Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

HF Question

Posts

HF Question

#1

HF Question

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>Having just started in hollowforms, I have one question. Do you normally take a wet piece of wood and go directly to the finished product, or turn it rough and let it dry before the final turning? I've tried a couple of small ones by rough turning and drying using the DNA method, but they both cracked around the opening. It seems to me that if I went directly from wet wood to finished product, I would have the same problem. Does anyone have any suggestions? Thanks.

Scott

Re: HF Question

#2

Re: HF Question

Allen Neighbors

>Scott, my results when I first began are the same as yours. I've found through this forum, and hook & crook, that there are some different ways to get better results with green wood.

One, you can turn green wood to finish thickness, and let it do what it wants to do, and that's 'warp'.

Two, you can turn to rough finish, and then soak... I use a soap solution. Then after drying, turn to finish.

If you first turn to finish thickness, you'll have better results if you make sure that the bottom is the same thickness, or a little thinner than the rest. The wood is trying to reach Equalization Moisture Content (EMC) and if the bottom is thicker than the top, it will be more likely to crack.

I am not an expert. I am a novice. What I have said is my experience, limited as it is. I am sure that someone else will chime in here and give some more advice that we both might learn from.

Hope this helps a little.

Allen

Re: HF Question

#3

Re: HF Question

john lucas

>Scott Wood selection, where you cut it from the log and how thick you leave it are the important issues. We would need to know more about your log and how you turned it to figure out the problem. I do both methods, that is rough turn, let dry and return, and finish in one session. I don't use any of the soaking, boiling, wear garlic around my neck or vodoo. I simply turn them and let them dry naturally.

For rough turnings that are going to be carved I leave them a little thicker, maybe 1/2 to 3/4" and I put them in a box with the lid closed but not sealed. These will sit this way for a month or more then I'll pull them out and put them on the bottom shelf or floor. I also do this for woods that I have had problems with, like cherry.

If I am going to finish turn a piece I usually turn them down to about 1/4" to 3/8". Sand and apply some sanding sealer and then let them dry on the shelf for a few days. For woods that really move like Apple I turn thinner but still just let it dry on the shelf where there's not much air movement.

Where you cut the wood from the log can make a difference. If you left the heart or a limb section with pith near the lip it will crack almost everytime. I had a piece start to crack on me yesterday. It was a much older piece of maple and it started to come apart at one of the annular rings. Sometimes that just happens. I try not to leave the pith in the piece but if I do I turn it thin. For hollow forms with the pith I will mount it so the pith runs through the middle. That way it will be removed when I hollow all except the bottom. I will drill this out when I reverse turn the piece. when it's dry I will true up the hole and plug it with a piece I cut from the original log.

Re: HF Question

#4

Re: HF Question

Jennifer@Indy.USA

>Scott, I seem to have the best of luck going pretty much start to finish. That is, I'll hollow to get the sides and bottom pretty much complete. Almost to the point of parting it off...where I can leave it in the chuck without the worry of it cracking apart. I do this only if I'm going to attempt to burn or carve on it. I like to leave them in the chuck or at least with a tennon so I can rechuck it in case I screw it up in the "enhancing" process. There are the ocasional ones that are so wet when I start that I don't want to take the chance and I will dunk it in the DNA. If you are going to do it this way....you'll need to leave more around the opening. This is usually the portion that we cut the thinnest while roughing. At least me anyway. Don't fret over the ones that do crack and go bad. It's bound to happen. Hey....thankfully this stuff grows on trees!

Jen :)

Re: HF Question

#5

Re: HF Question

Barry Irby

>Scott, I'm not an expert, but I have done about two dozen HFs over a number of years. Mine are usually less than 6" in diamter and less than 9" tall. I turn them green and put the tailstock into the pith in on end and the drive center into it in the other and rough the blank and cut the tenon. This way the pith is hollowed out except for the bottom as mentioned above. I don't drill mine out, I turn a distinct dome in the bottom similar to the bottom of an aluminm soda can. I turn from green to finish as quickly as I can, usually in one day. If I leave it even for a few minutes, I bag it in a plastic bag right on the lathe. (I left one on the lathe for two or three days once and had wrapped it and the chuck very tightly. A mistake. The chuck rusted and so did the inside of the shaft of the lathe.)

I ahve had only one failure. It was one I tried to turn to a point on the bottom and made a support for it. A turned ring with three legs. The form sat there for a while and split in half top to bottom. I think the bottom was too thick.

I try to turn them to 3/16 or an 1/8" wall thickness. Thinner near the bottom.

Re: HF Question

#6

Re: HF Question

john lucas

>Barry I didn't get into shapes this morning but a cone shape or concave or convex shape will be less likely to crack. For example if you cut the end off a log so it is perfectly flat with the pith in the middle, it will always crack. If you made a cone shape the same thickness with the pith being the bottom (not pointy but very rounded) it will be less likely to crack. The reason is when the wood starts to shrink it can elongate and warp when it's this shape. Making your bottoms concave and relatively thin will accomplish the same thing.

Can't stress enough to not leave a piece without wrapping it. I went in the house to go the bathroom one time and came out and the piece was starting to crack. Seems the sun was coming through the window and hitting it. I always wrap in plastic when I stop to eat or quit for the night.

If it is a wood with lots or tanins, Oak, ash etc I never leave it in the chuck. I did once, spent a whole afternoon cleaning the chuck up. I try my best to get to a stopping point where I can remove it safely from the chuck and then rechuck the next day. In this case faceplates are much better. Not only do you get a better hold and less vibration, if you leave the piece on the faceplate and rust it they are very quick and easy to clean up because they don't have all those nasty sticky outy grap your fingers jaws.

Re: HF Question

#7

Thanks for the swift replies!

Scott Hurley in N. VA

>

Re: HF Question

#8

Re: HF Question

John Jordan

>Email me your address and I'll send you something that will help.

John