish a new burr, you will find that your shear scraping goes much better. Those suggesting that you use a cabinet scraper are, in fact, suggesting such an approach -- except that holding a sharp cabinet scraper by hand is a dangerous way to go. How do you burnish the end of a small scraping tool? Get one of those Veritas burnishing fixtures (or make one -- it's just two upright hard metal "dowels".) Better still, buy one from Don Derry.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#10

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

John Lucas

>Dave I have only use the card scraper on wood with the lathe off. However I watched Clay Foster use a card scraper on green wood with the lathe running, really slow. He said it doesn't work well on dry wood with the lathe running. The card scraper gets too hot. I find they are really handy for removing chatter marks. You know the marks you get when the wood is flexing and even the lightest cut still produces them. If you try to sand them out you can create sanding ridges from the summer/winter wood. You can take a card scraper and level the surface and then go on to sandpaper.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#11

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Dave Belser

>John,

That's about what I expected it would go like. I often use cab scrapers on stationary wood, and find them extremely useful. They can save a lot of sanding time and do things you can't do with sanding.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#12

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Merv Graham Richmond BC Can

>One of the problens with turning that causes tearout is people attempt to cut unsupported fiber. Make sure where ever possible you are cutting in a direction that the fiber is supported

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#13

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Arch

>Dave, I use cab. scrapers both with the lathe running slowly and with it off. I defer to Eliot's caution, but holding the scraper freehand and scraping with a short section of the the burr lagging well below center hasn't seemed particularlyl risky in the scale of woodturning's dangers.

There is always that dreaded first time, however.

Probably my poor technique, but when I plane N.I.pine with a skew, I sometimes get ugly burnish marks that are easier to remove with a cab. scraper than with a shear scraper or sand paper.

Nothing new, but a reminder that discarded small engine valve stems (free at garden supply shops) make good burnishing rods for cab. scrapers. Be careful about grinding off the seating part. Some stems are sodium filled.

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#14

I had unsupported fibre for breakfast :)

John Lucas

>

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#15

Steven Antonucci

I hope you don't get any "tearout" from it :-)

steve antonucci

>

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

#16

Re: Shear Scraping -Right or Left

Jake Niedling

>Well that was sure entertaining post. Thanks for all the comments. I got the job done with problems. I always use the long side of my freshly sharpen bowl gouge for shear scraping. I keep it simple and it gets the job done. Thanks for all the comments.